Comments-ccnso-pdp3-retire-cctlds-05may20

Download

comments-ccnso-pdp3-retire-cctlds-05may20@icann.org

May 2020

2 participants
2 discussions

ccNSO PDP3: Initial Proposals for Process to Retire ccTLDs
by Dr Clement Genty May 21, 2020

May 21, 2020

Hi, The ccTLDs have been modelled on the ISO 3166-1 alpha 2 standard to avoid, as Postel said, IANA having to choose what a country is or is not. ISO is based on purely technical considerations. ICANN is a technical organization but includes public participation for public input, which I do. This humanism on the part of ICANN must remain a constant and ICANN must not act in a dichotomous way. The example of the .SU, which is still working is a good example of this. Tuvalu, .TV, ccTLD that has become a gccTLD according to Google, is a territory that risks disappearing in case of global warming. So according to the ISO, the TV code will no longer exist. But should we delete a code of a country and therefore its past, its history? A few years ago, I had contacted the ISO to activate the JU code for Julia Island, a French island located at the south of Sicily. I didn't get a positive answer as the island Julia was swallowed up by the waters. But wasn't there a past on this island? It seems important to me that ICANN goes beyond purely technical considerations and that it keeps any ccTLD that has already existed. Otherwise its role would be purely technical and nothing would prevent it from being included in the ITU. Regards, Clement -- Dr Clement Genty Meursault (Côte d'Or) - France www.genty.info

1 0

Enough Time
by ICANN Registrar Secura May 18, 2020

May 18, 2020

The report says,the ccTLD shall be removed from the Root Zone 5 years (Default Retirement Date) from the date of this notice. Five years are enough time for registrants and registrars to prepare for the situation. I assume, that in many cases the retired cc TLD is replace by a new cc TLD. We propose, that the grandfathering rule is applied and the owners of a name at the old cc TLD have the right to register their names prior to others. Mit freundlichen Grüßen/ with kind regards, Hans-Peter Oswald Geschäftsführer ----------------------------------------- SECURA GMBH Frohnhofweg 18 Tel +49(0)221 257 12 13 D-50858 Köln Fax +49(0)221 925 22 72 www.domainregistry.de secura(a)domainregistry.de Tel (US/CA toll-free): +1 866 655 3680 ------------------------------------------------------- Geschäftsführer/CEO Amtsgericht Köln HRB 31240 Hans-Peter Oswald Ust.-IdNr/VATID DE196859556 ------------------------------------------------------- +++ ICANN ACCREDITED REGISTRAR OF TOP-LEVEL-DOMAINS +++

1 0

Results per page: