HI Mona, Thanks so much for sharing ISOC’s intervention. It makes very interesting and important points. I also wanted to share with you and with others on this list serve DCAD’s comments on Rev1. We could not attend the virtual stakeholder consultation yesterday as we had clashes, but wanted to share it with all of you. The comment below was authored by Dr. Shabbir, my fellow Coordinator, DCAD proposes the following revisions to the WSIS+20 outcome document, Rev-1. These changes are proposed with an aim of ensuring the rights, leadership, and lived experience of persons with disabilities are embedded across implementation, measurement, and governance. The proposed changes include: 1. Original paragraph (para 22): "We call for concerted action by all stakeholders to promote accessibility and equal access to the Internet and digital resources as a priority, including through the availability of accessible and assistive technologies." Proposed revision: "We call for concerted action by all stakeholders to promote accessibility and equal access to the Internet and digital resources as a priority, including through the adoption and enforcement of international accessibility standards such as the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG 2.2) or any such recognized international standards, and the mandatory procurement and integration of assistive technologies across all public digital platforms and ICT initiatives." 2. Original paragraph (para 114): "We are committed to the further development and strengthening of internationally agreed targets, indicators and metrics for universal meaningful and affordable connectivity and digital development." Proposed revision (new clause added at the end): "We are committed to the further development and strengthening of internationally agreed targets, indicators and metrics for universal meaningful and affordable connectivity and digital development, including the systematic collection and reporting of disability-disaggregated data on digital access, usage, accessibility, and affordability, in line with CRPD obligations." 3. Original paragraph (para 88): "Measures are needed to ensure more effective participation by stakeholders from developing countries and underrepresented groups..." Proposed revision: "Measures are needed to ensure more effective participation by stakeholders from developing countries and underrepresented groups, including persons with disabilities, particularly those with lived experience, not only as beneficiaries but as equal contributors and leaders in Internet governance and standard-setting bodies." 4. Original paragraph (para 39): “We recognise that ICTs have helped governments and other stakeholders to address risks associated with natural disasters and facilitated humanitarian assistance at times of crisis through more consistent and remote monitoring of environmental and other hazards, enhancing and developing early warning systems and improving preparedness, response, recovery, rehabilitation and reconstruction.” Proposed revision: “We recognise that ICTs have helped governments and other stakeholders to address risks associated with natural disasters and facilitated humanitarian assistance at times of crisis through more consistent and remote monitoring of environmental and other hazards, enhancing and developing early‑warning systems and improving preparedness, response, recovery, rehabilitation and reconstruction. We further commit to ensuring that such systems and interventions are also accessible, inclusive and responsive to the needs of persons with disabilities; and that early warning communications, evacuation processes, recovery tools and digital information channels adhere to accessibility standards and assistive technology compatibility.” 5. Original paragraph (para 27): “We reiterate the need for the development of local content and services in a variety of languages and formats that are accessible to all people…” Proposed revision: “We reiterate the need for the development of local content and services in a variety of languages and formats that are accessible to all people, and ensure that these are delivered in formats compatible with accessible technologies (e.g., screen readers, captions, sign language, simplified language) to also meet the needs of persons with disabilities.” Some specific Additions: 6. Add to paragraph 12 (vulnerable groups): "...persons with disabilities, with attention to the leadership of people with lived experience..." 7. Add to paragraph 17 (digital public infrastructure): "...inclusive and interoperable digital public infrastructure that adheres to international accessibility standards by default..." 8. Add to paragraph 57 (capacity building): "...to build expertise in technical aspects of digitalisation, with special programs co-designed with organizations of persons with disabilities (OPDs)..." 9. Addition of New Sentence at End of Paragraph 88 (Internet Governance Section): Particular attention should also be given to ensuring the participation and leadership of persons with disabilities, including through appointment to decision-making roles within Internet governance structures at global, regional, and national levels. 