- Gdd-gnso-ppsai-impl - lists.icann.org

PPSAI IRT: Accreditation Model Comments Due Friday 30 May
by Jessica Puccio June 6, 2025

June 6, 2025

Hello IRT, Please find a few reminders related to the current IRT task and next IRT session below. Current IRT Task Please provide your input on the accreditation models document<https://docs.google.com/document/d/14FEv67ER-Qnz2iKiYCCGY8bK4Gky9Thi/edit#h…> by Friday, 30 May. Thanks to all who have contributed already. You can find responses to the comments received thus far in the IRT comment tracker<https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1fMhQNnxEM9l4RsFc3cmw62RwhADHSICFId4…>. In reviewing your comments, we identified areas where language should be updated for consistency. These updates have been highlighted in yellow for the IRT’s reference. Next IRT Session The IRT’s next session will be held on Wednesday, 11 June 07:00 UTC at ICANN83<https://icann83.sched.com/event/246XK/gds-ppsai-irt-working-session>. This session will focus on the input received on the accreditation models and next steps for the IRT’s work. Please let us know if you have not received invitations for the June session. We look forward to connecting in Prague. Best, Jason Sr. Manager, Reviews and Stakeholder Support Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) www.icann.org<http://www.icann.org> -- Jessica Puccio Sr Coordinator, Review Support and Accountability Projects Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN<http://www.icann.org/>)

6 6

PPSAI IRT Session #20: Thursday 15 May 2025 Followup
by Dana Kuebler May 20, 2025

May 20, 2025

Hello IRT, Thanks to all who participated in last Thursday’s IRT session (#20). The recordings and transcripts are available here<https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/IRT/pages/200572987/15+Ma…>. Reminders: * Current task: IRT input on the accreditation models paper is due by Friday, 30 May. * Next IRT session: The next IRT session will be held on Wednesday, 11 June at ICANN83. The 29 May IRT session (#21) is cancelled to give members more time to work on the models paper. Please find more information on the IRT’s current task and project schedule below. Best, Jason IRT Task: Task# Description Due Date 20250512 Review and comment on Ext: IRT Doc - Accreditation Models (12MAY2025)<https://docs.google.com/document/d/14FEv67ER-Qnz2iKiYCCGY8bK4Gky9Thi/edit#h…> 30 May 2025 IRT input is needed on the models to identify whether any of these options cannot be implemented in accordance with the policy recommendations and why, and where further GNSO guidance is needed. To support your comments, please cite: · the PPSAI Final Report, · discussions in the original PDP Working Group, and/or · discussions in the former IRT where appropriate Avoid IRT comments that: · Identify a personal accreditation model preference, or one based on SO/AC/group affiliation, rather than making an assessment based on the scope given to us by the Final Report. · Identify known implementation challenges which have already been noted and listed for further implementation planning discussions. Reminder: only highlight the specific area of related text when making comments. Schedule: * ICANN83 Prep Week Tuesday & Wednesday 27 - 28 May (Schedule<https://icann83.sched.com/>) * ICANN83 PPSAI IRT Session #22 Wednesday 11 June - 07:00 UTC (Session Link<https://icann83.sched.com/event/246XK/gds-ppsai-irt-working-session>) * Target Milestone - 26 June 2025, finalize IRT input on threshold Question B<https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1rqfRaG1yL8HU48u0_3rIHkREoWN0Psr0rT_…>

1 0

IRT Session Thur 15 May @15:30UTC **Please attend for Introduction of Accreditation Models and IRT Task Review**
by Jason Kean May 13, 2025

