Oh no. You are inserting a right here where there is none. The right to privacy regarding the ownership of a domain name. Anonymous speech does not equate to anonymous domain name registration.
That makes no sense - people have a Federal Constitutional right to privacy - See Griswold v Connecticut.
Of course they do, but it is an absurd leap to conclude that this somehow gives people a right to register domains anonymously. It is entirely possible for people to use the Internet without one's own vanity domain, as evidenced by the fact that about 99.9% of Internet users have never registered a domain and never will. A look at the venomous screeds found in any web site's comment section will confirm that the lack of a vanity domain is no bar to anonymous speech.
The registration of a domain requires the owner of the domain to correctly identify oneself to the public when registering the domain name.
"requires" - sez who? A non-responsive answer would be "a self-proclaimed regulator such as ICANN". Self-proclaimation hardly constitutes a legitimate form of "requires".
If you want to register in ICANN's TLDs, you have to play by ICANN's rules. If you prefer some other TLDs, or some other DNS root, you know where to find them. Regards, John Levine, johnl@iecc.com, Primary Perpetrator of "The Internet for Dummies", Please consider the environment before reading this e-mail. http://jl.ly