September 2025 - ALAC - lists.icann.org

SAC130: SSAC Comments on Name Collision Guidelines in the Proposed Language for the Draft Next Round Applicant Guidebook
by Matthias M. Hudobnik April 24, 2026

April 24, 2026

Dear Colleagues, The SSAC welcomes the opportunity to comment on ICANN's Draft Applicant Guidebook (AGB) for the New gTLD Program: Next Round. Our comments focus on improving Section 6.7 on Name Collisions, with an emphasis on risks arising from collisions between DNS and alternative naming systems (e.g., blockchain-based systems), as outlined in the Name Collision Analysis Project Study 2 Report (NCAP2). SUMMARY OF KEY RECOMMENDATIONS: * Clarify TRT's Role in Initial Assessments AGB §6.7.2 does not clearly state that the Technical Review Team (TRT) conducts the initial name collision risk assessment. NCAP2 indicates TRT is responsible from the outset. _Recommendation:_ Explicitly assign the initial assessment to the TRT. * Enable Pre-Delegation Action on High-Risk Strings Current language suggests high-risk strings are identified only after temporary delegation. NCAP2 supports action based on existing data. _Recommendation:_ Allow TRT to recommend withholding delegation if early analysis shows high risk. * Broaden TRT's Assessment Scope Beyond DNS Data Limiting analysis to DNS logs misses collisions from alternative namespaces that resolve via DNS (e.g., users accustomed to _.wallet_ from blockchain). ➤ _Recommendation:_ Permit use of OSINT, qualitative assessments, and external data sources per NCAP2. * Allow TRT Flexibility to Evolve Assessment Methods AGB cites four NCAP2 methods (NI, CI, VI, VIN), but doesn't state whether TRT may adopt new techniques. _Recommendation:_ Affirm TRT's discretion to evolve methods to address future risks. These updates will better align the AGB with NCAP2 and ICANN Board guidance, while improving transparency, security, and technical rigor in handling name collisions. The SSAC appreciates the efforts of the ICANN org and Subsequent Procedures IRT, and we are available for further discussion. Link: https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/security-and-stability-advisory-committe…. Best, Matthias

3 4

SSAC report and apology for the ALAC Monthly meeting on 26/08
by Matthias M. Hudobnik April 21, 2026

April 21, 2026

Dear Colleagues, please find below my report. I apologize for not being able to attend the ALAC Monthly meeting on August 26th. Have a nice day! Best, Matthias Publications: SAC130: SSAC Comments on Name Collision Guidelines in the Proposed Language for the Draft Next Round Applicant Guidebook The SSAC welcomes the opportunity to comment on ICANN's Draft Applicant Guidebook (AGB) for the New gTLD Program: Next Round. Our comments focus on improving Section 6.7 on Name Collisions, with an emphasis on risks arising from collisions between DNS and alternative naming systems (e.g., blockchain-based systems), as outlined in the Name Collision Analysis Project Study 2 Report (NCAP2). SUMMARY OF KEY RECOMMENDATIONS: * Clarify TRT's Role in Initial Assessments AGB §6.7.2 does not clearly state that the Technical Review Team (TRT) conducts the initial name collision risk assessment. NCAP2 indicates TRT is responsible from the outset. _Recommendation:_ Explicitly assign the initial assessment to the TRT. * Enable Pre-Delegation Action on High-Risk Strings Current language suggests high-risk strings are identified only after temporary delegation. NCAP2 supports action based on existing data. _Recommendation:_ Allow TRT to recommend withholding delegation if early analysis shows high risk. * Broaden TRT's Assessment Scope Beyond DNS Data Limiting analysis to DNS logs misses collisions from alternative namespaces that resolve via DNS (e.g., users accustomed to _.wallet_ from blockchain). _Recommendation:_ Permit use of OSINT, qualitative assessments, and external data sources per NCAP2. * Allow TRT Flexibility to Evolve Assessment Methods AGB cites four NCAP2 methods (NI, CI, VI, VIN), but doesn't state whether TRT may adopt new techniques. _Recommendation:_ Affirm TRT's discretion to evolve methods to address future risks. These updates will better align the AGB with NCAP2 and ICANN Board guidance, while improving transparency, security, and technical rigor in handling name collisions. The SSAC appreciates the efforts of the ICANN org and Subsequent Procedures IRT, and we are available for further discussion. Link: https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/security-and-stability-advisory-committe…. Ongoing work parties: * DNSSEC Operational Considerations Work Party * Open-Source Software Work Party * Responsible Integration of External Technologies into the DNS * SSAC Workshop Work Party SSAC Membership Applications: The application deadline is closed now and potential candidates are being assessed by the Membership Selection Committee. SSAC Workshop: For SSAC members only, will be held in September in Mexico City.

