Reminder: Comments on WorkPlan due Friday 5 December at 23:59 UTC
All, Just a reminder that the Chairs have asked for any comments/suggestions to the work plan to be submitted by Friday 5 December at 23:59 UTC. I've reattached their note and copied it here below for your convenience. Best, Grace IANA Stewardship Transition Cross Community Working Group (CWG) on Naming Related Functions Work plan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants Lise Fuhr & Jonathan Robinson The Chairs recognize the great amount of work that has been done drafting the proposal sent out for consultation and we thank the group for the effort. However, given the demanding schedule we still need to work with, we cannot rest on our laurels if we are to meet our next major objective of having a submission ready for the chartering organizations by 19 January 2015. As per our plan we are presenting 3 webinars on the public consultation document this week. Given 2 of these webinars are on Thursday 4 December 2014 and would be book-ends to our working group meeting and that your co-chairs will be presenting the webinars, we felt this was too much. As such we are cancelling the Thursday 4 December meeting of the CWG and hope that those that have questions on the proposal will attend the webinar. Although the 4 December meeting is cancelled, we are posting this new schedule of meetings to allow us to reach our objective, which will include continuing our CWG meetings during the holiday period: * * Thursday 10 December 2014 – 11:00UTC * * Thursday 18 December 2014 – 11:00UTC (Time change from 14:00 to 11:00) * * Tuesday 23 December 2014 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed * * Tuesday 30 December 2014 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed. * * Thursday 8 January 2015 – 11:00 - UTC - hour to be confirmed * * Saturday 10 January – Time TBC (New additional meeting inserted) * * Thursday 15 January 2015 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed. * * In addition to the above, we now need to focus our efforts on the tasks that still need to be completed in order to meet our next objective. To this end we would propose the following schedule: Public consultation o Prepare weekly reports on the public consultation for the CWG – Support staff. o Prepare a final report and analysis of the results of the public consultation for the CWG for the 30 December meeting – Support staff. o Review by the CWG of the results of the public consultation and identify action items resulting from – 30 December meeting. o Draft and post the results of the public consultation per the results of the CWG review – 5 January – Staff support. RFP3 – Contract Co. o Obtain formal legal advice regarding viability of concept and initial requirements – GS and volunteers. o Contract details Review key terms and make decisions regarding these after details of the MRT are settled. RFP3 – MRT RFP3 – CSC RFP4 o Complete functional analysis and derived requirements – GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting. o Composition requirements - GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting. o Structural (internal functional) requirements - TBD o Support requirements (secretariat etc.) - TBD o Bootstrap requirements – TBD o Complete functional analysis and derived requirements – GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting. o Composition requirements – CWG (10 December 10). o Structural (internal functional) requirements – CWG (10 December). o Support requirements (secretariat etc.) – CWG (10 December). o Bootstrap requirements – CWG (10 December). RFP3 – Independent Appeals Panel o Wait for results of public consultation. RFP5 RFP6 o Complete a list of proposed changes from RFP3 (confirmed and optional) that are to be considered in this section –Staff (5 December) o For each proposed change in the previous list identify which of the elements of RFP4 apply and have to be developed to meet the requirements. Present report to CWG – RG, SM (10 December). o Prepare a complete evaluation for one of the simple proposed changes for presentation to the CWG on 10 December – RG, SM. o Present additional elements at each of the following meetings of the CWG on December 18, 23, 30 - RG, SM. o Present a final draft at the 8 January meeting of the CWG. o This work will be completed by the drafting team when the other elements are being assembled. o Is being developed by staff with the help of the various communities. A draft of this is Section C of the public consultation document. This should be completed in the final drafting sessions in the week of 12 January. Furthermore the Principles need to be finalized and this is to be done by 10 December. They will be sent out for comments as soon as possible. We realize that