Evan,
You can't prove a counterfactual.
Businesses are spending large sums every day to acquire domain names. Indeed, the value of premium domain names continues to increase as the move of commerce online accelerates.
Beating this dead horse does a disservice to the At-Large community.
Even if you are right - what difference does it make? The ones you need to be persuading are the businesses buying the premium domain names and building their brand strategies around them, not the members of At-Large.
To be blunt, you simply don't know what you're talking about.
Regards,
Nat