September 2015 - gtld-tech - lists.icann.org

Draft RDAP Operational Profile for gTLD Registries and Registrars
by Francisco Arias Jan. 16, 2016

Jan. 16, 2016

Dear colleagues, As you may know, most gTLD registries and registrars have a provision in their respective agreements to implement RDAP. However, before requesting RDAP implementation, we would like your thoughts and inputs on which features, basic parameters, and objects will need to be implemented. We are calling this document the RDAP Operational Profile for gTLD Registries and Registrars. Attached you will find the first draft of the RDAP Operational Profile for gTLD Registries and Registrars (in Word and PDF formats). We are planning a session on the subject during both the ICANN meeting in Dublin and the IETF in Yokohama. Your feedback on this early document would be greatly appreciated by 9 November 2015. By then, we expect to have an updated document that we plan to publish for public comment around mid November. Regards, -- Francisco Arias Director, Technical Services Domain Name Services & Industry Engagement Global Domains Division ICANN

10 25

Definition of "% of DNS Service Availability" used in Registrant Survey
by Chris Baker Sept. 28, 2015

Sept. 28, 2015

Hello, I was reading the recent ICANN Releases Phase One Registrant Survey on the Domain Name Landscape and saw mention in the metrics section a "% of DNS Service Availability." I was wondering if there was a definition for this measurement available? Possibly some details about how data is collected where it is collected from? ... etc Please let me know if you have any questions, Thank you for your time, CBaker Reference: "% of DNS Service Availability ( Present SLA is 100% )" Category - Trust in http://newgtlds.icann.org/en/reviews/cct/iag-metrics-final-recs-26sep14-en.…

2 1

About repository identifier
by liangchenguang＠zdns.cn Sept. 15, 2015

Sept. 15, 2015

Dear Sir or Madam, I had to write e-mail to iana,but did not receive a reply.You acknowledge that i send to her acceptance? Mail content: We want to apply for the repository identifier below , among which "zdns" is for registrar and the other 22 IDs are all TLDs. Please check whether they are correct or not. Change Controller ID: zdns wang top show citic shop ren sohu bagua wangzhi wangzhan zhongxin yule wangdian sb zhaopin woaini shishang canting cishan sc xinwen jituan Change Controller Name: zdns wang top show citic shop ren sohu bagua wangzhi wangzhan zhongxin yule wangdian sb zhaopin woaini shishang canting cishan sc xinwen jituan Change Controller Email:fengshuo@zdns.cn Reference/Contact ID:fengshuo Reference/Contact Name:fengshuo Reference/Contact Email:fengshuo@zdns.cn Thank you. 梁晨光产品经理互联网域名系统北京市工程研究中心有限公司座机：010-58813244 手机：13811479777 邮件：liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn 网址：www.zdns.cn 地址：北京市海淀区中关村南4街4号中国科学院软件园1号楼邮编：100190

1 0

About repository identifier
by liangchenguang＠zdns.cn Sept. 8, 2015

Sept. 8, 2015

Dear Sir or Madam, We want to apply for the repository identifier below , among which "zdns" is for registrar and the other 22 IDs are all TLDs. Please check whether they are correct or not. Change Controller ID: zdns wang top show citic shop ren sohu bagua wangzhi wangzhan zhongxin yule wangdian sb zhaopin woaini shishang canting cishan sc xinwen jituan Change Controller Name: zdns wang top show citic shop ren sohu bagua wangzhi wangzhan zhongxin yule wangdian sb zhaopin woaini shishang canting cishan sc xinwen jituan Change Controller Email:fengshuo@zdns.cn Reference/Contact ID:fengshuo Reference/Contact Name:fengshuo Reference/Contact Email:fengshuo@zdns.cn Thank you. 梁晨光产品经理互联网域名系统北京市工程研究中心有限公司座机：010-58813244 手机：13811479777 邮件：liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn 网址：www.zdns.cn 地址：北京市海淀区中关村南4街4号中国科学院软件园1号楼邮编：100190

