Hello all,
The notes, recordings and transcripts for the CCWG ACCT Meeting #41, Session 2 – 17 July will be available here: https://community.icann.org/x/CYFCAw
A copy of the notes may be found below.
Thank you.
Kind regards,
Brenda
11:00-12:00 – Stress Test Work Party updates
Relevant documents : Updates stress tests reflecting public comments (please note some late inclusions could be added after the July 15 ST-WP call)
These high-level notes are designed to help you navigate through content of the call and do not substitute in any way the transcript.
Stress Tests Work Party Update
· 26 stress tests were published in the original draft
· 9 new stress tests added based on Public Comment
· 11 comments received directly on the Stress Tests section in Public Comment, + NTIA letter/ Larry Strickling blog, + Board memo with 2 new stress tests (20 June)
Analyzed CCWG discussions, public comments, NTIA letter, Board memo:
· Added 2 stress tests suggested by Chris Disspain involving California courts. pp 25-26
· Edited ST 20 per comment from RySG
· Added 2 stress tests suggested by Post & Kehl. pp.27-28
· Added a stress test on “rogue voting”. p.29
· Added all 4 of the NTIA suggested stress tests. See pages 30 – 33
· NTIA-1: Test preservation of the multistakeholder model if individual ICANN AC/SOs opt out of having votes in community empowerment mechanisms.
· NTIA-2: Address the potential risk of internal capture. ST 12 and 13 partly address capture by external parties, but not for capture by internal parties in an AC/SO.
· NTIA-3: Barriers to entry for new participants.
· NTIA-4: Unintended consequences of “operationalizing” groups that to date have been advisory in nature (e.g. GAC)
· Added two questions from the Board-Legal memo of Jun 20
· Reliance on IRP so need to verify ICANN must agree to binding
Stress tests that are relevant to IANA are outlined on Page 3