I find this quite troubling.


J. Scott Evans
Head of global Brand, Domains & Copyright
Yahoo! Inc.

Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPhone


From: Steve DelBianco <sdelbianco@netchoice.org>;
To: bc - GNSO list <bc-gnso@icann.org>;
Subject: [bc-gnso] regarding Jeff Neuman's motion to amend ICANN Bylaws
Sent: Sat, Jul 13, 2013 12:42:54 PM

Regrading Jeff's motion that we are discussing now:

Here are the ICANN Bylaws  -- with Jeff's amendment in GREEN:

ARTICLE X: GENERIC NAMES SUPPORTING ORGANIZATION

Section 1. DESCRIPTION

There shall be a policy-development body known as the Generic Names Supporting Organization ( GNSO ), which shall be responsible for developing and recommending to the  ICANN  Board substantive policies relating to generic top-level domains. The GNSO is also responsible for providing advice to the ICANN Board on the implementation of policies relating to gTLDs.

[add section requiring a formal consultation process if Board determines to take action not consistent with GNSO advice]

Section 2. ORGANIZATION

The  GNSO  shall consist of:

(i) A number of Constituencies, where applicable, organized within the Stakeholder Groups as described in Section 5 of this Article;

(ii) Four Stakeholder Groups organized within Houses as described inSection 5 of this Article;

(iii) Two Houses within the  GNSO  Council as described in Section 3(8) of this Article; and

(iv) a  GNSO  Council responsible for managing the policy development process of the  GNSO , as described in Section 3 of this Article.

Except as otherwise defined in these Bylaws, the four Stakeholder Groups and the Constituencies will be responsible for defining their own charters with the approval of their members and of the  ICANN  Board of Directors.

Section 3.  GNSO  COUNCIL

1. Subject to the provisions of Transition Article XX, Section 5 of these Bylaws and as described in Section 5 of Article X, the  GNSO  Council shall consist of:

a. three representatives selected from the Registries Stakeholder Group;

b. three representatives selected from the Registrars Stakeholder Group;

c. six representatives selected from the Commercial Stakeholder Group;

d. six representatives selected from the Non-Commercial Stakeholder Group; and

e. three representatives selected by the  ICANN  Nominating Committee, one of which shall be non-voting, but otherwise entitled to participate on equal footing with other members of the  GNSO  Council including, e.g. the making and seconding of motions and of serving as Chair if elected. One Nominating Committee Appointee voting representative shall be assigned to each House (as described in Section 3(8) of this Article) by the Nominating Committee.

No individual representative may hold more than one seat on the  GNSO Council at the same time.

Stakeholder Groups should, in their charters, ensure their representation on the  GNSO  Council is as diverse as possible and practicable, including considerations of geography,  GNSO  Constituency, sector, ability and gender.

There may also be liaisons to the  GNSO  Council from other  ICANN Supporting Organizations and/or Advisory Committees, from time to time. The appointing organization shall designate, revoke, or change its liaison on the  GNSO  Council by providing written notice to the Chair of the  GNSO Council and to the  ICANN  Secretary. Liaisons shall not be members of or entitled to vote, to make or second motions, or to serve as an officer on the GNSO  Council, but otherwise liaisons shall be entitled to participate on equal footing with members of the  GNSO  Council.

2. Subject to the provisions of the Transition Article XX, and Section 5 of these Bylaws, the regular term of each  GNSO  Council member shall begin at the conclusion of an  ICANN  annual meeting and shall end at the conclusion of the second  ICANN  annual meeting thereafter. The regular term of two representatives selected from Stakeholder Groups with three Council seats shall begin in even-numbered years and the regular term of the other representative selected from that Stakeholder Group shall begin in odd-numbered years. The regular term of three representatives selected from Stakeholder Groups with six Council seats shall begin in even-numbered years and the regular term of the other three representatives selected from that Stakeholder Group shall begin in odd-numbered years. The regular term of one of the three members selected by the Nominating Committee shall begin in even-numbered years and the regular term of the other two of the three members selected by the Nominating Committee shall begin in odd-numbered years. Each  GNSO  Council member shall hold office during his or her regular term and until a successor has been selected and qualified or until that member resigns or is removed in accordance with these Bylaws.

Except in a "special circumstance," such as, but not limited to, meeting geographic or other diversity requirements defined in the Stakeholder Group charters, where no alternative representative is available to serve, no Council member may be selected to serve more than two consecutive terms, in such a special circumstance a Council member may serve one additional term. For these purposes, a person selected to fill a vacancy in a term shall not be deemed to have served that term. A former Council member who has served two consecutive terms must remain out of office for one full term prior to serving any subsequent term as Council member. A "special circumstance" is defined in the  GNSO  Operating Procedures.

3. A vacancy on the  GNSO  Council shall be deemed to exist in the case of the death, resignation, or removal of any member. Vacancies shall be filled for the unexpired term by the appropriate Nominating Committee or Stakeholder Group that selected the member holding the position before the vacancy occurred by giving the  GNSO  Secretariat written notice of its selection. Procedures for handling Stakeholder Group-appointed  GNSO Council member vacancies, resignations, and removals are prescribed in the applicable Stakeholder Group Charter.

