Dear all,
I was assigned an action item at the last CPWG Call of 24 Jul 2019 along the lines of "ID of issues - "What subsequent procedures and where else do we go? Who is audience?""
Context
- Those of you who follow the proceedings of the GNSO Subsequent Procedures PDP WG ("SubPro WG") will know that the SubPro WG have in Apr 2019 commenced deliberations on the public comments received in response to the call for public comments to its Initial Report of Jul 2018. And the said deliberations, the SubPro WG welcomes input (especially from SubPro WG members) whether it be through its calls or mailing list
- The ALAC has over a long period of time (dating back to 2008) provided inputs or advice on various issues relating to Subsequent Procedures
- At this point, there may not be a further need for intervention within the SubPro WG by At-Large/ALAC provided it can be established that our inputs or advice have been satisfactorily taken into account by the SubPro WG. This is aside from continuing efforts by several active At-Large members in the SubPro WG in helping ensure that the ALAC inputs aren't inadvertently omitted, overlooked or misinterpreted in the context of the deliberations (especially when an input relates to more than one issue within the SubPro WG's agenda).
- In some cases, the ALAC's inputs in the form of statements submitted through the public comments process are shared by other constituencies; which leads to a finding of "high level agreement" thus enabling the SubPro WG to at least develop a recommendation for the same.
- It is the ALAC inputs which are not shared by other constituencies or which do not receive sufficient support that we are concerned with now. And what we have to now consider is whether we believe such inputs are crucial enough for At-Large to keep pressing for and if yes, how.
Action Taken
- Holly Raiche and I have prepared a list of Issues within Subsequent Procedures for which we think At-Large/ALAC have provided substantial input, as a starting reference point -- please go to the relevant At-Large Workspace: https://community.icann.org/x/6a_jBg to view or to comment on this said list.
- The idea we and Jonathan Zuck have is to try and highlight, over a series of CPWG calls, where the SubPro WG is at in terms of its deliberations, on a topic by topic basis, covering only those topics which relate to issues within subsequent procedures for which the ALAC has provided inputs (or advice).
Since the SubPro WG is currently deliberating the topic of Applicant Support (during its calls of 24 Jul and upcoming of 29 Jul 20:00 UTC), we thought we might try to properly start our exercise with this topic.
I will be sending a separate email on Applicant Support shortly.
Kind regards,
Justine Chew-----