In 2016��ISOC published its report "Internet Governance �C Why the Multistakeholder Approach Works��. I think It is very helpful to the discussion of evolving multistakeholder model. In the report�� ISOC emphasised that the effectiveness is most important for the multistakeholder decision-making. ISOC also developed four attributes of successful multistakeholder decision-making to guide the next phase of its evolution: 1.inclusiveness and transparency; 2.collective responsibility; 3.effective decision-making and implementation; 4.collaboration through distributed and interoperable governance. We can use these for the issues of evolving MSM�� **inclusiveness and transparency 8. ISSUE: Inclusiveness 11. ISSUE: Accountability 12. ISSUE: Transparency 6. ISSUE: Recruitment 7. ISSUE: Representativeness **collective responsibility 9. ISSUE: Consensus 15. ISSUE: Roles and Responsibilities **effective decision-making and implementation 1. ISSUE: Timing of decision-making: Our processes take too long 2. ISSUE: Complexity 4. ISSUE: Prioritization of Work 5. ISSUE: Demographics 10. ISSUE: Precision in Scoping the Work 13. ISSUE: Costs 16. ISSUE: Efficient Use of Resources 17. ISSUE: Volunteer Burnout 18. ISSUE: Silos 19. ISSUE: Work Processes 21. ISSUE: Terms **collaboration through distributed and interoperable governance 3. ISSUE: Culture 14. ISSUE: Trust 20. ISSUE: Holistic view of ICANN The multistakeholder approach is a toolbox, a way of doing things that can be used anywhere, from solving a specific problem or to helping an institution evolve; not a a single model or ��all or nothing�� solution. In reality there is no single model that works everywhere or for every issue. The multistakeholder approach must adapt to meet new challenges and develop a framework for ongoing improvement. New Issue�� For Evolving MSM��we need some metrics to evaluate how much we improve to bridge the gap between the reality and the ideal. And the ��evoled�� MSM should set up a mechanism of bringing new blood into it. Liu Yue A Researcher of Internet Governance ������ Windows 10 ���ʼ�<https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=550986>Ӧ��