Dear Review Team Members, Please find below the chat transcript of your call:

Lutz Donnerhacke: (5/18/2011 09:02) Yes Emily Taylor: (09:03) hi Lutz Lynn Goodendorf: (09:03) yes Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:03) legitemete needs is AoC Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:07) Whois began as alook-up service toenable Internetoperators to findone another andcommunicatedirectly if abnormalitiesin trafficoccur betweenservers. (ICANNAnnual Report „09) Lynn Goodendorf: (09:10) while it began that way, it is not up to date Lynn Goodendorf: (09:12) I like "those who operate" Lynn Goodendorf: (09:12) yes Bladel: (09:13) I like "those who operate" Bladel: (09:13) I think policy is "Registered Name Holder" Lynn Goodendorf: (09:13) good point Susan Susan: (09:14) Registered Name Holder would be fine with me Lynn Goodendorf: (09:15) what about "registrant contacts for..." peter: (09:17) I like James' original suggestion of 'entities responsible for' Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:17) whois -h whois.ripe.net -i e-mail lutz@iks-jena.de Sharon LEMON 2: (09:18) I would support James' proposal too Bladel: (09:22) Either is fine by me. Bladel: (09:24) 1.5 Red Bull Sharon LEMON 2: (09:24) 9am Susan: (09:32) I agree with James Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:35) ... techincal ressource lookup .. Bladel: (09:35) "technical queries?" Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:35) ok Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:36) Example: RFC 2622 - Routing Policy Specification Language (RPSL) Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:37) yes Bladel: (09:37) in one swell foop. Bladel: (09:40) it was mine. Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:40) It's even unclear, where the AoC wording is comming from. Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:40) 1) law enforcement occurs there for the first time (not in the polices) Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:41) 2) legitimate needs are not described Lutz Donnerhacke: (09:41) 3) definition of whois (as accurate, timely, ... service) is not founded. Bladel: (09:57) consensus policies: http://www.icann.org/en/general/consensus-policies.htm Alice Jansen: (09:59) FYI - Bill dropped Bladel: (10:03) ongoing policy development or Whois policy milestones.... or something. Lutz Donnerhacke: (10:04) Thank you all Sharon LEMON 2: (10:04) Thanks All, good sleep or good day Alice Jansen: (10:05) Thank you for participating