[[--Translated text (es -> en)--]] Subject: RES: my comments on the Amendment From: vanda@uol.com.br As Trasnlation not very clear. Esclarezco few points: My proposal of releccin cuestin peels for over 2 years: concordcon the releccin principle but I think we should reduce to + 1 year (no + 2) the participation of reelected to ensure more opportunities for others candidatearse. The other is sent cuestin (alternate) to ALAC is to reaffirm ALAC decide not LACRALO. I be interesting to know other opinions. Hugs ----- Mensagem original ----- From: lac-discuss-es-bounces@atlarge-lists.icann.org [Mailto: lac-discuss-es-bounces@atlarge-lists.icann.org] Em nome vanda@uol.com.br Posted in: sbado, 3 maro 2012 19:39 To: lac-discuss-es@atlarge-lists.icann.org Cc: 'Heidi Ullrich'; lac-discuss-es@atlarge-lists.icann.org Assunto: [lac-discuss-en] my comments on the Amendment [[- Translated text (in -> en) -]] Subject: My comments on the Amendment From: vanda@uol.com.br Aqumi analysis to share with you everything about the proposed amendments. I'm not sure if my commitment NOMCOMM be able to participate in all sessions, asque decidcompartir my views with you all. Seala I have something to say in the most prominent for below. Thanks VANDA Items proposed by a group My comments 1) the right to vote in ALS LACRALO matters determined by a minimum level of participation This is positive 2) the working languages \u200b\u200bexpanded to francsy Portugus I see no need and may be too expensive.But this is not a main preocupacin. (But I see APRALO working in over 20 languages \u200b\u200bthat have there 3) eliminates the concept of operating by consensus
Desde mi punto de vista esto es contra uno de los principio de la ICANN a consensus
4) creation of Vice Those can not be aadir to normal ALAC representation without the decision to ALAC smismo. Not for LACRALO to decide. Vase tambinms forward in the item 8 5) the clauses of President and Vice eligible for two terms of two each years This make some sense, as the representation in ALAC requires degree of learning, so a year is a short term. But second term will be one year to allow others to participate. 6) creation of the position of Vice-Ministry Just as Vice President 7) LACRALO elect 2 people to be part of ALAC and other 2 as its alternates (diversity requirements shall not apply to choice ALAC member and alternate). I disagree - the diversity apply. The principles of the ICANN states diversidad.La concentration of people of one country, for example, neither democratic nor safe for the organization. (I imagine that if the two major countries of Mexico and Brazil decided to make a strong movement for take in this group, you can control all positions) is not really insurance. It should has diversity. 8) The deputy or assistant can take ALAC representative in case of any inability of the chief representative of ALAC I think this will be submitted to ALAC, we can not decide the next time shall send the ALAC meeting is another 9) ALAC member can be reappointed for a period of 2 nd year two The election is the same principle of one year for a second term to allow other participate. 10) creation of a directory of LACRALO or Board with LACRALO administrative and operational functions. This includes persons elected in LACRALO (President, Vice President, Secretary, Assistant Secretary, the two LACRALO elected representatives and their alternates ALAC) and five Policy Managers who lead work groups within LACRALO and in responsible for selecting members within their groups Policy trabajo.Directores be elected by the General Assembly by simple majority. In my opinion, this will mean too general and not to command troops but does not affect at all. 3 would be good to one member of the Caribbean region and two America region also maintain diversity and yet be reasonable (not there members of both LACRALO really works so I do not think will enough groups to work under 5 political directors). But it is not relevant 11) states that the elections can take place almost This is good, but needs clear tools must be available to prevent one of the members to vote for all ALS under his command - only allow this after check the safety of the tool. 12) the changes would be applicable to existing mandates President, Secretary I do not agree that if he would have a one year term only. The application of change for the benefit of existing members elected sight manipulation. The same people may be a candidate and be elected, but the extension of mandate, looks is not democratic. That's the way ditactors used to maintain in place Totally against. 13) The constitution of the Board of LACRALO be held after the first election to be held immediately at the time of these reforms approved. It is not so relevant. Vanda Scartezini Acesse: http://nomcom.icann.org candidate-mail is! Access: http://nomcom.icann.org and apply! Polo Consultores Asociados IT Trend Alameda Santos 1470 conj. 1407 01418-903 São Paulo, SP, Brazil Tel + 5511 3266.6253 Mobile + 55118181.1464 Dissemine this idia: Enter or research domain or unable to call. Dialing domain Descrio: Descrio: Siter-16-square.png <http://www.siter.com> www.siter.com [[--Original text (es) http://mm.icann.org/transbot_archive/bdaf1e350e.html --]]