this is a demanding schedule and acknowledge the commitment required of members, participants and staff in working within this schedule, especially as it impacts on the calendar year end holiday season for many. Comments, suggestions and improvements to the proposed schedule are welcome but please provide these as soon as possible and in any event by 23:59 UTC on Friday 5 December 2014. From: Jonathan Robinson <jrobinson@afilias.info> Organization: Afilias Reply-To: Jonathan Robinson <jrobinson@afilias.info> Date: Wednesday, December 3, 2014 9:11 AM To: "cwg-stewardship@icann.org" <cwg-stewardship@icann.org> Subject: [CWG-Stewardship] Workplan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants All, Please see attached for a work plan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants and including detail on proposed meetings and times (some of which have changed). Note: Tomorrow’s meeting of the CWG (4 December 2014, 14:00 UTC) will no longer go ahead as planned. Please check the attachment for full details. Thank-you, Lise Fuhr & Jonathan Robinson
Dear Jonathan and Lise, Thank you for this. On the scheduling of conference calls, I agree to the proposed schedule but would like to ask whether there are any provisions to have another F2F meeting or high intensity calls (say 48 hours of long calls) if by January we find this would be required to find consensus. If there is, could we please all agree ASAP to set the date for this option so we are all able to clear that in our calendars? Secondly, I note guidelines on the work remaining for RFP sub-groups. Whilst I agree with the items lists, I also think that we should not be limited to what is on the list at the moment. We might need to allocate more items specifically under RFP3. For example, one major item I see missing is the issue of Jurisdiction especially for Contract Co. & for MRT. Kind regards, Olivier On 05/12/2014 05:24, Grace Abuhamad wrote:
All,
Just a reminder that the Chairs have asked for any comments/suggestions to the work plan to be submitted by Friday 5 December at 23:59 UTC. I've reattached their note and copied it here below for your convenience.
Best, Grace
IANA Stewardship Transition Cross Community Working Group (CWG) on Naming
Related Functions
Work plan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants Lise Fuhr & Jonathan Robinson
The Chairs recognize the great amount of work that has been done drafting the proposal sent out for consultation and we thank the group for the effort. However, given the demanding schedule we still need to work with, we cannot rest on our laurels if we are to meet our next major objective of having a submission ready for the chartering organizations by 19 January 2015.
As per our plan we are presenting 3 webinars on the public consultation document this week. Given 2 of these webinars are on Thursday 4 December 2014 and would be book-ends to our working group meeting and that your co-chairs will be presenting the webinars, we felt this was too much. As such we are cancelling the Thursday 4 December meeting of the CWG and hope that those that have questions on the proposal will attend the webinar.
Although the 4 December meeting is cancelled, we are posting this new schedule of meetings to allow us to reach our objective, which will include continuing our CWG meetings during the holiday period:
*
Thursday 10 December 2014 – 11:00UTC
*
Thursday 18 December 2014 – 11:00UTC (Time change from 14:00 to 11:00)
*
Tuesday 23 December 2014 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed
*
Tuesday 30 December 2014 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed.
*
Thursday 8 January 2015 – 11:00 - UTC - hour to be confirmed
*
Saturday 10 January – Time TBC (New additional meeting inserted)
*
Thursday 15 January 2015 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed.
In addition to the above, we now need to focus our efforts on the tasks that still need to be completed in order to meet our next objective. To this end we would propose the following schedule:
page1image17584 page1image17744
Public consultation
o Prepare weekly reports on the public consultation for the CWG – Support staff. o Prepare a final report and analysis of the results of the public consultation for the CWG for the
30 December meeting – Support staff. o Review by the CWG of the results of the public consultation and identify action items resulting
from – 30 December meeting. o Draft and post the results of the public consultation per the results of the CWG review – 5
January – Staff support.
RFP3 – Contract Co.
o Obtain formal legal advice regarding viability of concept and initial requirements – GS and volunteers.
o Contract details
Review key terms and make decisions regarding these after details of the MRT are settled.
