Dear Wang Wei san and all, Thank you for CGP's effort. I checked mss-var-20150430.xml from two viewpoints below: (1) Whether Yoneya's algorithm work fine with C and J LGR-1 (2) Whether C-LGR-1 has conflicts of disposition type For (1), it seemed working fine. - There was no difference between C-LGR-1 and generated C-LGR-2 (This is because J-LGR-1 has no variant) - Variants in generated J-LGR-2 were the same with C and J LGR-M (please let me know if you want to see J-LGR-2) For (2), I found hundreds of conflicts listed below. Here, each mark means the disposition type as: - S: simp - T: trad - B: both - b: blocked CP disposition types U+4E10: SB U+4E11: BS U+4E18: BS U+4E30: BbS U+4E43: BSS U+4E48: BTSS U+4E7E: BTTbbS U+4E86: BSS U+4E91: BS U+4E95: SB U+4EC6: BS U+4EC7: BSbb U+4ED9: BSS U+4EF2: BS U+4EFF: BSbS U+4F0A: BS U+4F19: BS U+4F59: BSb U+4F5B: BBSS U+4F60: TBbbb U+4F63: BS U+4F69: BS U+4F84: BS U+4FDD: BS U+4FDE: BBS U+4FEF: SBS U+500F: BS U+501F: BSS U+5026: BbS U+506C: BS U+5077: BBS U+508D: BS U+50ED: SB U+50F5: BS U+5149: BS U+514B: BSS U+518F: BS U+51A2: BS U+51AC: BS U+51B1: BS U+51C6: BSS U+51CC: BS U+51E0: BS U+51F6: SB U+51FA: BS U+5212: BS U+5228: BS U+522E: BS U+5236: BS U+5238: bBT U+5243: BS U+5269: BBS U+526F: BS U+527D: BS U+527F: BS U+52D6: BS U+52E4: BS U+5343: bBS U+5347: BSS U+535C: BbS U+5360: SB U+5377: BBS U+5382: BS U+5384: BS U+5398: BS U+53CD: BS U+53EA: BSS U+53F0: BSSS U+5401: BS U+5403: BS U+5408: BS U+540A: BS U+540C: bBS U+540E: BS U+5411: BSS U+543B: BSB U+5446: BS U+5468: BS U+5471: BT U+5475: BTbb U+547C: BBbS U+548C: BSS U+549D: BS U+54B1: SB U+54B8: BS U+54BD: BS U+54C4: BSS U+5507: BS U+5546: BS U+5556: BSS U+5582: BS U+5591: BS U+55A7: BS U+563B: BS U+566A: BS U+56DE: BSSS U+56F0: BS U+572D: BS U+5730: BS U+5740: BS U+574F: BbSS U+5751: BS U+5807: BSS U+5824: BS U+58D6: SB U+590D: BSSb U+5925: TB U+592B: SB U+592D: BS U+5938: BS U+5976: bbBbS U+5978: BS U+5996: BS U+5999: BSB U+59DC: BS U+59F9: SB U+5A18: BSS U+5A49: SB U+5B81: BSSbSSb U+5B83: BS U+5BB4: BS U+5BB6: SB U+5C38: BS U+5C40: SBS U+5CA9: BSSS U+5CAD: BBS U+5CB3: BS U+5D0E: SBS U+5D4F: BS U+5DE8: BSb U+5E03: SB U+5E18: BS U+5E19: BS U+5E2D: BS U+5E55: BS U+5E72: SSBSSb U+5E76: SSSBBS U+5E78: SB U+5E84: BSS U+5E95: SB U+5EFF: SB U+5F04: BBS U+5F26: BS U+5F69: BS U+5F81: BSS U+5FA1: BS U+5FAD: SB U+5FB5: TTB U+5FCF: BSS U+5FD7: BS U+5FF5: SB U+601C: BS U+604D: SB U+6052: SB U+6064: SBB U+6096: BS U+60E0: BBS U+6108: BSS U+6127: SB U+613F: BS U+6167: BS U+6247: BS U+624D: BS U+624E: bbBbSSS U+6251: BS U+6258: BS U+625B: BS U+6263: BS U+626F: BS U+627C: BS U+6298: BS U+62AC: BS U+62B5: bBbbS U+62D0: BS U+62DA: SB U+633D: BS U+6346: BS U+634D: bBT U+636E: BSS U+63EA: BS U+647A: TB U+64B0: BS U+6548: SBB U+6597: BSSSSS U+65A4: BbS