Dear all, Please find included the agenda and draft resolution (and some proposed action items). In addition, written updates from Annebeth Lange (co-chair WT 5), Wafa Dahmani (ALAC Liaison) and Ben Fuller (GNSO Liaison) are included. Please note that Stephen Has also bene added to the list of people who expressed willingness to stay on the SOP Committee. Kind regards, Bart Agenda and Draft resolutions ccNSO Council Meeting 18 January 2018 1) Welcome and Apologies Attendance list is available at: http://ccnso.icann.org/about/council/attendance.htm 2) Minutes and Actions Minutes 7 December 2017 meeting. Circulated to Council 11 January 2018 Action items Action Item 136-01: The Secretariat is requested to inform the review team accordingly (ccNSO meeting strategy). Completed Action Item 136-02: Secretariat is requested to send email to Council for volunteers (Ethos awards panel). Completed Action Item 136-03: Ask the secretariat to check the references in the current Fast Track documentation and overall recommended policy to understand if and how references to relevant RFC’s is included and report back to Council by February meeting in time for our meeting in Puerto Rico. Ongoing 3) Overview inter-meeting Council decisions Approval of letter to the ICANN Board on Emoji and request to discuss and adopt overall policy IDN ccTLDs Approval Membership application 164 and 165: University of Guam, the ccTLD operator of .gu (Guam), and Djibouti Telecom, the ccTLD operator of .dj (Djibouti) 4) Update & Discussion progress Work Track 5 Subsequent procedures (country and territory names For discussion Update drafting terms of reference Note from Chair of GAC on direction of travel 5) Use of selection criteria by the ccNSO Travel Committee For discussion and decision The ccNSO Travel funding committee was requested to use the selection criteria as proposed in the new guideline and report back to Council. If criteria proof to be useful, they will be included in the Guideline: ccNSO Travel Funding. Draft Action item The ccNSO Council thanks its travel committee for its report, and request the the GRC tot take the results into account and finalize the draft travel guideline by the next Council meeting for adoption by Council. 6) ccNSO-GAC meeting agenda committee 6.1 Appointment of ccNSO Co- Chair For discussion The ccNSO Council should seek co-chair for the agenda committee ccNSO-GAC. Purpose of the committee is to prepare the topics of the f-2-f meetings. Criteria: Council member Understanding and knowledge of GAC (preferably former GAC member) 6.2 Closure of the ccNSO-GAC Liaison Working Group For decision Draft Resolution Background The GAC-ccNSO Liaison Working Group has been dormant since 2010. With the new agreed upon approach, establishing a ccNSO-GAC meeting agenda committee, the Liaison Working Group could be formally closed. Decision The ccNSO Council formally closes the GAC-ccNSO Liaison Working Group and request the secretariat to take all steps to effectuate this decision. For the record, the Council thanks all listed and former members of this Working Group. 7) Next Steps ccNSO Organisational Review: Appointment of working party For discussion Background The ccNSO Organisational Review has been deferred one year until mid- 2018. The ccNSO was requested to conduct a voluntary internal review. The ccNSO GRC is effectively taking care of this and as part of the process it reviewed current status of implementation of recommendation first organizational review of the ccNSO. The ccNSO is requested to appoint a working party, which will act as point of contact and organize the ccNSO activities pertaining to the ccNSO Organisational review. Alternative approaches are: Request the GRC to undertake this role Establish separate, working party Draft Resolution The ccNSO Council requests members of the ccNSO GRC to participate in the working party that will act as point of contact and organize the ccNSO activities pertaining to the upcoming ( 2018) second ccNSO Organisational review. In addition, the secretariat is requested to send a call for volunteers to the ccTLD community, for additional members of the working party. 8) Reconfirmation membership SOPC & call for volunteers For decision Following adoption of the updated charter, the chair of SOPC reached out to membership to seek re-confirmation of membership. The following persons intend to remain members: Wafa Dahmani, .tn Irina Danelia, .ru Rosalia Morales, .cr Andreas Musielak, .de Philip Du Bois, .be Roelof Meijer, .nl Pablo Rodriguez, .pr Giovanni Seppia, .eu (Chair) Barrack Otieno, AfTLD Leonid Todorov, APTLD Michael Vassilakis, .gr Additional Confirmation of membership: Stephen Deerhake, reconfirmed before the seasonal holiday. In addition, the Committee requests the Council to seek additional volunteers. Draft Resolution The ccNSO Council reconfirms the following persons as members of the Strategic Operational Planning Committee for the term of 2 years: Wafa Dahmani, .tn Irina Danelia, .ru Rosalia Morales, .cr Andreas Musielak, .de Philip Du Bois, .be Roelof Meijer, .nl Pablo Rodriguez, .pr Giovanni Seppia, .eu (Chair) Barrack Otieno, AfTLD Leonid Todorov, APTLD Michael Vassilakis, .gr Stephen Deerhake The Council requests the secretariat to inform the SOPC about the re-confirmation and sent out a call for volunteers as soon as possible 9) Update SSR 2 & WHOIS/RDS discussions 9.1 Update on discussions SSR 2 and next steps. For discussion 9.2 ccNSO Participation WHOIS- RDS review In May 2017 the ccNSO informed the ICANN Board of directors that is did not consider itself to be in in a position to nominate volunteers for the following reasons (see: https://ccnso.icann.org/sites/default/files/file/field-file-attach/2017-05/s...): Unclear