Hi Joyce,
Just to quickly answer that from the point of view that I put the request
out to the RrSG, we have sufficient (provided to Dennis and Marc offlist to
stop scraping of email addresses) requests that at the very least there are
more than a few (3+) the trigger only needing 1 to trigger it. I will
trigger it day 1 as I mentioned in one of my previous emails.
If we do need a date, or timeline, then great, I can set that in my
calendar - otherwise I see it as 1st Agusut 2017.
Kind regards,
Chris
From: "Joyce Lin" <
jlin@007names.com>
To:
"Dennis Chang" <dennis.chang@icann.org>, "gtheo"
<gtheo@xs4all.nl>, "chris" <chris@netearth.net>
Cc:
gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt@icann.org
Sent: Tuesday, 4 October, 2016
17:35:19
Subject: Re: [Gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt] Questions from last
meeting, Alternative method and some comments.
Hi Dennis,
If you meant to drop 2.2
completely, your combined paragraph states that by
August 1, 2017 the
registry's EPP and alternative bulk transfer have to be
deployed
> 2.1. Registry Operator MUST deploy an EPP mechanism
and an alternative
> bulk transfer mechanism by 1 August 2017 for
registrars to migrate
> registration data for Existing Domain
Names...
Then what is the deadline for those registrars who need to use
alternative
bulk transfer option to apply ? Don't we need a
separate deadline for
those registrars to apply so the registry can
tell if there is indeed a need
to develop and deploy the alternative
mechanism? Or do we want the
registry go ahead to have the
alternative mechanism available by Aug. 1,
2017
regardless?
Joyce
-----
Original Message -----
From: "Dennis Chang"
<dennis.chang@icann.org>
To: "gtheo" <gtheo@xs4all.nl>; "Chris
Pelling" <chris@netearth.net>
Cc:
<gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt@icann.org>
Sent: Monday, October 03, 2016
12:56 PM
Subject: Re: [Gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt] Questions from last
meeting,
Alternative method and some comments.
> Thanks
Chris for following through on your action regarding the Registrar’s
>
request for the alternative solution.
> Since your email to the IRT
satisfies the triggers for the “request” in
> section 2.2,
> We
can simplify the policy by combining 2.2 with 2.1 using the same date.
>
Btw, 1 August 2017 provides the 6-month duration that Marc had requested
> for development.
>
> Below if my proposed
change.
>
> From:
> 2.1. Registry Operator MUST deploy an
EPP mechanism by 1 August 2017 for
> registrars to migrate registration
data for Existing Domain Names (i.e.,
> transition from Thin to
Thick).
> 2.2. Registry Operator MUST upon request provide an
alternative bulk
> transfer mechanism by 1 February 2018 for registrars
to migrate data for
> Existing Domain Names (i.e., transition from Thin
to Thick). The request
> MUST be made by 1 August
2017.
>
> To:
> 2.1. Registry Operator MUST deploy an EPP
mechanism and an alternative
> bulk transfer mechanism by 1 August 2017
for registrars to migrate
> registration data for Existing Domain Names
(i.e., transition from Thin to
> Thick).
>
>
> As for
your question about the draft privacy memo to GNSO Council, the IRT
>
had agreed the implementation project will continue in parallel to any
> activity related to the memo. This was agreed upon when the
subject was
> broached at the Helsinki ICANN meeting and again in
subsequent meetings.
> Our plan to continue with the implementation
work including the Public
> Comment has not changed. It is the goal of
our implementation team to
> press forward as best we can to meet the 1
February 2017 Announcement Date
> per the project schedule we’ve agreed
upon.
>
> Thanks for your support and look forward to our meeting
tommorrow.
> Dennis Chang
>
> On 10/3/16, 5:11 AM, "gtheo"
<gtheo@xs4all.nl> wrote:
>
> Thanks Chris, for
posting on the RrSG distribution list and engage with
> our
members.
>
> Theo
>
> Chris
Pelling schreef op 2016-10-02 01:46 PM:
> > Good
afternoon all,
> >
> > First and
foremost we have had ten registrars (including myself)
>
> interested in the alternative solution, so day one there will be
at
> > least 1 triggering it - as that will be
me.
> > This being just the RrSG folks, once ICANN reach
out to all registrar
> > from GDD, I am positive you
will find more. But, as mentioned - I
> have
> >
had active requests for the alternative to be created.
>
>
> > Further questions:
>
>
> > 1. The Verisign/GNSO memo, does this need
to go directly to GNSO, or,
> > via ICANN legal first, I
assume this will happen before the public
> > comment
period?
> >
> > 2. Alan G. said
that a legal review by ICANN legal is needed (I
> >
mentioned to include EU lawyers) because the original legal review in
>
> 2015 did not include Safe Harbor, nor contemplating that
Safe Harbor
> > would be invalidated, where are we on
this and I assume this will
> > happen before the public
comment period?
> >
> > 3.
Implementation notes state there is a procedure for handling whois
>
> conflicts. However, the current method for handling WHOIS
conflicts
> is
> > not working, and the WHOIS IAG
version is at the GNSO and still does
> > not include an
effective procedure as EU privacy regulators are not
> >
giving statements to trigger the procedure. So this kind of sits at
> a
> > stalemate, is ICANN going to remove this?
(I would assume they can't,
> > but we do need more
info/guidance)
> >
> > The above
points 1 and 2, will these happen before the public comment
>
> period or after? Please note if you state afterwards, we are
all
> > potentially sitting here wasting time, as once
those 2 legals come
> > back, it is more than likely we
will all end up reviewing those and
> > going for a
second public comment period based on new findings and
>
> changes to existing work - I am just trying to save time here
(and
> > everyone's sanity) :-)
>
>
> > Kind regards,
>
>
> > Chris
> >
_______________________________________________
> >
Gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt mailing list
> >
Gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt@icann.org
> >
https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt
>
>
>
>
_______________________________________________
>
Gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt mailing list
>
Gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt@icann.org
>
https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/gnso-impl-thickwhois-rt