RFP3 – MRT
RFP3 – CSC
RFP4
o Complete functional analysis and derived requirements – GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting.
o Composition requirements - GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting.
o Structural (internal functional) requirements - TBD o Support requirements (secretariat etc.) - TBD o Bootstrap requirements – TBD
o Complete functional analysis and derived requirements – GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting.
o Composition requirements – CWG (10 December 10). o Structural (internal functional) requirements – CWG (10 December). o Support requirements (secretariat etc.) – CWG (10 December). o Bootstrap requirements – CWG (10 December).
RFP3 – Independent Appeals Panel
o Wait for results of public consultation.
RFP5
RFP6
o Complete a list of proposed changes from RFP3 (confirmed and optional) that are to be considered in this section –Staff (5 December)
o For each proposed change in the previous list identify which of the elements of RFP4 apply and have to be developed to meet the requirements. Present report to CWG – RG, SM (10 December).
o Prepare a complete evaluation for one of the simple proposed changes for presentation to the CWG on 10 December – RG, SM.
o Present additional elements at each of the following meetings of the CWG on December 18, 23, 30 - RG, SM.
o Present a final draft at the 8 January meeting of the CWG.
o This work will be completed by the drafting team when the other elements are being
assembled.
o Is being developed by staff with the help of the various communities. A draft of this is Section C of the public consultation document. This should be completed in the final drafting sessions in the week of 12 January.
Furthermore the Principles need to be finalized and this is to be done by 10 December. They will be sent out for comments as soon as possible.
We realize that this is a demanding schedule and acknowledge the commitment required of members, participants and staff in working within this schedule, especially as it impacts on the calendar year end holiday season for many.
Comments, suggestions and improvements to the proposed schedule are welcome but please provide these as soon as possible and in any event by 23:59 UTC on Friday 5 December 2014.
From: Jonathan Robinson <jrobinson@afilias.info <mailto:jrobinson@afilias.info>> Organization: Afilias Reply-To: Jonathan Robinson <jrobinson@afilias.info <mailto:jrobinson@afilias.info>> Date: Wednesday, December 3, 2014 9:11 AM To: "cwg-stewardship@icann.org <mailto:cwg-stewardship@icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship@icann.org <mailto:cwg-stewardship@icann.org>> Subject: [CWG-Stewardship] Workplan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants
All,
Please see attached for a work plan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants and including detail on proposed meetings and times (some of which have changed).
*Note*: Tomorrow’s meeting of the CWG (4 December 2014, 14:00 UTC) will no longer go ahead as planned. Please check the attachment for full details.
Thank-you,
Lise Fuhr & Jonathan Robinson
_______________________________________________ CWG-Stewardship mailing list CWG-Stewardship@icann.org https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/cwg-stewardship
Olivier:, Point well taken, although I'm not sure I understand what you mean by jurisdiction for MRT. As a group with no formal (i.e., legally recognizable) existence, the intent is that it would not have any particular jurisdiction as its "domicile." Are you referring to jurisdiction.in some other sense? In any event, Bernie and I are working more detailed working documents specifically for RFP-3. We hope to circulate these today or at the latest, MOnday. Best regards, Greg Greg On Fri, Dec 5, 2014 at 8:53 AM, Olivier MJ Crepin-Leblond <ocl@gih.com> wrote:
Dear Jonathan and Lise,
Thank you for this. On the scheduling of conference calls, I agree to the proposed schedule but would like to ask whether there are any provisions to have another F2F meeting or high intensity calls (say 48 hours of long calls) if by January we find this would be required to find consensus. If there is, could we please all agree ASAP to set the date for this option so we are all able to clear that in our calendars?
Secondly, I note guidelines on the work remaining for RFP sub-groups. Whilst I agree with the items lists, I also think that we should not be limited to what is on the list at the moment. We might need to allocate more items specifically under RFP3. For example, one major item I see missing is the issue of Jurisdiction especially for Contract Co. & for MRT.
Kind regards,
Olivier
On 05/12/2014 05:24, Grace Abuhamad wrote:
All,
Just a reminder that the Chairs have asked for any comments/suggestions to the work plan to be submitted by Friday 5 December at 23:59 UTC. I've reattached their note and copied it here below for your convenience.
