are you saying here that in your view the two behaviors referenced in the ICANN advisory, namely i) denying transfers in the grace period and ii) denying transfers for any change in whois information, are allowed for in the current policy? or are you saying they should be?

Regards

On 26-Sep-07, at 12:15 PM, John Berryhill wrote:

The transfers policy has been very effective at eliminating certain

practices, of which we need not recite the history, that were clearly

directed at shaking down registrants for renewals while denying transfers.

The policy does allow room for registrants to consent to a variety of

practices which are motivated by security.