scope and process to define scope. The scope of the RDS /WHOIS 2 review has been defined. Concurrent processes relating to RDS /WHOIS. Impact of EU GDPR and its implementation. The ccNSO expected that the GDPR and its required implementation would have a major impact on RDS and hence on any review, implying that any review of current processes and policies would be affected by the GDPR. The Chair of the ccNSO was approached by the RDS/WHOIS review team to consider participation (see background material), as the Review Team has developed the terms of Reference for the review (see background material). Questions for discussion Given current state of affairs with respect to RDS-WHOIS review should the ccNSO participate in the RDS/WHOIS 2 review process/ have all these concerns been addressed? If the ccNSO intends to participate, who to nominate? Nominate candidates from the original call for volunteers? Other volunteers? (the original list of applicants can be found here: https://community.icann.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=63145857) Draft action item: following the discussion the chair is requested to propose a resolution for an on-line decision as soon as feasible. 10) Council Statement on Operational Standards for Specific Reviews For discussion The GRC has prepared a draft for consideration by the ccNSO Council. Document to be circulated on Monday. The Public comment period has bene extended until 2 February. Councillors are requested to submit comments if any by 25 February, which will then be incorporated. The final text needs to be adopted by Council by 1 February Draft Action items: The Councillors to provide comment on-line by 25 January 2018 23.59 UTC. The Chair to propose final text for on-line adoption by 29 January 2018, 23.59 UTC. And submit the agreed upon Council Statement by 2 February 2018. 11) Re-appointment working party EPSRP to assist implementation of changes Fast Track Process. For decision: appointment of working party to provide feed-back The ccNSO has been requested to re-install the working party EPSRP to assist in the implementation of the updated version of the IDN ccTLD Fast Track Implementation Plan. Draft Resolution The ccNSO Council re-installs the working party EPSRP and mandates its chair to seek 2 volunteers that could provide feed-back and comments on the implementation details for the amended “Final Implementation Plan for IDN ccTLD Fast Track Process” . 12) PDP Retirement 12.1 Update progress 12.2 Appointment new chair: Stephen Deerhake (nominated by the WG) The current chair (Nigel Roberts) intends to step down as chair no later than the f-2-f meeting in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Stephen Deerhake has been nominated by the WG to replace Nigel as chair. Draft Resolution Background The current chair of the ccNSO Policy Development Process Working group on retirement of ccTLDs Nigel Roberts has been designated to become a member of the ICANN Board of Directors and as such recused from being chair of the PDP WG on retirement of ccTLDs. Stephen Deerhake was nominated by the members of the WG to replace him as chair. Decision Following the nomination of the working group members, the ccNSO Council appoints Stephen Deerhake as chair of the ccNSO Policy Development Process Working group on retirement of ccTLDs no later than by 15 March 2018, 23.59 UTC. 13) Special Elections European Region Nigel Roberts indicated he intends to step down from his position as a Councillor from the European region in the course of 2018. His regular term would end in March 2020. As a result, the members in the EU region need to elect a new member to the ccNSO Council for the remainder of his period (until March 2020). Discussion on timing. Draft action item The secretariat is requested to propose a timeline taking into account the results of today’s discussion on timing and inform the Council by 2 February 2018 to allow Council to take a decision, if any, by its next meeting. 14) ICANN 61 14.1 ccNSO Council meetings Sunday, 11 March (Day 2) 12:15-13:30 – ccNSO Council Preparatory Meeting (lunch) 13:30-15:00 – ccNSO Council Workshop 17:00-18:30 – Joint ALAC / ccNSO – TBC Monday, 12 March (Day 3) 12:15-13:30 – Joint ccNSO / GNSO Tuesday, 13 March (Day 4) 11:00-12:00 – Joint Board / ccNSO – Room TBD 15:15-16:15 – Joint ccNSO / GAC Wednesday, 14 March (Day 5) 17:00-18:30 – ccNSO Council Face to Face Meeting 14.2 ICANN 61 ccNSO Meetings Agenda 14.3 Proposed Topics meeting with ICANN Board Communication ccNSO related Board decision to ccNSO: Timing, interpretation of decision, work load impact. Impact leveling of funding on priorities and Priority setting. Other? 14.4 Topics meeting ccNSO- GAC Progress WT 5 & role of ccNSO, GAC in process FAQ ccTLD delegation, transfer and revocation of ccTLDs Other? 15) CSC, RZERC and ECA related updates 15.1 CSC update (Byron) 15.2 RZERC update (placeholder) 15.3 Empowered Community Administration update (placeholder) 15.4 CSC Charter review (Abdalla) 16) Council Updates 16.1 Chair Update 16.2 Vice-Chair Update 16.3 Councilors Update 16.4 Regional Organizations Update 16.5 Secretariat update 17) WG update 17.1 GRC update (Katrina) 17.2 CCWG Auction Proceeds (Ching) 17.3 CCWG Internet Governance (Young Eum) 17.4 CCWG Accountability WS 2 18) Liaison Updates 18.1 GNSO Update 18.2 ALAC update 19) Next meetings (2018) 15 February – 12:00 UTC (was 11.00 UTC) 14 March – face to face, San Juan 26 April – 18:00 UTC 24 May – 12:00 UTC 27 June – face to face, Panama City 23 August – 12:00 UTC (July and Aug combined) 20 September 18:00 UTC October – face to face, Barcelona (date tbd) 15 November – 11:00 UTC 13 December – 17:00 UTC 20) AOB 21) Closure