10. Addition of New Sentence in Paragraph 58 (Digital Skills & Learning) Suggested Insert (after 1st sentence): Special efforts should be made to co-design and deliver digital capacity building and leadership development programs for persons with disabilities, ensuring that their lived experience informs policymaking, especially in emerging areas like AI, cybersecurity, and data governance. 11. Addition of New Sentence at End of Paragraph 84 (AI Capacity Building): This should include the participation of persons with disabilities, both as beneficiaries and contributors, and establish leadership pathways for experts with lived experience of disability to shape inclusive and ethical AI governance frameworks. Thanks for allowing us to share these remarks Best, Judith Sent from my iPad judith@jhellerstein.com Mobile: +1202333517
On Nov 14, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Mona Gaballa via wsis20 <wsis20@icann.org> wrote:
Hi everyone,
Please find the Internet Society's intervention during the WSIS+20 Virtual Stakeholder Consultation on Rev1 earlier today. On behalf of the Internet Society, I would like to begin by thanking you, DESA and the co-facilitators, for keeping the WSIS process as open and transparent as possible, and for welcoming stakeholders views on t views on the first revision of the zero draft. The Internet Society is committed to bridging the digital divide by supporting connectivity and sustainable infrastructure, and to ensuring the Internet remains an open, secure and trusted global resource for everyone. On this occasion, noting time is running short, we would like to offer some general remarks and recommendations to keep the text crisp, concise and action focused. The Internet is empowering more people, more services, and more development opportunities than ever. Which is precisely why the WSIS+20 review outcome document should reinforce what keeps it open, globally connected, secure, and trustworthy. Firstly, we would like to note that the section entitled “Enabling environment for digital development”, should explicitly include elements that help achieve an enabling environment. Paragraph 48 should include measures such as “proportionate taxation and licensing fees, access to finance, facilitation of public-private partnerships, multistakeholder cooperation, national and regional broadband strategies, efficient allocation of radio frequency spectrum, infrastructure sharing models, community-based approaches, and public access facilities.” Secondly, in paragraph 53, we note the reference to “critical Internet infrastructure”, which has no agreed definition, and would like to call for it’s deletion, as the paragraph already importantly recognizes the efforts to protect infrastructure. Additionally, we welcome the substantive changes introduced to the “Internet Governance” section. Including the permanent mandate of the Internet Governance Forum (IGF) and the recognition of the NETmundial+10 guidelines for multistakeholder collaboration and consensus building. As well as paragraph 120 which provides recommendations on how to strengthen coherence between the WSIS vision and GDC commitments. However, paragraph 101, which invites the Secretary-General to make proposals concerning future funding of the IGF , needs to be done in consultation with existing IGF funders and stakeholders to ensure stable, predictable, and sustainable financial support of the Forum. Regarding paragraph 119, we recommend retaining the call for multistakeholder advice to UNGIS to ensure more effective collaboration, information exchange, and to avoid duplication. As we noted in the previous consultation, the Internet Society will keep working with our global community of chapters, individual and organization members to translate these priorities into additional concrete recommendations as the process reaches its final stages. Our aim is the same as yours: a WSIS+20 outcome that people can rally around, that strengthens multistakeholder collaboration, and that keeps the Internet open, globally connected, secure and trustworthy for everyone. Warm regards, Mona Gaballa, Senior Advisor, Institutional Relations gaballa@isoc.org | +19082799933
internetsociety.org | @internetsociety _______________________________________________
Learn more about the WSIS+20 Outreach Network and review relevant resources: https://go.icann.org/wsis20
Read the public archives for this mailing list: https://mm.icann.org/pipermail/wsis20/
_______________________________________________ By submitting your personal data, you consent to the processing of your personal data for purposes of subscribing to this mailing list accordance with the ICANN Privacy Policy (https://www.icann.org/privacy/policy) and the website Terms of Service (https://www.icann.org/privacy/tos). You can visit the Mailman link above to change your membership status or configuration, including unsubscribing, setting digest-style delivery or disabling delivery altogether (e.g., for a vacation), and so on.