Best, Grace
IANA Stewardship Transition Cross Community Working Group (CWG) on Naming
Related Functions
Work plan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants Lise Fuhr & Jonathan Robinson
The Chairs recognize the great amount of work that has been done drafting the proposal sent out for consultation and we thank the group for the effort. However, given the demanding schedule we still need to work with, we cannot rest on our laurels if we are to meet our next major objective of having a submission ready for the chartering organizations by 19 January 2015.
As per our plan we are presenting 3 webinars on the public consultation document this week. Given 2 of these webinars are on Thursday 4 December 2014 and would be book-ends to our working group meeting and that your co-chairs will be presenting the webinars, we felt this was too much. As such we are cancelling the Thursday 4 December meeting of the CWG and hope that those that have questions on the proposal will attend the webinar.
Although the 4 December meeting is cancelled, we are posting this new schedule of meetings to allow us to reach our objective, which will include continuing our CWG meetings during the holiday period:
-
Thursday 10 December 2014 – 11:00UTC -
Thursday 18 December 2014 – 11:00UTC (Time change from 14:00 to 11:00) -
Tuesday 23 December 2014 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed -
Tuesday 30 December 2014 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed. -
Thursday 8 January 2015 – 11:00 - UTC - hour to be confirmed -
Saturday 10 January – Time TBC (New additional meeting inserted) -
Thursday 15 January 2015 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed.
In addition to the above, we now need to focus our efforts on the tasks that still need to be completed in order to meet our next objective. To this end we would propose the following schedule:
[image: page1image17584] [image: page1image17744]
Public consultation
o Prepare weekly reports on the public consultation for the CWG – Support staff. o Prepare a final report and analysis of the results of the public consultation for the CWG for the
30 December meeting – Support staff. o Review by the CWG of the results of the public consultation and identify action items resulting
from – 30 December meeting. o Draft and post the results of the public consultation per the results of the CWG review – 5
January – Staff support.
RFP3 – Contract Co.
o Obtain formal legal advice regarding viability of concept and initial requirements – GS and volunteers.
o Contract details
Review key terms and make decisions regarding these after details of the MRT are settled.
RFP3 – MRT
RFP3 – CSC
RFP4
o Complete functional analysis and derived requirements – GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting.
o Composition requirements - GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting.
o Structural (internal functional) requirements - TBD o Support requirements (secretariat etc.) - TBD o Bootstrap requirements – TBD
o Complete functional analysis and derived requirements – GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting.
o Composition requirements – CWG (10 December 10). o Structural (internal functional) requirements – CWG (10 December). o Support requirements (secretariat etc.) – CWG (10 December). o Bootstrap requirements – CWG (10 December).
RFP3 – Independent Appeals Panel
o Wait for results of public consultation.
RFP5
RFP6
o Complete a list of proposed changes from RFP3 (confirmed and optional) that are to be considered in this section –Staff (5 December)
o For each proposed change in the previous list identify which of the elements of RFP4 apply and have to be developed to meet the requirements. Present report to CWG – RG, SM (10 December).
o Prepare a complete evaluation for one of the simple proposed changes for presentation to the CWG on 10 December – RG, SM.
o Present additional elements at each of the following meetings of the CWG on December 18, 23, 30 - RG, SM.
o Present a final draft at the 8 January meeting of the CWG.
o This work will be completed by the drafting team when the other elements are being
assembled.
o Is being developed by staff with the help of the various communities. A draft of this is Section C of the public consultation document. This should be completed in the final drafting sessions in the week of 12 January.
Furthermore the Principles need to be finalized and this is to be done by 10 December. They will be sent out for comments as soon as possible.
We realize that this is a demanding schedule and acknowledge the commitment required of members, participants and staff in working within this schedule, especially as it impacts on the calendar year end holiday season for many.
Comments, suggestions and improvements to the proposed schedule are welcome but please provide these as soon as possible and in any event by 23:59 UTC on Friday 5 December 2014.
