Hi all –

Noting the desire to “clean up” the impressions document, I hoped to shift from a margin comment conversation to an email conversation for the specific issue of whether/not RDRS can pass requests to participating registrars regardless of whether/not the domain is a TLD.

Below are pasted the original feedback topic, and the subsequent margin comments. 

I will next respond to my own email (this) to continue the discussion, but wanted to make a clean break before adding anything new.

Cheers,

G

Gabriel Andrews

11:33 AM May 22

Pinned for further discussion.  Existing RDS/WHOIS queries provide this information a non-zero % of time - is this intended to say technical staff can't guarantee to have the info 100% of the time?  Clarity sought.

Anonymous

8:38 AM May 30

In other words:  what other info does ICANN tech staff think is needed in order to route the request to the registrar as is done in gTLD contexts?

Anonymous

8:39 AM May 30

Additionally:  PSWG is hearing from some ccTLD operators their desire to voluntarily participate in RDRS, which may assist in solving any challenges.

Lisa Carter

9:03 AM Today

Just an FYI that RDDS requirements for ccTLDs are Unstandardized/Unenforceable as there is no contract for ccTLDs with ICANN.