May 13, 2025

Dear IRT, The next IRT meeting is scheduled for Thursday 15 May @15:30 UTC. During this session, we will introduce three accreditation models ICANN org believes align with the PPSAI Final Report policy recommendations’ intent and review the IRT’s task (below) in greater detail. Please make every effort to attend this important session. The IRT’s input will inform Threshold Question B<https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1rqfRaG1yL8HU48u0_3rIHkREoWN0Psr0rT_…>: Can an accreditation model without a formal Accreditation Program remain consistent with the policy recommendations? This is based on the IRT comment asking if the community had ever concluded that a formal Accreditation Program was needed/wanted, having found no evidence in previous discussions. IRT Task: Review and comment on accreditation models<https://docs.google.com/document/d/14FEv67ER-Qnz2iKiYCCGY8bK4Gky9Thi/edit?u…>. Due Friday, 30 May 2025 IRT input is needed on the models to identify whether any of these options cannot be implemented in accordance with the policy recommendations and why, and where further GNSO guidance is needed. To support your comments, please cite: * the PPSAI Final Report, * discussions in the original PDP Working Group, and/or * discussions in the former IRT where appropriate Avoid IRT comments that: * Identify a personal accreditation model preference, or one based on SO/AC/group affiliation, rather than making an assessment based on the scope given to us by the Final Report. * Identify known implementation challenges which have already been noted and listed for further implementation planning discussions. Reminder: only highlight the specific area of related text when making comments. We look forward to seeing you this Thursday. Best, Jason Jason Kean Sr. Manager, Reviews and Stakeholder Support Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) www.icann.org<http://www.icann.org> Upcoming Schedule: * 15 May @15:30 UTC: IRT meeting introducing the accreditations models and detailing IRT task instructions. * 27-28 May: ICANN 83 Prep Week. The Prep Week schedule<https://icann83.sched.com/> will be published on 5 May 2025 * 30 May: Deadline for IRT to submit its comments on the accreditation models. * 11 June: ICANN83 session in Prague from 9:00am - 10:15am local time. The IRT will discuss the input provided on the accreditations models. * To register for ICANN83, visit: https://events.icann.org/icann83/registration

3 3

Re: [Ext] Re: IRT Session Thur 15 May @15:30UTC **Please attend for Introduction of Accreditation Models and IRT Task Review**
by Jason Kean May 13, 2025

