Claire I will document my concerns here and in the CPWG mailing list.  Louie Touton’s original General Counsel had a saying that ICANN’s mission is to protect competition, not individual competitors’ business models.  All too often in ICANN’s current PDP, Registrars and Registrars flex their de facto veto authority at the GNSO to impede real, meaningful change. Why this is BAD for ICANN is that it demonstrates that certain aspects of ICANN’s multistakeholder model have been captured, thus leaving disenfranchised members to resort to national laws, see NIS2, Chinese Real Name Verification, India litigation, etc.