Adobe Connect chat transcript for Tuesday, 29 November 2016
Michelle DeSmyter:Dear All, Welcome to the Privacy and Proxy Services Accreditation Program IRT Meeting on Tuesday, 29 November 2016 at 14:00 UTC.
Chris Pelling:Good afternoon all, could we make the chat window slightly taller please ?
Chris Pelling:Many thanks, I have 2 lines now :)
Tom Kinstler:Good Day to all
Graeme Bunton:Morning all.
Theo Geurts:hiyas
Chris Pelling:Thius time is perfect for me
Chris Pelling:I dont see a check mark - sorry
Ashley Heineman:I support the time. I'm clearly an idiot.. as I don't see a green check mark.
Chris Pelling:yes please :)
Sara Bockey:I'm fine with pushing it forward an hour, but this time works for me as well
Ashley Heineman:learn something new every day.
Chris Pelling:aha found it thanks :)
steve metalitz:I am also fine either way and this slot is awfully early for PST
Tom Kinstler:Please can you send an email detailing the type of candidate you are looking for in order for us to forward to the right people.
Graeme Bunton:My recollection is that the PDP struggled to identify any as well
Tom Kinstler:Understood, thank you.
Tom Kinstler:YES PLEASE!
Greg DiBiase:yes please
Carlton Samuels:Morning all
Carlton Samuels:My apologies for the late join; connection issues
Michele Neylon:Sorry - Can't speak not dialled in - am currently on hold with my bank
Mary Wong:We also hope to get specific feedback from the PSWG and the GAC on a potential scope of Section IV
Mary Wong:@Tom, wouldn't that come under Section III?
Chris Pelling:Within UDRP, that already existts
Mary Wong:I believe the existing IP Disclosure Framework allows for trademark holders to make requests, including if the domain is subject to a UDRP proceeding.
Nick Shorey:Has the IRT leadership received any further indication from the Board on when further guidance re GAC advice is likely to be received?
Nick Shorey:cool - i love short answers! Thanks!
Mary Wong:@Nick, the Board is expected to respond to GAC advice from Helsinki and Hyderabad shortly - which includes GAC advice on privacy/proxy issues.
Nick Shorey:@Mary thanks for this. most helpful
Mary Wong:You're most welcome!
Carlton Samuels:Will Sec VI also contains specific data items to be recorded and reported for Compliance purposes?
Carlton Samuels:Thanks for the response.
Carlton Samuels:Good suggestion Steve.
Carlton Samuels:Question, how would the Transfer Policy of Dec 1 impact this?
Mary Wong:@Carlton, none of this would change the 1 Dec effective date - however, to the extent that the Board subsequently agrees to the GNSO request to put the privacy/proxy aspect to our IRT, I believe that Compliance will allow for that flexibility.
Alex Deacon:Maybe Graeme can describe what other alternatives were discussed?
Vicky Sheckler:i'd be interested in understanding hte alternatives for where the issue can be addressed so as not to slow down the work of the work in this group
Carlton Samuels:@Mary: Thanks. Look at the comments from this article concerning whois handling. Is that a legit issue?
Graeme Bunton:Alex - I don't want to eat this call up on that issue, but if there is time at the end?
Graeme Bunton:or maybe the RrSG could host a chat with IPC on this?
Luc Seufer:Do we have LEA reps on this WG? (and not just US ones)
Graeme Bunton:Nick Shorey is from UK LEA
Alex Deacon:Thanks Graeme - just curious that other alternatives were discussed. I don't object per se but want to make sure it doesn't delay existing work....
Luc Seufer:it would be good to have some from Asia... where the language can be a barrier for PPSAI providers to handle requests
Mary Wong:If it helps, any request from the Board/GNSO to handle the privacy/proxy aspects of IRTP within our IRT will be strictly bounded as such - any new or additional policy issues that may arise in the course of doing so will not be for the IRT
to solve; ICANN's existing Consensus Policy Implementation Framework allows for how that will be handled e.g. referral back to the GNSO for policy work.
Carlton Samuels:Thanks all. Bye
Sara Bockey:thanks all
Philip Corwin:bye all
Tom Kinstler:THanks all
Chris Pelling:Many thanks :)
Alex Deacon:Thanks!
Nick Shorey:Thanks!
Luc Seufer:bye