Lars Hoffmann:Welcome to the IRTP Part D PDP Working Group on Monday 30 September 2013
Bladel:Thanks for the Zoom control. :)
Julia Charvolen:Avri DOria and Chris Chaplow joined the meeting
Volker Greimann:I am now in the meeting#
Chris Chaplow:It is a good issue description
Bladel:Mine too.
Bladel:Are we asking for Compliance Action, or are we establishing TDRP eligibility?
Bladel:(call dropped, rejoining)
Julia Charvolen:James is back on the call
Bladel:Wow...now I know how to fence stolen goods in Germany!
Kristine Dorrain:Wow..yeah, sell all stolen art in Germany. :)
Chris Chaplow:Isnt SEDO a german company?
Bladel:Lol.
Kristine Dorrain:the TDRP has a six month expiration....
Avri Doria:auction become domain name laundering?
Avri Doria:titles never hurt the auto secnd hand market, but they do create a new bureaucracy.
Kristine Dorrain:Mikey, you're thinking of reverse domain name hijacking??
Volker Greimann:I just think that we need to make sure this policy cannot be abused
Bladel:I was thinking along the same lines, but Volker said it better.
Bladel:We aren't evil enough to put ourselves in the mindset of a hijacker. :)
Bladel:BUt it's not free for them to do so...
Avri Doria:Is "you can alwsays go to court" a good temrinal postion for us to count on in Policy?
Volker Greimann:would we not be better advised to tell the registrant to rely on the courts
Bladel:@Avri: I think so.
Bladel:Otherwise there is no floor....
Avri Doria:Should our policies be complete. and yes there is court. but for us to assume it is the exit point, is a moveable line.
Volker Greimann:I am just saying that arbitration may be good for certain issues, other issues should be relegated to the respective courts
Kristine Dorrain:I agree volker
Volker Greimann:especially where there is potential for abuse
Volker Greimann:"just because you can, does not mean you should"
Kristine Dorrain:I'm thinking this way....very low value domain, if the registrar can't fix the wrong, maybe the losing registrant says "that sucks", medium value, maybe they pay to try a TDRP or something, high value, maybe you skip the TDRP and go right to court... Not every avenue is right for every domain name.
Kristine Dorrain:and I use the word "value" loosely....it's all relative
Avri Doria:also court will get more complicated when we get to multiple jurisdictions - the scaling point we haven't thought of too much.
Avri Doria:also in the reverse highjacking we are talking a big-guy highjacker , little guy registrant - court is even less of a slution based on cost than TDRP.
Graeme Bunton:thanks mikey
Bartlett Morgan:thanks
Bladel:Thanks