March 2019 - RDS-WHOIS2-RT - lists.icann.org

Letter to CCT review chair
by Chris Disspain March 14, 2019

March 14, 2019

All, FYI please see this letter on the CCT Review. https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/correspondence/chalaby-to-zuck-14mar1… The letter has been published on the correspondence page. Cheers, CD

1 0

Canceled: RDS-WHOIS2 RT Engagement Session at ICANN64
by MSSI Secretariat March 11, 2019

March 11, 2019

This meeting is being cancelled. Engagement Session with the RDS-WHOIS2 Review Team<https://64.schedule.icann.org/meetings/962070> (click link for meeting description on ICANN64 Schedule) Adobe Connect link: https://participate.icann.org/kix64-emerald Date: Tuesday, 12 March 2019 Time: 9:00-10:15 AM/local Kobe time Location: Emerald - see venue map here<https://64.schedule.icann.org/floor_maps/3664/shapes/42152> RDS-WHOIS2 Engagement Session wiki page here<https://community.icann.org/x/-QNIBg>

1 0

RDS-WHOIS2 RT Engagement Session at ICANN64
by Jean-Baptiste Deroulez March 11, 2019

March 11, 2019

Dear review team members, This is to kindly let you know that the RDS-WHOIS2 RT Engagement Session scheduled for tomorrow has been cancelled at the request of the review team leadership. You will shortly receive an outlook meeting cancellation notice. Apologies for the inconvenience caused. Kind regards, Jean-Baptiste

1 0

Status update
by Alan Greenberg March 10, 2019

March 10, 2019

We have full consensus on all recommendations. Stephanie is also submitting a statement which will be included in the report. We are just waiting for final edits to be done by Jean-Baptiste and we are ready to publish. Thanks to all for getting us to this stage. Alan

3 2

statement from Perrin
by Stephanie Perrin March 10, 2019

March 10, 2019

My apologies for the delay in sending this, my laptop died and I had a hard time finding a plug to recharge. I will not disrupt consensus on the recommendations, given that Alan has agreed to remove the offending section on accuracy requirements of the GDPR. Here is my statement, on behalf of the NCSG. Kind regards Stephanie Perrin

1 0

Revised Doc
by Alan Greenberg March 4, 2019

March 4, 2019

Here is the revised report incorporating what I considered to be the non-controversial (and often very helpful) revisions that Stephanie provided. Alan

2 1

Late markup
by Stephanie Perrin March 4, 2019

March 4, 2019

Attached is my markup of the document. Overall, this document is impressive in its scope and research. Basically, I think many of our recommendations are sensible. However, the bias towards disclosure of information, the negative attitude towards the GDPR (which my SG applauds as exemplary effort to protect privacy and human rights), and the absence of any explicit recognition of the fact that our WHOIS practices already violated data protection law during the time of the past review are discouraging. Not to mention the fact that the birth of ICANN coincided with the coming into force of the EU directive, and we have had plenty of advice from the DPAs over the past 19 years telling us how to fix it. The push to continue doing what we have done since ICANN was born, regardless of changing risks, improvements in data protection, and the existence of many other ways to achieve the security and stability of the Internet, is discouraging. I realize we had to review the recommendations of the previous Review team. We live in different times, however, and the evidence of that impacting our review is not there. Given how many issues I have reservations about, I would like to make a statement, but I am not quite sure where it belongs. I do not want to resist consensus, but I do want to register some frustration with this process and final result. I do appreciate that I am a minority view and that you have tolerated my raising my comments and objections throughout the process. Stephanie Perrin Chair, NCSG

4 7

Draft report
by Alan Greenberg March 2, 2019

March 2, 2019

A copy of the draft report was sent out a few weeks ago. I have received no input and presume at this stage there will be none as the report will be sent off early next week. Note that I just discovered that the section on Consumer Trust is the wrong version. The correct one can be found at https://docs.google.com/document/d/1J2kdCRH1ftDd78ZoYrYcwA8HCrMEgPyaUW8DsKL…. I have just finished my almost-final editing pass and I am attaching a copy here. There is still some clean-up that Jean-Baptiste will do and that should be integrated in the next few days. Also note that we are still awaiting the consensus call decisions from Stephanie and Volker but I am optimistic we will have that no later than Monday. Alan

1 0

Draft FINAL Report
by Alan Greenberg March 1, 2019

March 1, 2019

As you will have noted, for a variety of reasons we have not yet issued the final report. My intention is to do so prior to my leaving for Kobe 12 days from now. Note that we are still awaiting consensus on the recommendations from two team members. The document attached will be updated to address a number of comments/action items, but is close to final. If you plan to review it (as I hope you all will), please do so quickly. As it is cleaned up, I will send revisions. Alan

2 2