U+65C5: BS U+65CB: BSb U+65D7: SB U+6606: SSB U+6635: BS U+6696: BS U+6697: SBS U+66F2: BBS U+6717: BS U+671B: BS U+672C: TB U+672D: SSbBbbb U+6731: BS U+6734: BS U+6746: BS U+6760: BS U+676F: BSS U+6770: SB U+677E: BS U+677F: BS U+6781: BS U+6784: SSBS U+679C: BS U+67DC: BS U+67F1: BS U+6816: SBS U+6817: SB U+6838: BS U+6840: BS U+6881: BS U+68CB: BBS U+68F0: BS U+68F1: BS U+68F9: bBS U+6994: SB U+699C: BS U+69A8: SB U+69B7: SB U+6A3D: BS U+6A90: BS U+6A97: BS U+6B32: SB U+6BB7: SB U+6BD7: BS U+6C1B: BS U+6C61: SBB U+6C78: BS U+6C88: BbS U+6CBE: BS U+6CC4: BSb U+6CDB: SSB U+6CDE: BS U+6CE0: BS U+6CE8: BS U+6D01: BS U+6D3C: BSS U+6D3D: SB U+6D59: BS U+6D63: BS U+6D69: BS U+6D82: BSB U+6D8C: BS U+6DC0: BS U+6DCB: BbSbb U+6DEB: SB U+6E05: SBB U+6E38: BS U+6EAA: BBS U+6EAF: SBB U+6F13: BS U+6F2B: BS U+6F3E: BS U+6F84: SB U+7095: SB U+70AE: BSS U+70B3: bSB U+710A: BSS U+7130: BBS U+7167: SSB U+71D5: BS U+72F7: BS U+72F8: BS U+732C: BS U+733F: BS U+73C9: bBS U+73F6: BT U+7403: SB U+7405: BS U+7483: SBS U+7487: SBS U+74F6: BBS U+753A: SB U+754E: SB U+75B1: BS U+75C7: BS U+75F1: SB U+75F4: BS U+75F9: SBS U+7682: SB U+768E: BS U+7693: BSBS U+7696: SB U+772F: BS U+7737: BS U+773A: BS U+777F: SB U+77AD: TbB U+77B0: BS U+77E9: TB U+7827: BS U+786C: TB U+7887: SB U+788C: BS U+7897: TBBS U+78B0: SBS U+7947: BS U+79CB: BBS U+79D8: SB U+79FB: BS U+7A11: BS U+7A17: BS U+7A57: BBS U+7B2E: BS U+7B51: BS U+7B52: BS U+7B56: BBS U+7BA1: SB U+7BAC: BS U+7BEA: SB U+7C97: BSBS U+7CC7: BS U+7CCA: BS U+7CCD: BS U+7CDF: BS U+7CFB: SBSS U+7D2F: BS U+7DAE: SB U+7E9B: BS U+7F38: SB U+7F50: BS U+7F6E: SB U+7F8E: SB U+7FA1: BS U+7FFB: SBB U+8000: bSB U+8003: SB U+809B: SB U+80B4: BS U+80C4: SB U+80CC: SB U+80DC: SB U+80E1: BS U+80ED: BS U+80F3: SB U+814A: SBS U+8198: BS U+81BB: SB U+81F4: SB U+820D: SBB U+82B1: BS U+82B8: BS U+82DF: SB U+8303: SB U+8347: BS U+8349: SBS U+8350: BS U+83F0: TbB U+83F1: BS U+8431: BS U+8457: TB U+8499: SSSB U+8511: BS U+854A: SBBB U+85AF: BS U+85C9: TbB U+85DC: SB U+85E4: SB U+85E9: SB U+8616: SB U+866C: BS U+866E: BS U+86B6: BS U+86D4: SSB U+8737: BS U+8776: SB U+8782: SB U+8815: SB U+8822: SB U+8868: BS U+8892: BS U+88F8: SB U+8C37: SB U+8C46: SB U+8D9F: BS U+8DD6: BS U+8E0A: BS U+8E29: SB U+8F9F: BbS U+8FA8: bbBS U+8FE4: SB U+903E: SB U+9041: BS U+90C1: SBSS U+916C: SBBB U+91C7: SB U+91CC: SSB U+91CE: SB U+962A: TB U+9676: SB U+9699: TB U+96C1: BS U+96C7: SB U+96CD: BS U+96D5: bSBS U+9709: BS U+9713: SB U+9762: BSSS U+99A8: BS U+9B03: bSbB U+9B41: SB U+9D02: BS U+9EBB: bSbBB U+9F39: SB U+9F96: BS Regards, -- Yoshiro YONEYA <yoshiro.yoneya@jprs.co.jp> On Thu, 30 Apr 2015 23:44:32 +0800 王伟 <wangwei@cnic.cn> wrote:
Dear All
CGP updates the code points and variants in CGP-MSS, which will be used as CGP LGR1 to coordinate with J and K.