From: Jonathan Robinson <jrobinson@afilias.info> Organization: Afilias Reply-To: Jonathan Robinson <jrobinson@afilias.info> Date: Wednesday, December 3, 2014 9:11 AM To: "cwg-stewardship@icann.org" <cwg-stewardship@icann.org> Subject: [CWG-Stewardship] Workplan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants
All,
Please see attached for a work plan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants and including detail on proposed meetings and times (some of which have changed).
*Note*: Tomorrow’s meeting of the CWG (4 December 2014, 14:00 UTC) will no longer go ahead as planned. Please check the attachment for full details.
Thank-you,
Lise Fuhr & Jonathan Robinson
_______________________________________________ CWG-Stewardship mailing listCWG-Stewardship@icann.orghttps://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/cwg-stewardship
_______________________________________________ CWG-Stewardship mailing list CWG-Stewardship@icann.org https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/cwg-stewardship
-- *Gregory S. Shatan **ï* *Abelman Frayne & Schwab* *666 Third Avenue **ï** New York, NY 10017-5621* *Direct* 212-885-9253 *| **Main* 212-949-9022 *Fax* 212-949-9190 *|* *Cell *917-816-6428 *gsshatan@lawabel.com <gsshatan@lawabel.com>* *ICANN-related: gregshatanipc@gmail.com <gregshatanipc@gmail.com> * *www.lawabel.com <http://www.lawabel.com/>*
Jonathan, all Thank you for the workplan. This is an aggressive timetable and I am certain that we all understand the reasons for this. However, I would just like to understand, from a pragmatic point of view, how we are going to reconcile our work with the accountability stream? I think we need to find a balance between pushing ahead to meet a deadline and ensuring that we have a proposal that has been developed with all the relevant information. Thanks, Donna [Description: Description: Description: ARI Logo]DONNA AUSTIN Policy and Industry Affairs Manager ARI REGISTRY SERVICES Melbourne | Los Angeles P +1 310 890 9655 P +61 3 9866 3710 E donna.austin@ariservices.com<mailto:donna.austin@ariservices.com> W www.ariservices.com<http://www.ariservices.com/> Follow us on Twitter<https://twitter.com/ARIservices> The information contained in this communication is intended for the named recipients only. It is subject to copyright and may contain legally privileged and confidential information and if you are not an intended recipient you must not use, copy, distribute or take any action in reliance on it. If you have received this communication in error, please delete all copies from your system and notify us immediately. From: cwg-stewardship-bounces@icann.org [mailto:cwg-stewardship-bounces@icann.org] On Behalf Of Grace Abuhamad Sent: Thursday, 4 December 2014 8:24 PM To: jrobinson@afilias.info; cwg-stewardship@icann.org Subject: [CWG-Stewardship] Reminder: Comments on WorkPlan due Friday 5 December at 23:59 UTC All, Just a reminder that the Chairs have asked for any comments/suggestions to the work plan to be submitted by Friday 5 December at 23:59 UTC. I've reattached their note and copied it here below for your convenience. Best, Grace IANA Stewardship Transition Cross Community Working Group (CWG) on Naming Related Functions Work plan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants Lise Fuhr & Jonathan Robinson The Chairs recognize the great amount of work that has been done drafting the proposal sent out for consultation and we thank the group for the effort. However, given the demanding schedule we still need to work with, we cannot rest on our laurels if we are to meet our next major objective of having a submission ready for the chartering organizations by 19 January 2015. As per our plan we are presenting 3 webinars on the public consultation document this week. Given 2 of these webinars are on Thursday 4 December 2014 and would be book-ends to our working group meeting and that your co-chairs will be presenting the webinars, we felt this was too much. As such we are cancelling the Thursday 4 December meeting of the CWG and hope that those that have questions on the proposal will attend the webinar. Although the 4 December meeting is cancelled, we are posting this new schedule of meetings to allow us to reach our objective, which will include continuing our CWG meetings during the holiday period: · • Thursday 10 December 2014 – 11:00UTC · • Thursday 18 December 2014 – 11:00UTC (Time change from 14:00 to 11:00) · • Tuesday 23 December 2014 