Dear Eric Brunner-Williams, If you are referring to the Scenarios shown in the third column, Item # 40 is a scenario outlined by Robert Guerra. Here is the complete list BC - # 1 - 10 SSAC # 11 Weill # 12-20 (Can't find the email / document where Weill had outlined these scenarios. Robert, do you have the original mail from Weill that listed 12-20, please ? ) Olivier # 21 -34 Siva # 35-39 Robert # 40 Siva # 41- 45 As for the mitigation options, Olivier's options are copied against 29 -32, I started outlining some preventive / mitigation strategies for the rest of the scenarios and waiting for participation. Thank you Sivasubramanian M Sivasubramanian M <https://www.facebook.com/sivasubramanian.muthusamy> On Wed, Jan 14, 2015 at 8:09 AM, Eric Brunner-Williams < ebw@abenaki.wabanaki.net> wrote:
Siva,
Thanks again. Is there a reason why Robert is identified separately? Is his contribution (your #40) made separately from those (not yet present in your list) made by the SSAC?
Eric
On 1/13/15 5:44 PM, Sivasubramanian M wrote:
Thanks Eric. Did some more work.
The authors are:
Olivier Crepin-LeBlond Robert Guerra Business Constituency Mathieu Weill SSAC
Sivasubramanian M <https://www.facebook.com/sivasubramanian.muthusamy>
On Wed, Jan 14, 2015 at 6:44 AM, Eric Brunner-Williams < ebw@abenaki.wabanaki.net> wrote:
Siva,
I'll pick those up tomorrow. Could you confirm who the authors of these are, e.g., the "Olivier", the "Robert", etc., in case there is a need for clarification.
Thanks in advance, Eric
On 1/13/15 12:40 PM, Sivasubramanian M wrote:
Thank You Eric. I have added four more scenarios and wrote down some preventive / mitigation pointers.
Sivasubramanian M <https://www.facebook.com/sivasubramanian.muthusamy>
On Wed, Jan 14, 2015 at 1:04 AM, Eric Brunner-Williams < ebw@abenaki.wabanaki.net> wrote:
Colleagues,
During yesterday's ConCall Sivasubramanian M provided a link to a set of contingencies / scenarios he is managing. For my own purposes I've used some of each of his contingencies / scenarios to form a short, and possibly relevant identifier.
This note is simply informative, providing the URL of the original, below my personal short identifiers, to allow Mr. Sivasubramanian to know that I'm reading his document, and to provide you all with the URL for your own purposes.
Eric Brunner-Williams Eugene, Oregon
1 Cancellation of the AoC 2 Flight to avoid jurisdiction 3 Insolvency 4 Applicant Support Revisited 5 Ignoring SSAC 6 GAC Votes 7 .xxx redux 8 Contested gTLD Redelegation 9 Enjoined Delegation 10 Contested ccTLD Redelegation 11 Governmental sanctions and restrictions 12 Domain industry financial crisis 13 Significant financial contributor fee escrow 14 Competing new technology 15 Governance crisis 16 Major corruption or fraud 17 Antitrust or class action 18 Chairman, CEO or major officer conduct 19 Major personal data leak 20 Financial crisis affecting Icann's reserves 21 IANA Customer Standing Committee (CSC) failure 22 IANA Periodic Review Team (PRT) failure 23 Current IANA functions operator threatens litigation 24 A stakeholder captures a multi-stakeholder committee 25 A stakeholder ensures overwhelming control of processes 26 A country captures the process of the PRT 27 Members of the PRT have their lives threatened 28 The PRT is overwhelmed with complaints 29 Terrible appeals judgments by Independent Appeals Panel 30 Current IANA functions operator threatens litigation 31 Rogue Board 32 Rogue Employees 33 Contracting Entity refuses to follow policy or instructions from PRT 34 Operator goes rogue 35 ALAC and GNSO do not see eye to eye 36 ccTLDs and gTLDs strongly disagree 37 ccTLDs that are not part of ICANN oppose ccTLD policies and programs 38 Escalated conflicts between ICANN Board and Staff 39 Nomcom is highly politicized 40 NTIA holds off transferring control until all conditions are met
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1QVC12Q-NuB35pyaBirUDF85DBR_oFHkEYC5vbWu0...