Please find the attached XML file generated by Mr. QI Chao. Also, we provide a readable EXCEL version for your review.
Please feel free to give your comments
Best Regards Wang Wei
-----邮件原件----- 发件人: 王伟 [mailto:wangwei@cnic.cn] 发送时间: 2015年4月27日 10:15 收件人: 'hotta@jprs.co.jp'; 'KoreanGP@icann.org'; 'ChineseGP@icann.org'; 'JapaneseGP@icann.org' 主题: 答复: [ChineseGP] Proposed Action items before Seoul meeting
Dear ALL
For CGP, ToDo-6 has been done.
ToDo-7 will be sent out after double check this week.
-----邮件原件----- 发件人: chinesegp-bounces@icann.org [mailto:chinesegp-bounces@icann.org] 代 表 HiroHOTTA 发送时间: 2015年4月26日 1:05 收件人: KoreanGP@icann.org; ChineseGP@icann.org; JapaneseGP@icann.org 主题: [ChineseGP] Proposed Action items before Seoul meeting
Dear colleagues in CGP/JGP/KGP,
If I may, in order for us to make our Seoul meeting efficient and fruitful, I'd like to propose what each of us is expected to prepare well before the meeting.
I know I am very pushy but I think at least we must not use our precious time just to understand the information in front of us for a long time.
Please give comments and let's discuss online about the ToDo's before Seoul meeting .
==
[[Premise]]
ToDo-1 <must> Each participant understands what RootLGR is and what is expected for GPs to do.
ToDo-2 <must> Each participant understands Yoneya's algorithm that was already sent to CGP/JGP/KGP by Yoneya and also agreed by C and J in Dallas, which is attached to this mail as well
ToDo-3 <must> Each participant understands MSS concept that was already sent to CGP/JGP/KGP by Dr. Wang Wei, which is attached to this mail along with HiroHOTTA's response
ToDo-4 <expected> Participants agree on Yoneya's algorithm as a framework and also agree on partial usage of MSS to accelerate our discussion ("partial" means "J doesn't need to be considered to be incorporated into MSS") This is expected to be discussed and finalized online before our meeting
[[Integration Algorithm]]
ToDo-5 <expected> J gets IP's feedback on Yoneya's algorithm
[[MSS/LGR-1]]
ToDo-6 <must> C prepares MSS repertoire, which may be equivalent to Chinese LGR-1 repertoire (done?)
ToDo-7 <expected> C prepares Chinese variants within MSS, which may be equivalent to Chinese LGR-1 (planned date is expected to be declared, if not in time for the meeting)
ToDo-8 <must> J prepares Japanese LGR-1 repertoire and variants (there's no variants in Japanese LGR-1 : they were already sent to CGP/JGP/KGP)
ToDo-9 <must> K prepares the basic idea of Korean LGR-1 repertoire and variants
ToDo-10<expected> K prepares Korean LGR-1 repertoire and variants (planned date is expected to be declared, ift LGR-1 does not come in time for the meeting)
ToDo-11<expected> each of CGP/JGP/KGP assesses the repertoires and variants that have already been provided by other GPs as far as possible
[[Logistics/etc.]]
ToDo-12<must> each CGP/JGP/KGP Chair designates a person in charge of ToDo-5 to ToDo-11 well in advance to the meeting (expected to post the (names) in replying this mail by May 1st) - this may accelerate the coordination a lot
ToDo-13<must> convener fixes the agenda through consultation with CJK colleagues (Hiro is pleased to behave as the convener until someone will raise his/her hand)
Hiro
_______________________________________________ ChineseGP mailing list ChineseGP@icann.org https://mm.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/chinesegp