Gosh Evan do you ever sleep? But I feel compelled to reply... On Tue, Aug 6, 2019 at 9:37 PM Evan Leibovitch <evan@telly.org> wrote:
Hi Maureen,
On Wed, 7 Aug 2019 at 02:01, Maureen Hilyard <maureen.hilyard@gmail.com> wrote:
Evan, in my example cos I am always looking at what is happening in my
backyard, what I am saying too is that end-users in my space don't care, but that's because they are unaware.
Unaware of what?
Unaware of Internet domains? Unaware of the ability to purchase a top-level domain? or Unaware of the possibility that such a purchase could be reduced in price under certain circumstances.
Indeed, in your backyard lie a number of the domain-name world's great small-player success stories, in one case a TLD is the source of ten percent of the country's whole GDP. The potential of Internet domains in the region is well understood by governments and entrepreneurs. There is a big difference between "they don't participate because they don't know" and "they don't participate because they know and choose to stay away".
(BTW, there is a GREAT video that explains domain names to the "unaware", through the lens of the Tuvalu experience, that can be found here <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=34gHoxqZlJc>. I highly recommend it.)
There are lots of stories similar to that of Tuvalu and Niue who have others running their cctlds and giving a small share back to the country concerned. There are rules about .ck domain names and because the government is a part owner of the domain they are very fussy about how it is used. There have been lots of requests as you can imagine. But again
All of the above. I live on an island where most people aren't really interested because the majority contact with the internet is with mobiles and they only use what they can afford which is very little on local salaries. Adults seem to spend their money on cigarettes at $33 a packet of 20 the youngsters spend their money on the Internet and pay $50 for 5GB of mobile data. They dont need to know that Facebook is a domain. However with the advent of cable next year and a cable company actually competing with the current monopoly satellite service provider, things might start getting interesting. Also a new Telecommunications Act when the government finally puts it through parliament will enable lots of opportunities for new businesses and other entrepreneurial ventures. This is when domains may start to feature. This is my backyard. End-users dont know the potential of being a registrant because they havent had the chance to know what domains are and to see how domains might be used. They dont participate because they* really* don't know. But the potential for change is just around the corner. And while there is a lot of learning and setting up that needs to take place but there are also political and cultural barriers. Regardless, the capacity building WG is working with Brian Gutterman on a Registrant ICANN Learn course to explain what is involved in being a registrant and the potential that can come about through domains. This is an ideal time for people in the Cook Islands to do this course so that they get a better understanding of being a registrant before more broadband becomes available. It would be good to know how they can use a domain to set up and promote their business or their personal or NGO websites. I see this course as being one means of supporting new registrants. Maureen, I will respectfully disagree wholeheartedly with your assertion. this is a government level decision not end-user..
In any case, I am unclear of the logic that leads from the premise of "people are unaware" to a conclusion of "therefore we should subsidize certain gTLD applications".
Well that didn't come from me... support does not necessarily mean subsidise.
Cheers,
- Evan