Dear members of LACRALO I understand Alberto and Humberto are doing a good job so far. Under the election process we can recognise only one mistake that was to set up a call before the end of the formal process. All other action was included recommended by Ombudsman and followed as such. I do not agree that there is anything against Caribbean is particular. Members of Caribbean have been relevant members at ALAC, NOMCOM and LACRALo since the beginning and with very good performance. Problems with election we had a big one back in Mexico when the two “elected candidates" were from Argentine, and none complained that the problem existed because candidates were from Argentina or Lainos in general. There are several points in our bylaws deserving reviews, generating doubts and open areas for these problems. I normally agree with several points Carlton use to bring to our debates because they are consistent and normally brings new views on the issue. But this time I am totally against this motion. As conclusion I , representing NEXTi ALS , am against this motion. Best to all Since I never can understand the translations, because they are quite poor, I am also writing it in Spanish to make it quite clear to all . ------------------------------------------ Estimados miembros de LACRALO You entiendo que Alberto y Humberto hen sid buenos encargados de LACRALo hasta este momento. Bajo el proceso de elecciones Yo reconozco solo uno error que fue organizar el call antes de finalizar el proceso formal. En las demás acciones fueran inclusive recomendadas por el Ombudsman y seguidas por ellos como propuesto. Yo no veo que haga ninguna acción en contra el Caribe o sus miembros en particular . Miembros del Caribe hen sido miembros relevantes de ALAC, NOMCOM y LACRALO desde el inicio de LACRALo y todos con excelente performance. Problemas com elecciones ya lo tuvimos en Mexico cuando los dos "candidatos electos” eran de Argentina y nadie he reclamado que el problem existió porque los participantes eran argentinos o Latinos en general. Hay muchos puntos en abierto en nuestros estatutos que generan diferentes interpretaciones y dudas y son las causas de estos problemas. Yo normalmente estoy de acuerdo con lo que sugere Carlton porque sus comentarios son consistentes y normalmente traen a la mesa otras visiones sobre el tema en cuestión. Todavia en esta moción estoy totalmente en contra. Como conclusion Yo, representando NEXTi ALS, estoy en contra de esta mocion. Abrazos a todos, Vanda Scartezini NEXTi ALS – Brasil Land Line: +55 11 3266.6253 Mobile: + 55 11 98181.1464 Sorry for any typos. From: <lac-discuss-en-bounces@atlarge-lists.icann.org<mailto:lac-discuss-en-bounces@atlarge-lists.icann.org>> on behalf of Carlton Samuels Date: Saturday, September 5, 2015 at 20:59 To: ICANN Staff Cc: LACRALO list Subject: [lac-discuss-en] Fwd: Moton of NO CONFIDENCE in LACRALO Leadership Dear Heidi: I ma making a formal request that the Staff prepare an official translation of this motion for the list and presentation on the wiki. Kind regards, -Carlton Samuel ============================== Carlton A Samuels Mobile: 876-818-1799<tel:876-818-1799> Strategy, Planning, Governance, Assessment & Turnaround ============================= ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: Carlton Samuels <carlton.samuels@gmail.com<mailto:carlton.samuels@gmail.com>> Date: Fri, Sep 4, 2015 at 9:31 PM Subject: Moton of NO CONFIDENCE in LACRALO Leadership To: "lac-discuss-en@atlarge-lists.icann.org<mailto:lac-discuss-en@atlarge-lists.icann.org>" <lac-discuss-en@atlarge-lists.icann.org<mailto:lac-discuss-en@atlarge-lists.icann.org>> Cc: At-Large Staff <staff@atlarge.icann.org<mailto:staff@atlarge.icann.org>> Now that a LACRALO general assembly is in session, The University of the West Indies At-Large Structure (hereafter the UWI ALS) in accordance with LACRALO Rules of Procedure, raise a Point of Order and offer this motion of NO CONFIDENCE in the LACRALO leadership. -------------------------------------------------------- MOTION OF NO CONFIDENCE Humberto Carrasco, the member representative from “Asociación de Derecho e Informática de Chile”, an At-Large Structure mutually connected to LACRALO and the ICANN community was elected Secretariat in February 2015. Alberto Soto, the member representative from “Instituto Iberoamericano de Investigacion para la Sociedad de la Informacion”, an At-Large Structure mutually connected to LACRALO and the ICANN Community was elected Chair of LACRALO in February 2015. Both are responsible under the ordinary LACRALO Rules of Procedure to conduct the business of LACRALO honestly and with integrity. By their actions, the following have transpired: That this general assembly is incompetent to make a decision on the question of electing a representative from LACRALO to the ALAC for the period 2015-2017; That the question before the assembly is improper and misplaced because Lance Hinds, the member from Devnet is the one true and s[elected] member to the At-Large Advisory Committee (ALAC) from LACRALO for the period 2015-2017; That the nomination of Lance Hinds, the member from Devnet to the ALAC was illegally and maliciously subverted by the actions of the elected Chair of LACRALO in conspiracy with others, known and unknown; That the elected Secretariat of LACRALO wittingly and unwittingly and in abdication of his sworn duties assisted and enabled the conspiracy to subvert the [s]election of Lance Hinds, the member from Devnet, to the ALAC for the period 2015-2017; That this assembly is corruptly spawned and in furtherance of the conspiracy to legalize a corrupted LACRALO election process; That the Chair and Secretariat of LACRALO have corruptly and illegally voided the vote of the UWI ALS and by doing so, denied the UWI ALS our choice of representation to the ALAC; That the Chair and Secretariat of LACRALO have corruptly restricted the voice and influence of Jamaican Internet end users in the ICANN policy development process. On the balance of these facts, the UWI ALS charge the Chair and Secretariat of LACRALO with 1. Inattention to duty 2. Failure to act in accordance with LACRALO Rules of Procedure and the ordinary rules of order pertaining ​ democratic institutions 3. Conspired with one and each other and with others unknown to hijack the electoral process of LACRALO 4. Bringing LACRALO in further disrepute in the ICANN community 5. Impeded the efforts of the UWI ALS to pursue its role in the ICANN policy development process Resolved: That the general assembly demonstrate its lack of confidence in the LACRALO leadership and vote on this motion -------------------------------------------------------------------------- THe University of the West Indies ALS -Carlton Samuels ============================== Carlton A Samuels Mobile: 876-818-1799<tel:876-818-1799> Strategy, Planning, Governance, Assessment & Turnaround =============================