Re: [UA-EAI] Question re: wording in UASG 007

In article <dadad825-21ec-f904-74f4-f2776b7f7b60@catalyst.net.nz> you write:

-=-=-=-=-=- -=-=-=-=-=-

UASG 007 version 9, page 24 reads:

"Robust UA-ready software and services may be able to handle and treat all these formats identically, even those which are not RFC-compliant. Nevertheless, UA-ready software should not generate true EAI email addresses only."

Should this rather be "should generate true EAI email addresses only", without the negation?

That whole section needs to be rewritten to about a sentence that says that you cannot rewrite local parts so don't even try. I really wish the document did not mention punycode at all, rather saying A-labels in the DNS context, because it just confuses people. R's, John