May 13, 2025

Hello Volker, Thank you for your response. We look forward to discussion on your points within the Accreditation Models document and during the upcoming IRT session. Regarding your questions as to whether this exercise is premature, whether the current policy is fit for purpose, and whether changes are necessary, these are the very questions we will be posing to the GNSO Council via the Threshold Questions as part of this initial phase of implementation planning. The GNSO Council will then provide guidance as appropriate based on its discussion on the Threshold Questions posed and the information provided. We hope to see you at this Thursday’s meeting. Best, Jason Jason Kean Sr. Manager, Reviews and Stakeholder Support Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) www.icann.org<http://www.icann.org> From: Volker Greimann <volker.greimann(a)centralnic.com> Date: Monday, May 12, 2025 at 4:51 PM To: "gdd-gnso-ppsai-impl(a)icann.org" <gdd-gnso-ppsai-impl(a)icann.org> Cc: Karen Lentz <karen.lentz(a)icann.org>, Leon Grundmann <leon.grundmann(a)icann.org>, Jessica Puccio <jessica.puccio(a)icann.org>, Jason Kean <jason.kean(a)icann.org> Subject: [Ext] Re: [Gdd-gnso-ppsai-impl] IRT Session Thur 15 May @15:30UTC **Please attend for Introduction of Accreditation Models and IRT Task Review** Hi, are we not putting the cart before the horse with this? Should we not first determine whether the current policy is ft for purpose and whether changes are necessary, and if so, which ones? The last time we danced this dance with ICANN (back in the Cyrus days) ICANN came up with a model similar to Model 1 and then opined that the fees it would need to charge would be ridiculously high to an extent that it would disincentivise any potential accreditee from seeking that accreditation, essentially solving the whois privacy "issue" by ensuring there were no more privacy services. Secondly, there is not a single reason why registrars that offer these services would or should be forced to sign another agreement as the RAA is already sufficient in regulating the issues of affiliated providers. This would just add additional costs with negligible benefits and therefore any such model should be rejected. Model 2: I do not understand Model 2 as presented: No new accreditation agreement, but we must obtain an accreditation anyway? In general the basic principle of a light-weight, self-policing model that relies on consensus policy and the RAA is to be supported however. Less is more. Sincerely, Volker Greimann General Counsel & Head of Policy and Compliance - Online Division volker.greimann(a)centralnic.com Office: +49-172-6367025 Web: www.teaminternet.com Team Internet Group PLC (AIM:TIG). Registered Office: 4th Floor, Saddlers House, 44 Gutter Lane, London, United Kingdom, EC2V 6BR. Team Internet is a company registered in England and Wales with the company number 8576358. ________________________________ From: Jason Kean via Gdd-gnso-ppsai-impl <gdd-gnso-ppsai-impl(a)icann.org> Sent: 12 May 2025 7:28 PM To: gdd-gnso-ppsai-impl(a)icann.org <gdd-gnso-ppsai-impl(a)icann.org> Cc: Karen Lentz <karen.lentz(a)icann.org>; Leon Grundmann <leon.grundmann(a)icann.org>; Jessica Puccio <jessica.puccio(a)icann.org>; Jason Kean <jason.kean(a)icann.org> Subject: [Gdd-gnso-ppsai-impl] IRT Session Thur 15 May @15:30UTC **Please attend for Introduction of Accreditation Models and IRT Task Review** Dear IRT, The next IRT meeting is scheduled for Thursday 15 May @15:30 UTC. During this session, we will introduce three accreditation models ICANN org believes align with the PPSAI Final Report policy recommendations’ intent and review the IRT’s task (below) in greater detail. Please make every effort to attend this important session. The IRT’s input will inform Threshold Question B [docs.google.com]<https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1rqfRaG1y…>: Can an accreditation model without a formal Accreditation Program remain consistent with the policy recommendations? This is based on the IRT comment asking if the community had ever concluded that a formal Accreditation Program was needed/wanted, having found no evidence in previous discussions. IRT Task: Review and comment on accreditation models [docs.google.com]<https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/docs.google.com/document/d/14FEv67ER-Qnz…>. Due Friday, 30 May 2025 IRT input is needed on the models to identify whether any of these options cannot be implemented in accordance with the policy recommendations and why, and where further GNSO guidance is needed. To support your comments, please cite: * the PPSAI Final Report, * discussions in the original PDP Working Group, and/or * discussions in the former IRT where appropriate Avoid IRT comments that: * Identify a personal accreditation model preference, or one based on SO/AC/group affiliation, rather than making an assessment based on the scope given to us by the Final Report. * Identify known implementation challenges which have already been noted and listed for further implementation planning discussions. Reminder: only highlight the specific area of related text when making comments. We look forward to seeing you this Thursday. Best, Jason Jason Kean Sr. Manager, Reviews and Stakeholder Support Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) www.icann.org<http://www.icann.org> Upcoming Schedule: * 15 May @15:30 UTC: IRT meeting introducing the accreditations models and detailing IRT task instructions. * 27-28 May: ICANN 83 Prep Week. The Prep Week schedule [icann83.sched.com]<https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/icann83.sched.com/__;!!PtGJab4!4Q00G60AD…> will be published on 5 May 2025 * 30 May: Deadline for IRT to submit its comments on the accreditation models. * 11 June: ICANN83 session in Prague from 9:00am - 10:15am local time. The IRT will discuss the input provided on the accreditations models. * To register for ICANN83, visit: https://events.icann.org/icann83/registration [events.icann.org]<https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/events.icann.org/icann83/registration__;…>

1 0

PPSAI IRT Task: 20250424 Review Revised Language for Threshold Questions: A, C, K Due Monday 05 May 2025
by Dana Kuebler April 24, 2025

