Hi Bruna
I’m rather surprised at your email. As one of the participants in the PDP you should have had the various emails, so please contact staff if you aren’t getting them. As the initial
email on 17 February made clear to all WG members, Paul was identified by full consensus of the SSC as the recommended candidate to chair this PDP, and that appointment is subject to the usual confirmation by Council at our next meeting. A motion is currently
being prepared to proceed under the consent agenda, and this will be shared shortly. The motions deadline is 1 March. I don’t understand you to be actually objecting and intending to vote “no” to Paul’s appointment, Bruna, but if you or any Councillor does
so object I would urge you to raise that promptly.
The first ICANN 85 meeting will be opened by the GNSO Council Liaison for this PDP, which in this case is Jennifer Chung. All emails and communication to and documents prepared for
the WG have been in coordination with Jen as Council Liaison.
Given the SSC recommendation, Council Leadership considers it is appropriate for Paul to take up this post on an interim basis, pending the vote to confirm by Council. This allows
for a timely start of the PDP1 and for the working group to progress with important PDP steps. You surely would not wish to lose the valuable opportunity
for this PDP WG to meet in person during ICANN 85, nor for staff to chair these four meetings when a qualified chair has been identified by the SSC?
With regards to the Vice-Chair role, again as noted in the Kick Off Email, a Call for Volunteers for the Vice Chair position has been opened with the deadline of 27 February. Once the deadline has passed,
the WG leadership will reach out to the WG with the list of volunteers and decide during ICANN85 how to best select the Vice-Chair.
It’s a shame you did not join our Prep Webinar last Thursday, which would have been a good opportunity to talk through your concerns rather than having to do so over email.
From: Bruna Martins dos Santos via council <council@icann.org>
Sent: 24 February 2026 11:29
To: Council@icann.org
Subject: [council] DNS Abuse PDP Chair
Dear all,
Hope this email finds you well.
I understand we are all under a lot of pressure due to the forthcoming start of the DNS Abuse PDP and Mumbai meeting, but I would like to share my discomfort as to how the chair selection and PDP communications has been handled so far.
As of now, we have had an announcement made on the list on behalf of a preliminary chair. And, as per our understanding, Council leadership has made a request for SSC to make a recommendation of a chair and this recommendation needs to
be confirmed by council and hasn't been yet.
Therefore, I would like to kindly request that Council leadership informs us of the next steps in this process, especially because I have the following doubts:
1. Will there be a motion confirming Paul as PDP Chair in Mumbai we need to vote on ?
2. How can a preliminary chair host the first meeting of the PDP if he hasn't been formally confirmed on the role ? In this case, shouldn't we ask Staff to chair the first meeting? (im invoking gnso working group guidelines that foresee the possibility of staff
performing admin coordination until a chair is appointed)
3. How can a preliminary chair select his vice-chair if he hasn't been confirmed yet ?
Again, I understand we're all doing our best and my email is by no means a question about Paul's abilities. But the way we have been dealing with this process has been a tad frustrating and I wish we had more information from leadership.
Kind regards,
Bruna
--
Bruna Martins dos Santos
Policy and Advocacy Manager | WITNESS
German Chancellor Fellow 21' (Bundeskanzler-Stipendiatin) |
Alexander von Humboldt Foundation
Member |
Coalizão Direitos na Rede
Twitter: @boomartins // Skype:
bruna.martinsantos
Email: bruna.mrtns@gmail.com