Monsieur Morfin, Merci pour votre message et au plaisir de vous rencontrer la semaine prochaine. Frédéric Frédéric E. Teboul, Ph.D., MBA Manager for At-Large Regional Affairs Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) Phone Number: +33 6 3487 0575 (France) & +1 310 578 8642 (USA) Email: frederic.teboul@icann.org AIM/iSight: frederic.teboul@mac.com Jabber: frederic.teboul@jabber.icann.org Skype: frederic.teboul On 10/06/08 23:17, "JFC Morfin" <jefsey@jefsey.com> wrote: At 17:56 10/06/2008, At-Large Staff wrote:

For your convenience, below you will find a restated set of the same questions.

This answer is based upon the vision that ICANN is not necessary to the Internet on an Internet @large point of view, but necessary to some members of the Internet community. As such ICANN : 1) must undertake a transition towards a mission which is not yet well defined as enhanced cooperation has not been really discussed by the WSIS community. It is therefore likely that this mission will not be finalized before the end of JPA and IGF. 2) @large are probably probably going to be the toughest competition ICANN will meet in the coming years if it engages into a TLD marketing campaign, because the technical evolution is to a dillution of the DNS in terms of TLDs and semantic addressing. (This conforms to ICANN ICP-3 document ICANN should reread).

1. What issues being debated in ICANN do you believe are the most important to your RALO?

- which services ICANN can bring to the @large community in terms of network operations (escrow is an idea). - Mostly ICANN can help RALO meetings, and RALOs progressive autonomy from ICANN in order to become credible ICANN interfaces (RALO must take over an interest in practical operations ISOC has never taken). Otherwise it will be a grassroots @large deployment. These kinds of move are slow and call for adequate/credible tools/applications. I think we see them coming (ex. unbound).

2. How can we help make the time you spend on ICANN issues as valuable and efficient to you as possible?

- In listening and reporting to the BoD. @large are no value to ICANN if they are not accepted as field experts. What is certainly difficult is to assess the exact field of expertise of each of them (usage, PRs, operations, DNS, legal, political, future, connections, etc.). This kind of work calls for a great expertise in the Internet field, just to be able to understand the implications of what is reported. Example: ICANN should work out an agreement with IETF on a IETF/ICANN WG-@large able to interface @larges. Not so much to answer @larges, but to get commented/translated field inputs from @larges as lead users. Probably the same with the GAC.

3. What challenges and opportunities do you see for your RALO and for At-Large more generally (in the context of ICANN work)?

Getting ICANN to properly define a strategic objective which fits whith what Internet users might be interested in. The real risk is an ICANN split due to a disagreement between what ICANN proposes and what users really wait for.

4. How interaction between and within RALOs be increased?

f2f specialised meetings. Working/Reporting on a given topic. With external experts.

5. What are the top three things you would like your RALO to achieve?

- participate in creating the Euro-IGF - document a position on ICANN future and specific services to Europe - accredit france@large :-)

6. What are the top three things you believe ICANN Staff could do to help your RALO?

- explain why they opposed france@large - work on support of the RALO through working tools. Mailing lists (ICANN Staff should be explained about) are not sufficient. This is a community wide need ICANN should be associated with - organising the funding of network oriented Open Source projects. GPL is not oriented towards networking solutions. (cf. RFC 3869) jfc _______________________________________________ EURO-Discuss mailing list EURO-Discuss@atlarge-lists.icann.org http://atlarge-lists.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/euro-discuss_atlarge-lists.i... Homepage for the region: http://www.euralo.org