A  GNSO  Council member selected by the Nominating Committee may be removed for cause: i) stated by a three-fourths (3/4) vote of all members of the applicable House to which the Nominating Committee appointee is assigned; or ii) stated by a three-fourths (3/4) vote of all members of each House in the case of the non-voting Nominating Committee appointee (seeSection 3(8) of this Article). Such removal shall be subject to reversal by the ICANN  Board on appeal by the affected  GNSO  Council member.

4. The  GNSO  Council is responsible for managing the policy development process of the  GNSO . It shall adopt such procedures (the " GNSO Operating Procedures") as it sees fit to carry out that responsibility, provided that such procedures are approved by a majority vote of each House. The  GNSO  Operating Procedures shall be effective upon the expiration of a twenty-one (21) day public comment period, and shall be subject to Board oversight and review. Until any modifications are recommended by the  GNSO  Council, the applicable procedures shall be as set forth in Section 6 of this Article.

5. No more than one officer, director or employee of any particular corporation or other organization (including its subsidiaries and affiliates) shall serve on the  GNSO  Council at any given time.

6. The  GNSO  shall make selections to fill Seats 13 and 14 on the  ICANN Board by written ballot or by action at a meeting. Each of the two voting Houses of the  GNSO , as described in Section 3(8) of this Article, shall make a selection to fill one of two  ICANN  Board seats, as outlined below; any such selection must have affirmative votes compromising sixty percent (60%) of all the respective voting House members:

a. the Contracted Party House shall select a representative to fill Seat 13; and

b. the Non-Contracted Party House shall select a representative to fill Seat 14

Election procedures are defined in the  GNSO  Operating Procedures.

Notification of the Board seat selections shall be given by the  GNSO  Chair in writing to the  ICANN  Secretary, consistent with Article VI, Sections 8(4)and 12(1).

7. The  GNSO  Council shall select the  GNSO  Chair for a term the  GNSO Council specifies, but not longer than one year. Each House (as described in Section 3.8 of this Article) shall select a Vice-Chair, who will be a Vice-Chair of the whole of the  GNSO  Council, for a term the  GNSO  Council specifies, but not longer than one year. The procedures for selecting the Chair and any other officers are contained in the  GNSO  Operating Procedures. In the event that the  GNSO  Council has not elected a  GNSO Chair by the end of the previous Chair's term, the Vice-Chairs will serve as Interim  GNSO  Co-Chairs until a successful election can be held.

8. Except as otherwise required in these Bylaws, for voting purposes, the GNSO  Council (see Section 3(1) of this Article) shall be organized into a bicameral House structure as described below:

a. the Contracted Parties House includes the Registries Stakeholder Group (three members), the Registrars Stakeholder Group (three members), and one voting member appointed by the  ICANN  Nominating Committee for a total of seven voting members; and

b. the Non Contracted Parties House includes the Commercial Stakeholder Group (six members), the Non-Commercial Stakeholder Group (six members), and one voting member appointed by the  ICANN  Nominating Committee to that House for a total of thirteen voting members.

Except as otherwise specified in these Bylaws, each member of a voting House is entitled to cast one vote in each separate matter before the  GNSO Council.

9. Except as otherwise specified in these Bylaws, Annex A hereto, or the GNSO  Operating Procedures, the default threshold to pass a  GNSO Council motion or other voting action requires a simple majority vote of each House. The voting thresholds described below shall apply to the following  GNSO  actions:

a. Create an Issues Report: requires an affirmative vote of more than one-fourth (1/4) vote of each House or majority of one House.

b. Initiate a Policy Development Process (" PDP ") Within Scope (as described in Annex A): requires an affirmative vote of more than one-third (1/3) of each House or more than two-thirds (2/3) of one House.

c. Initiate a  PDP  Not Within Scope: requires an affirmative vote of  GNSO  Supermajority.

d. Approve a  PDP  Team Charter for a  PDP  Within Scope: requires an affirmative vote of more than one-third (1/3) of each House or more than two-thirds (2/3) of one House.

e. Approve a  PDP  Team Charter for a  PDP  Not Within Scope: requires an affirmative vote of a  GNSO Supermajority.

f. Changes to an Approved  PDP  Team Charter: For any PDP  Team Charter approved under d. or e. above, the GNSO  Council may approve an amendment to the Charter through a simple majority vote of each House.

g. Terminate a  PDP : Once initiated, and prior to the publication of a Final Report, the  GNSO  Council may terminate a  PDP  only for significant cause, upon a motion that passes with a  GNSO  Supermajority Vote in favor of termination.

h. Approve a  PDP  Recommendation Without a  GNSO Supermajority: requires an affirmative vote of a majority of each House and further requires that one  GNSO  Council member representative of at least 3 of the 4 Stakeholder Groups supports the Recommendation.

i. Approve a  PDP  Recommendation With a  GNSO Supermajority: requires an affirmative vote of a  GNSO Supermajority,

j. Approve a  PDP  Recommendation Imposing New Obligations on Certain Contracting Parties: where an ICANN  contract provision specifies that "a two-thirds vote of the council" demonstrates the presence of a consensus, the GNSO  Supermajority vote threshold will have to be met or exceeded.

k. Modification of Approved  PDP  Recommendation: Prior to Final Approval by the  ICANN  Board, an Approved  PDP Recommendation may be modified or amended by the GNSO  Council with a  GNSO  Supermajority vote.

l. A " GNSO  Supermajority" shall mean: (a) two-thirds (2/3) of the Council members of each House, or (b) three-fourths (3/4) of one House and a majority of the other House."