Dear Working Group members,

Please find a public comment analysis document which encapsulates/summarizes the Working Group’s deliberations on the public comments for individual proposals: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Pnqor6rHjvowH66GPQG9XI23n8H2mgkbf39-jA4KlFc/edit?usp=sharing The updated content for URS Proposals #1, #2, #3, #6, #11, #13, #15, #22, and #26 are on pages 1-12, 14-17.

Brief introduction:

• This document is not meant to replace the Working Group’s transcripts/recordings/chat records, which include the full details of each meeting.
  • Tue, 23 June session: https://68.schedule.icann.org/meetings/4h27u2A9rBqt8annP
  • Thu, 25 June session: https://community.icann.org/x/9YBIC
• Each proposal section includes its full language (in the yellow box), as well as the rationale provided by the original proponent.
• Under each proposal, there are two sections:

1) Public Comment Deliberation Summary:

• “WG Initial Deliberation Summary” contains the summary of the current round of public comment review by the WG, including any action item/decision by the WG regarding the individual proposal.
• If the WG decides not to preserve the proposal for further deliberation/consensus call, the summary is recorded under “WG Final Deliberation Summary”.  

2) Final Recommendation Language Derived from the Individual Proposal (If Applicable): this section will include the recommendation language if an individual proposal gains consensus to become a WG final recommendation.

The update of this document will be ongoing. You are welcome to provide input/feedback and point out any error/mischaracterization/missing content on list.

Best Regards,

Mary, Julie, Ariel