April 24, 2025

Hello IRT, We hope this finds you well. As a reminder that our Thursday 24 April IRT session has been cancelled. Invitations have been sent for our next IRT session on Thursday 15 May 2024 15:30 UTC. To continue our productive collaboration on list the next IRT task is here. 20250423 Review and Provide Feedback on Revised Language for Threshold Questions: A, C, K 05Dec2024 - EXT IRT Draft Proposed Candidate Questions for GNSO Council v1<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jvVfgLtnqzcSarbL2UfeHQV_CykUbpv-DB_m5ZA…> 05 May 2025 Please follow requested feedback guidance found within the document tab: Section 2. IRT Review Instructions<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jvVfgLtnqzcSarbL2UfeHQV_CykUbpv-DB_m5ZA…>, and identify any text that you CANNOT LIVE WITH (provide text that you could support in your comment; and please select only the specific part of text that you cannot live with); · Please hold back on comments on smaller issues - we are looking for any changes in direction for these TQs to prepare them for submission to the GNSO Council. To reduce confusion, tabs with “Archive” and in red text can be ignored. Quick Links to revised language: * TQ A: Definitions<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jvVfgLtnqzcSarbL2UfeHQV_CykUbpv-DB_m5ZA…> * TQ C: Illustrative Disclosure Framework - policy or example<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jvVfgLtnqzcSarbL2UfeHQV_CykUbpv-DB_m5ZA…> * TQ.K: Similarities between "High Priority" (PPSAI Disclosure Framework) and "Urgent" (Registration Data Policy issue) requests<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jvVfgLtnqzcSarbL2UfeHQV_CykUbpv-DB_m5ZA…> We invite further task related discussion & collaboration on the listserv until we meet again Thursday 15 May 2025. Thanks again for all you do to help our PPSAI efforts.

2 1

Schedule Update: Next IRT Session Changed to 15 May 2025
by Dana Kuebler April 17, 2025

April 17, 2025

Hello again Owen and IRT! Thanks again for flagging the schedule conflict with both the Contracted Parties Summit on May 6 and 7 in Hanoi and the APAC DNS Forum on May 8 and 9. We took another look and agree we should shift the timing of our Thursday 08 May IRT session. We will be sending out invitation updates for Thursday 15 May 15:30 UTC and will keep the next scheduled session for Thursday 22nd May. Safe travels and we look forward to reconnecting in May From: Dana Kuebler Date: Tuesday, April 15, 2025 at 5:47 PM To: Owen Smigelski Cc: Dana Kuebler <dana.kuebler(a)icann.org> Subject: Re: Meeting: PPSAI IRT | Thursday, 8 May 2025 | 1530 UTC | 90 minutes | Hi Owen, Thanks for the heads up on the schedule conflicts. Wishing safe travels for all to attending the CPS and APAC DNS Forum. Currently, the intention is to hold our scheduled session for 08 May and plan a quick meeting to introduce Implementation Models and assign the IRT a task to review. We anticipate a short/manageable session recording for those who are not able to attend and will keep our efforts moving things forward. We will continue to evaluate IRT scheduling conflicts as they arise and accommodate when feasible. Dana From: Owen Smigelski Date: Monday, April 14, 2025 at 3:31 PM To: GDS Shared Services Cc: GDS Shared Services <gds-shared-services(a)icann.org>, Owen Smigelski <owen.smigelski(a)namecheap.com> Subject: Re: Meeting: PPSAI IRT | Thursday, 8 May 2025 | 1530 UTC | 90 minutes | Hi ICANN, Due to the Contracted Parties Summit on May 6 and 7 in Hanoi (and the APAC DNS Forum on May 8 and 9), most contracted party participants will be unable to attend. Can we please reschedule this meeting? Thanks! Regards, Owen

1 0

PPSAI IRT Session #18: Thursday 10 April 2025 Follow up
by Dana Kuebler April 11, 2025

April 11, 2025

Hello IRT, Happy Friday! The session #18 recordings are available here,<https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/IRT/pages/106367969/10+Ap…> transcripts will be posted shortly. Schedule: * We have Cancelled IRT Session#19: Thursday, 24 April 2025 @15:30 UTC * Invitations for May IRT Sessions #20 & #21: Thursday 08th and 22nd May 2025 @15:30 UTC & will be sent next week. Tasks: * IRT can anticipate a request on-list to review revised language for Candidate Threshold Questions for GNSO Guidance. Have a great weekend.