1 0

Fw: Re: About repository identifier
by liangchenguang＠zdns.cn Sept. 7, 2015

Sept. 7, 2015

FYI. 梁晨光产品经理互联网域名系统北京市工程研究中心有限公司座机：010-58813244 手机：13811479777 邮件：liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn 网址：www.zdns.cn 地址：北京市海淀区中关村南4街4号中国科学院软件园1号楼邮编：100190 From: liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn Date: 2015-09-07 17:00 To: Kuhl CC: 高雷; gtld-tech; os_zhangjun Subject: Re: Re: [gtld-tech] About repository identifier Dear Sir or Madam, Sorry, the information in the last email is wrong, this is the update information. Change Controller ID: zdns wang top show citic shop ren sohu bagua wangzhi wangzhan zhongxin yule wangdian sb zhaopin woaini shishang canting cishan sc xinwen jituan Change Controller Name: zdns wang top show citic shop ren sohu bagua wangzhi wangzhan zhongxin yule wangdian sb zhaopin woaini shishang canting cishan sc xinwen jituan Change Controller Email:fengshuo@zdns.cn Reference/Contact ID:fengshuo Reference/Contact Name:fengshuo Reference/Contact Email:fengshuo@zdns.cn Thank you. 梁晨光产品经理互联网域名系统北京市工程研究中心有限公司座机：010-58813244 手机：13811479777 邮件：liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn 网址：www.zdns.cn 地址：北京市海淀区中关村南4街4号中国科学院软件园1号楼邮编：100190 From: liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn Date: 2015-09-07 16:28 To: Kuhl CC: 高雷; gtld-tech; os_zhangjun Subject: Re: Re: [gtld-tech] About repository identifier Dear Sir or Madam, Thank you for your response. We want to apply for the repository identifier below , among which "zdns" is for registrar and the other 22 IDs are all TLDs. Please check whether they are correct or not. Change Controller ID: zdns wang top show citic shop ren sohu &#x7f51 &#x5740 &#x7f51 &#x7ad9 &#x7f51 &#x5e97 &#x516b &#x5366 &#x4e2d &#x4fe1 &#x5a31 &#x4e50 &#x5546 &#x6807 &#x62db &#x8058 &#x6211 &#x7231 &#x4f60 &#x65f6 &#x5c1a &#x9910 &#x5385 &#x6148 &#x5584 &#x5546 &#x57ce &#x65b0 &#x95fb &#x96c6 &#x56e2 Change Controller Name: zdns wang top show citic shop ren sohu &#x7f51 &#x5740 &#x7f51 &#x7ad9 &#x7f51 &#x5e97 &#x516b &#x5366 &#x4e2d &#x4fe1 &#x5a31 &#x4e50 &#x5546 &#x6807 &#x62db &#x8058 &#x6211 &#x7231 &#x4f60 &#x65f6 &#x5c1a &#x9910 &#x5385 &#x6148 &#x5584 &#x5546 &#x57ce &#x65b0 &#x95fb &#x96c6 &#x56e2 Change Controller Email:fengshuo@zdns.cn Reference/Contact ID:fengshuo Reference/Contact Name:fengshuo Reference/Contact Email:fengshuo@zdns.cn Thank you. 梁晨光产品经理互联网域名系统北京市工程研究中心有限公司座机：010-58813244 手机：13811479777 邮件：liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn 网址：www.zdns.cn 地址：北京市海淀区中关村南4街4号中国科学院软件园1号楼邮编：100190 From: Rubens Kuhl Date: 2015-09-07 11:33 To: liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn CC: gtld-tech; 高雷 Subject: Re: [gtld-tech] About repository identifier On Sep 6, 2015, at 10:12 PM, liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn wrote: Dear Sir or Madam, A shall be part of the ROID and the identifier shall be registered by IANA. What dose the Controller Email and Reference/Contact Email mean? Change Controller Email and Reference/Contact Email Is the information below right?we want to ues "zdns" as our repository identifier for all our tlds. Although it's not what ICANN prefers, I don't see many options for IDN TLDs... they would prefer the TLD itself due to the possibility a business transaction or a back-end change. Also, RFCs are not totally clear where RoIDs must be unique between domains and contacts, but just in case you could use ZDNHDL and ZDNSDOM, ZDNSHDL and ZDNS etc. Change Controller ID: #x007A #x0064 #x006E #x0073 Change Controlled ID doesn't need to be expressed in this notation, although it could be ZDNS Change Controller Name:#x007A #x0064 #x006E #x0073 Same as above. Reference/Contact ID:#x007A #x0064 #x006E #x0073 This could a person's name represented like Liang_Chen_Guang or a role name Back_End_Registry_Admin Reference/Contact Name:#x007A #x0064 #x006E #x0073 This could Liang Chen Guang, Back End Registry Admin Do we need to provide other information to prove our identity? There is no such thing. Obama could use ZDNS as RoID unique suffix if he registers first... Argentinians might not like the AusRegistry registered AR, but sounds like a good suffix since AusRegistry contains more than 8 letters. Some registries clearly went for random IDs (Q9JYB4C, for instance). Rubens

1 0

About repository identifier
by liangchenguang＠zdns.cn Sept. 7, 2015

Sept. 7, 2015

Dear Sir or Madam, A shall be part of the ROID and the identifier shall be registered by IANA. What dose the Controller Email and Reference/Contact Email mean? Change Controller Email and Reference/Contact Email Is the information below right?we want to ues "zdns" as our repository identifier for all our tlds.Change Controller ID: #x007A #x0064 #x006E #x0073Change Controller Name:#x007A #x0064 #x006E #x0073Reference/Contact ID:#x007A #x0064 #x006E #x0073 Reference/Contact Name:#x007A #x0064 #x006E #x0073 Do we need to provide other information to prove our identity? 梁晨光产品经理互联网域名系统北京市工程研究中心有限公司座机：010-58813244 手机：13811479777 邮件：liangchenguang(a)zdns.cn 网址：www.zdns.cn 地址：北京市海淀区中关村南4街4号中国科学院软件园1号楼邮编：100190

3 4

URS and replay attacks
by Rubens Kuhl Sept. 1, 2015

Sept. 1, 2015

@ll, I'm wondering what we have, if any, in resources to prevent URS replay attacks. The threat scenario we've made include access to the "Sent Items" folder of an URS Provider, without access to PGP information. With such access, domains that already received URS-Lock and URS-Suspend commands might be subject to lock or suspension again, even if there is not, at that time, an URS procedure ongoing. That could even happen with a new registrant of that domain. I couldn't find anything in the requirements or URS Provider RFIs that would generate information capable of mitigating this threat... am I missing something ? Rubens

2 2