Thank you very much for your suggestions, comments and contributions on this matter.
The edition of the response to Roelof's email was finalized today at 14:00 UTC and unless there is any major concern, I will send the final text tomorrow at 14:00 UTC.
Best regards,
Alejandra
-----
Final text:
Dear Roelof
First of all thank you for your email in response to the Council Statement.
With respect to your questions, let me start with the general observation that the need to treat all ccTLD Managers equally and impartially is fundamental. By definition, membership in the ccNSO is open to all ccTLD Managers listed in the IANA Root Zone Database. This follows the basic policies for ccTLDs, specifically RFC1591 as interpreted through the Framework of Interpretation. This foundational principle of the ccNSO was recently (2 March 2022) confirmed with the proposed Bylaw change to include IDN ccTLDs in the ccNSO. Membership in the ccNSO ends automatically after a transfer or removal from the IANA database. As ccNSO we do not have a process to suspend or end a membership, nor did we want it as recently as ICANN 70, when the question was raised explicitly.
Therefore, trust in the ccNSO is about being a trusted partner to all ccTLD Managers, independent of the environment in which they are embedded. It is about living up to our own ccNSO principles and acting predictably even under the worst circumstances and/or sometimes even at the expense of one’s personal views.
To be very clear, the ccNSO Council condemns violence and war to resolve differences, now and in the future, anywhere in the world.
Best regards,
Alejandra Reynoso
On behalf of the ccNSO Council
First of all thank you for your email in response to the Council Statement.
With respect to your questions, let me start with the general observation that the need to treat all ccTLD Managers equally and impartially is fundamental. By definition, membership in the ccNSO is open to all ccTLD Managers listed in the IANA Root Zone Database. This follows the basic policies for ccTLDs, specifically RFC1591 as interpreted through the Framework of Interpretation. This foundational principle of the ccNSO was recently (2 March 2022) confirmed with the proposed Bylaw change to include IDN ccTLDs in the ccNSO. Membership in the ccNSO ends automatically after a transfer or removal from the IANA database. As ccNSO we do not have a process to suspend or end a membership, nor did we want it as recently as ICANN 70, when the question was raised explicitly.
Therefore, trust in the ccNSO is about being a trusted partner to all ccTLD Managers, independent of the environment in which they are embedded. It is about living up to our own ccNSO principles and acting predictably even under the worst circumstances and/or sometimes even at the expense of one’s personal views.
To be very clear, the ccNSO Council condemns violence and war to resolve differences, now and in the future, anywhere in the world.
Best regards,
Alejandra Reynoso
On behalf of the ccNSO Council
--
 |
| Alejandra Reynoso Investigación & Desarrollo | Dominios .gt |
| P: +502 23688565 E: alejandra.reynoso@cctld.gt |
| 18 Ave. 11-95 Zona 15, V.H. III. (A-109) Guatemala, Guatemala |
| www.gt |