-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 And we need to make extremely clear what "public interest" or even "interest" means with regards to incumbent ccTLD Managers. And other entities having a bilateral relationship with ICANN. greetings, el el On 2015-02-18 19:24 , "Carlos Raúl G." wrote:
Dear Robin, Avri,
Prof. Scott Hempling, of Georgetown University who is a specialist in regulatory law has a very good one. I know that the Internet is ver special and very different from 20th century public utilities, but sometimes past experience does help.......
Carlos Raúl Gutiérrez +506 8837 7176 (New Number) Enviado desde mi iPhone
El feb 18, 2015, a las 12:02, Robin Gross <robin@ipjustice.org> escribió:
"public interest consistent with human rights and within ICANN's scope."
This is a good compromise and sufficiently addresses my concern that "public interest" alone is too vague and subject to numerous conflicting interpretations.
Thank you, Robin
On Feb 18, 2015, at 9:56 AM, Carlos Raúl G. wrote:
I like It Thanks
Carlos Raúl Gutiérrez +506 8837 7176 (New Number) Enviado desde mi iPhone
El feb 18, 2015, a las 11:36, Avri Doria <avri@acm.org> escribió:
Hi,
On 18-Feb-15 11:51, "Carlos Raúl G." wrote: So perhaps we should be considering "public interest consistent with human rights."
Within ICANN narrowly define technical scope??!
Of course it needs to be in scope. and yet that scope is as hard to define as public interest is. For example, by my definition of 'technical', ICANN does almost nothing technical outside of IANA, unless you include IT..
But over the years the technical scope has been defined in an ICANN context to include all kinds of policy stuff that can be defined as technical in perhaps a legal, financial or organizational context. The boarders on that definition are fuzzy at best.
But if we want to add further conditionalizing words, we could say
"public interest consistent with human rights and within ICANN's scope." [...] -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/
iQIVAwUBVOTcUZcFHaN5RT+rAQL/pxAAsKj7VwJRjf6rGyYObmYRKOjCO+qckRVY PupIEQBvfHDTobccxOMcRE/cAWCwm9jfGVU0LycqSCUuqod4dZJi40ggR4eC6hJp 4dDT0bkXPQlfYsXg2BOC9QW50AALMDAILAiRIVcABWcuXHZQI8F++kJyWzwKNM/0 0NZNdp0DvJwVNrkmBKI9CNKPZy5NH7+ySyi3X46HDCbwoJ3YzFWSFD7vZizBbt80 qzKrONi/Ga3NSDrTFMOiMd3gNwqWNXTWdYvtM3cuJQ+skQ59Cj15ruwpiYKmqngu c7PlJTuWrM4LALxi2ZexvCUBgonQ4akieCMBXrc7dXXs9luy6IG2cj5wfa0+dlJ5 E2povdM8zoEisl72IHzZL+5oYC/c7uuP+nG9zW6Jw4G85BTzetpAQN1n4AS4L4tU orLLzOaioz2TpINLkOzJBgiran17LKZiLsWBEBKfFVZa8KJhlrHC9ywI/4DQgdGu ylY6HIDykrYK5rk/Dkj0rS9ldtL/qKb7/ZmJsxegkWZuatazNxXFCl2zxBQ+F6Fn MYCBauh187MVE3sMimj9RJRbW4dQJ42YT/MIXKQNV91832w522Z0Zw7BDJ9jXSOy ckAbUf2mEG3JrYIqqskkSeO6TJ/ijeW8CAgrH7J2/aOPRzUvzQ++MWOaSTcLagjn Ikl68RPGNcg= =wC5F -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----