1 0

PPSAI IRT Upcoming Session #18: Thursday 10 April 1530 UTC
by Dana Kuebler April 7, 2025

April 7, 2025

Dear IRT, Thank you for comments on the Ext: IRT Doc - Alignment of Disclosure Frameworks to Existing Work/Procedures (07Mar25)<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Gx_OsTUYmF3bab1j__is2S4edYZ3r5DtEHpsTMc…>. IPT has responded to comments and looks forward to continued discussion on Disclosure Framework Threshold Category 3, Part B. Can these frameworks be aligned with existing work on RDRS, Registration Data Policy, and other existing procedures and remain consistent with the policy recommendations? Please review the recent ICANN82 session<https://icann82.sched.com/event/1vpbs/gds-ppsai-irt-working-session> if you were unable to attend. Reach out to us if you have not received an invitation for the upcoming session #18 Thursday, 10 April at 15:30 UTC. The agenda can be found here<https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/IRT/pages/106367969/10+Ap…>.

1 0

PPSAI IRT Upcoming Session #18: Thursday 10 April 1530 UTC
by Dana Kuebler April 1, 2025

April 1, 2025

Hello IRT, Thank you again for your engagement during the ICANN82 IRT Session<https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/IRT/pages/106366110/12+Ma…>. We appreciate your input on the workplan, timeline, and Disclosure Framework comments. In response to requests for more time, we extended the IRT comment deadlines on the Alignment of Disclosure Frameworks to Existing Work/Procedures<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Gx_OsTUYmF3bab1j__is2S4edYZ3r5DtEHpsTMc…> and the Draft Disclosure Framework Assessment<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1prbyViSAFL866FjYD9VSwSH4aGjkJZgNYn6m3NX…> to Thursday, 27 March 2025. IPT responses to comments will be posted ahead of our next session on Thursday, 10 April at 15:30 UTC. Please let us know if you have any questions or need the upcoming meeting invite resent. Best regards

1 0

IRT Session #17: Meeting Cancellation for Thursday 27 March 2025
by Dana Kuebler March 24, 2025

March 24, 2025

Hello IRT, Hoping all found their way home safely from ICANN82 and have fully recovered from all the traveling. We are cancelling IRT Session #17, this Thursday 27 March 2025 to allow IRT members to utilize session time to complete assigned tasks. Reminder: Tasks are due Thursday 27 March, EOD Task # IRT Task (homework) Due Date 20250307a Review Alignment of Disclosure Frameworks to Existing Work/Procedures<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Gx_OsTUYmF3bab1j__is2S4edYZ3r5DtEHpsTMc…> and comment on questions and assumptions 19 March 2025 27 March 2025 20250307b Provide priority comments for Threshold Question 3: Part B, within the Draft Disclosure Framework Assessment<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1prbyViSAFL866FjYD9VSwSH4aGjkJZgNYn6m3NX…> document 19 March 2025 27 March 2025 Please review the IRT Comment Guidelines section<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1prbyViSAFL866FjYD9VSwSH4aGjkJZgNYn6m3NX…> of the assessment for guidance & examples on how to best make comments. For the Alignment Document, please review the instructions in that document<https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Gx_OsTUYmF3bab1j__is2S4edYZ3r5DtEHpsTMc…> for how to best give your input. REMINDER: please select a small, specific portion of text when making comments on either document. We look forward to further discussion Session #18, Thursday 10 April 2025 @15:30 UTC. Invites will be sent out this week. Please reach out to us if you do not receive an invite.

1 0