Dear
Mr. Arasteh ..
Allow
me to re-iterate my reply to you regarding your very important questions
..
“I
believe the excellent points you raise below should be addressed through the
proposals we are expecting to receive .. I do not think we should pre-empt what
the community will ultimately reach and express views through this FAQ
..”
In
other words, those questions will be answered in the proposals submitted to the
ICG ..
Looking
forward to receiving your reply to the above ..
I’m
sure there are ICG members more capable of replying to your points on IANA
..
Kind
Regards
--Manal
From: Kavouss Arasteh
[mailto:kavouss.arasteh@gmail.com]
Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2014
8:20 PM
To: Manal Ismail; Alissa Cooper; Patrik Fältström; Mohamed El
Bashir
Cc: Milton L Mueller; Martin Boyle; Coordination
Group
Subject: Re: [Internal-cg] ICG FAQ ..
Manal
Alissa,Patrik,mohamed
Others
I disagree with Patrik that I should draft questions for the
points that I raised
Alissia decided to assign the prepartion of FAQ to
Manal and Martin AND THEN WE RECEIVED THE DRAFR PREPARED.
Now I have made three rounds of questions .those who were
assighned/ designated to prepare the draft of FAQ are kindly requested to put my
points in the propoer questions usuing the style that was utilized
before.
I am awaiting for these very important questions to be
answered
Moreover ,pls clarify what do you mean
by
" I do not disagree that the IANA Department at ICANN
does more than the contract with NTIA describes. What the ICG is
discussing is replacing the stewardship by NTIA for the IANA functions that the
NTIA oversees. The functions that NTIA oversees are described in the
contract and those are the only activities done by the IANA department that have
oversight by NTIA. Any other, non-contractual activities of the IANA
department which may be described in SAC-067 have no contractual relationship
with NTIA and it stewardship"
.
1 Please advise what
what are the actions that IANA Department at ICANN does more than the
contract with NTIA :
2Please also describe what are the IANA functions that
NTIA oversight ?Please cut and paste them from the contract as during the PUBLIC
MEETING we could not refer to the contract as many people may not know that
3,After transition who will oversight those actions?
4. What are those other, non-contractual activities of
the IANA department which may be described in SAC-067 have no contractual
relationship with NTIA and it stewardship"?
5. After transition who will
perform that :
Regards
Kavouss .
2014-09-30 19:36 GMT+02:00 Manal Ismail <manal@tra.gov.eg>:
From: Milton L Mueller
[mailto:mueller@syr.edu]
From: Martin Boyle
[mailto:Martin.Boyle@nominet.org.uk]
For
Q15, Manal is right about running behind the moving train. But I now realise
that the answer is very ICANN centric! In part this is corrected in the
next question, but I would suggest that this question should look at the
operational communities and those directly engaged with them (GAC, ALAC...),
while the next question could then refer to addressing those who do not take
part, but will be affected - the business community, ccTLDs that are not in
ICANN etc
MM: It seems then that the “real” answer to this question
is that the Operational communities themselves should play a major role in the
outreach to relevant non-ICANN communities
MI: I fully agree .. and that’s why I suggested to
add “Inclusiveness/Outreach – check the level of inclusiveness and
outreach of the provided process” to the criteria
of individual proposals assessment, to make sure the Operational communities
considers this seriously and play an active/proactive role in outreach
..
_______________________________________________
Internal-cg
mailing list
Internal-cg@icann.org
https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/internal-cg