I have made a couple of edits to your spreadsheet (there were a couple of examples of wrong colour code use in columns 2 and 3.

Overall, I would suggest not alternating between 2 sets of options but going with the (simpler IMO) 3-way rotation. Doing so would mean we first settle on a preference between option 1 and 4. As you suggest you would prefer option 4 to option 1 (which is just crazy to me as I would rather work late than early, so it really is a case of personal preference here), perhaps we can go with that one.