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed · • Tuesday 30 December 2014 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed. · • Thursday 8 January 2015 – 11:00 - UTC - hour to be confirmed · • Saturday 10 January – Time TBC (New additional meeting inserted) · • Thursday 15 January 2015 – 14:00UTC - hour to be confirmed. In addition to the above, we now need to focus our efforts on the tasks that still need to be completed in order to meet our next objective. To this end we would propose the following schedule: • Public consultation o Prepare weekly reports on the public consultation for the CWG – Support staff. o Prepare a final report and analysis of the results of the public consultation for the CWG for the 30 December meeting – Support staff. o Review by the CWG of the results of the public consultation and identify action items resulting from – 30 December meeting. o Draft and post the results of the public consultation per the results of the CWG review – 5 January – Staff support. • RFP3 – Contract Co. o Obtain formal legal advice regarding viability of concept and initial requirements – GS and volunteers. o Contract details • Review key terms and make decisions regarding these after details of the MRT are settled. • RFP3 – MRT • RFP3 – CSC • RFP4 o Complete functional analysis and derived requirements – GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting. o Composition requirements - GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting. o Structural (internal functional) requirements - TBD o Support requirements (secretariat etc.) - TBD o Bootstrap requirements – TBD o Complete functional analysis and derived requirements – GS and Staff will prepare a report for CWG consideration at its 10 December meeting. o Composition requirements – CWG (10 December 10). o Structural (internal functional) requirements – CWG (10 December). o Support requirements (secretariat etc.) – CWG (10 December). o Bootstrap requirements – CWG (10 December). • RFP3 – Independent Appeals Panel o Wait for results of public consultation. • RFP5 • RFP6 o Complete a list of proposed changes from RFP3 (confirmed and optional) that are to be considered in this section –Staff (5 December) o For each proposed change in the previous list identify which of the elements of RFP4 apply and have to be developed to meet the requirements. Present report to CWG – RG, SM (10 December). o Prepare a complete evaluation for one of the simple proposed changes for presentation to the CWG on 10 December – RG, SM. o Present additional elements at each of the following meetings of the CWG on December 18, 23, 30 - RG, SM. o Present a final draft at the 8 January meeting of the CWG. o This work will be completed by the drafting team when the other elements are being assembled. o Is being developed by staff with the help of the various communities. A draft of this is Section C of the public consultation document. This should be completed in the final drafting sessions in the week of 12 January. Furthermore the Principles need to be finalized and this is to be done by 10 December. They will be sent out for comments as soon as possible. We realize that this is a demanding schedule and acknowledge the commitment required of members, participants and staff in working within this schedule, especially as it impacts on the calendar year end holiday season for many. Comments, suggestions and improvements to the proposed schedule are welcome but please provide these as soon as possible and in any event by 23:59 UTC on Friday 5 December 2014. From: Jonathan Robinson <jrobinson@afilias.info<mailto:jrobinson@afilias.info>> Organization: Afilias Reply-To: Jonathan Robinson <jrobinson@afilias.info<mailto:jrobinson@afilias.info>> Date: Wednesday, December 3, 2014 9:11 AM To: "cwg-stewardship@icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship@icann.org>" <cwg-stewardship@icann.org<mailto:cwg-stewardship@icann.org>> Subject: [CWG-Stewardship] Workplan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants All, Please see attached for a work plan update from the CWG co-chairs for members and participants and including detail on proposed meetings and times (some of which have changed). Note: Tomorrow’s meeting of the CWG (4 December 2014, 14:00 UTC) will no longer go ahead as planned. Please check the attachment for full details. Thank-you, Lise Fuhr & Jonathan Robinson
participants (4)
-
Donna Austin -
Grace Abuhamad -
Greg Shatan -
Olivier MJ Crepin-Leblond