On 1 Apr 2026, at 21:26, Anne ICANN via Reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review <reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review@icann.org> wrote:

Thanks Chris,

A few comments prior to the April 2 meeting:

1.  I would add to the Screening Process (in second place after the reference to the Mission) a requirement to state that the topic must recommend

a procedure or process closely related to the Accountability and Transparency requirements of the ICANN Bylaws  (After all, we are calling this the ATR bucket.) 

2. I would limit the SOs and AC leadership to recommending review of no more than three (3) topics.  If the list is unlimited, everyone will add a "pet peeve" and you will not get through the screening process in a reasonable time frame.

I agree with David that development of a template makes sense.

Separately, Could you please confirm that the call for topics at the GNSO will be made to GNSO Council Leadership?  (I understand that each SO/AC Leadership team would be able to develop approaches to developing the slate within its own body. Trying to figure out how many individuals are involved in analyzing once the topics are submitted?)  Is it 3 for GNSO, 5 for the GAC, one for every region of ALAC etc etc - same issue we often have in a CCWG.  And does this team operate under the CCWG Working Group Guidelines to make Recommendations for reviews to the Board which must then approve or not?

Thank you,

Anne

Anne Aikman-Scalese

GNSO Councilor

NomCom Non-Voting 2022-2026

anneicanngnso@gmail.com

On Wed, Apr 1, 2026 at 6:26 AM Chris Disspain via Reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review <reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review@icann.org> wrote:

Hello All,

As discussed yesterday here is a straw-being on the scoping process which we will discuss on our call at 1500 UTC tomorrow. 

It is also available as a google doc (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1w2cSH9jhz74gU_NFbAUSf14qvNubbaWt/edit).

Feel free to ask questions or make comments on the google doc or to this list before our call. Observers input is also welcome.

Tomorrow we will also discuss the second question around setting safeguards for time limiting scoping exercises.

Cheers,

CD

Chris Disspain

Senior Advisor on Policy and Internet Governance 

_______________________________________________
Reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review mailing list -- reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review@icann.org
To unsubscribe send an email to reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review-leave@icann.org

_______________________________________________
Reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review mailing list -- reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review@icann.org
To unsubscribe send an email to reviewsccg-subgroup-bucket-a-review-leave@icann.org