2 6

Re: Fw: Launch of The Internet Ecosystem Book
by Kaleel Bin Javeed Sept. 24, 2025

Sept. 24, 2025

I will also recommend it. Nice to have ! It is a very good reference guide book for the whole Internet history, the future of the Internet, Internet Governance and for the community. Dr. Kaleel Bin Javeed, PhD Associate Professor, Research and Development On Tuesday, September 23, 2025, Abba wrote: Nice comprehensive book. I have received a shared coupon for community-use from the author. You can use coupon code: INTECO10, you will receive the book at a discounted price for those interested. Abba Saheb, PhD CTO *From:* Nikesh B. Simmandree <nikeshbs(a)outlook.com> *Sent:* Monday, August 18, 2025 1:35 PM *To:* alac-announce(a)icann.org <alac-announce(a)icann.org>; alac(a)icann.org < alac(a)icann.org>; at-large(a)icann.org <at-large(a)icann.org>; afri-discuss(a)icann.org <afri-discuss(a)icann.org> *Subject:* Launch of The Internet Ecosystem Book Dear Community, I am thrilled to announce the launch of my book, *The Internet Ecosystem* — a comprehensive exploration of the history, architecture, governance, and future of the Internet. This book distills decades of technological evolution — from ARPANET and packet switching, to AI, Web3, quantum networks, and beyond — into a clear, engaging narrative accessible to both technical and non-technical readers *What the Book Covers* - *The Past:* How Cold War research, ARPANET, and packet switching gave birth to the Internet we know today. - *The Present:* The intricate roles of ISPs, backbone providers, cloud infrastructure, AI, cybersecurity, and global governance shaping our daily online experiences. - *The Future:* Insights into 5G/6G, blockchain, immersive technologies, quantum security, and the Internet in 2050. With *49 detailed chapters*, the book provides a definitive yet approachable reference for students, professionals, policymakers, and curious readers alike. My mission with *The Internet Ecosystem* is to make the Internet’s complexity understandable — showing not only *how* the Internet works, but also *why* it matters and has become one of the most transformative human inventions — while sparking dialogue on how we build a secure, inclusive, and sustainable digital future. In the 21st century, understanding the Internet is not optional — it’s essential. Whether you’re a business leader, policymaker, educator, student, or everyday Internet user, this book provides the context and clarity you need to navigate the opportunities and challenges of our connected world. *Get Your Copy* *The Internet Ecosystem* is now available: https://payhip.com/b/hfvYg Thank you, Best Regards, Nikesh B. Simmandree +230-5-907-3413 nikeshbs(a)outlook.com This message and its attachments are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and are strictly confidential. If you have received this in error, please delete it from any devices after having informed the sender.

1 0

SSAC report
by Matthias M. Hudobnik Sept. 23, 2025

Sept. 23, 2025

Dear all, please find my report below. Unfortunately, I will miss the call today because I am on the plane due to a rescheduled flight L. Have a great day! Best, Matthias Publications: SAC131: SAC131 SSAC Comments on Functional Model for Root Server System Governance The SSAC commends the Root Server System (RSS) Governance Working Group (GWG) for developing the proposed Functional Model, a significant step toward evolving RSS governance. We acknowledge the Root Server Operators’ (RSOs) critical role in ensuring DNS stability through independent, resilient, and technologically advanced operations. The SSAC supports the Functional Model as a foundation for future RSS governance but highlights areas needing further clarity: · Governance Principles: Define clear principles to guide decision-making and governance evolution. · Implementation Roadmap: Develop a staged plan balancing continuity and governance maturity. · Inclusivity and Transparency: Ensure accountability and diverse stakeholder participation. · Funding Stability: Explore sustainable funding to maintain RSS security and resilience. Regarding the RSSAC037 Concept Model, the SSAC recommends the RSS Council address: · Operationalization: Provide a detailed plan to implement the Concept Model. · High-Level Principles: Specify processes, e.g., for RSO designation/removal. · Operational Details: Define secretariat formation, funding mechanisms, and ICANN community relations. · Interactions: Clarify relationships with bodies like CSC, RZERC, and SSAC. The SSAC urges the RSS Council to prioritize these operational specifics, maintain transparency, and consult the community throughout implementation. We look forward to offering further support to enhance RSS security, stability, and accountability. Link: HYPERLINK "https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/security-and-stability-advisory-committe…"SAC131 SSAC Comments on Functional Model for Root Server System Governance. SAC131 has also been submitted as the SSAC’s response to the Functional Model for Root Server System Governance: https://www.icann.org/en/public-comment/proceeding/functional-model-for-roo…. Ongoing work parties: DNSSEC Operational Considerations Work Party Responsible Integration of External Technologies into the DNS Open-Source Software Work Party (is finished, the publication will follow soon) SSAC Workshop: The SSAC workshop, held exclusively for SSAC members from 16 to 18 September in Mexico City, included no public sessions. Strategic and substantive topics were discussed, including guidance on travel funding and defining SSAC members’ engagement. Further details will be shared with the broader ICANN community once communicated; currently, this information remains internal to the SSAC. SSAC Membership Applications: Potential candidates are being evaluated by the Membership Selection Committee, and the outcome will be presented in due course.

1 0

Fw: Re: Launch of The Internet Ecosystem Book
by Ole Mubanga Sept. 23, 2025

Sept. 23, 2025

Those who wish to have a copy of the newly launched: "The Internet Ecosystem" Book. Use coupon code: INTECO10 I completed the reading and I will recommend it. A book which englobe the whole history and future of the Internet. Happy Reading ! - Ole Dear Community, > > I am thrilled to announce the launch of my book, *The Internet Ecosystem* — > a comprehensive exploration of the history, architecture, governance, and > future of the Internet. > This book distills decades of technological evolution — from ARPANET and > packet switching, to AI, Web3, quantum networks, and beyond — into a clear, > engaging narrative accessible to both technical and non-technical readers > > *What the Book Covers* > > - *The Past:* How Cold War research, ARPANET, and packet switching > gave birth to the Internet we know today. > - *The Present:* The intricate roles of ISPs, backbone providers, > cloud infrastructure, AI, cybersecurity, and global governance shaping our > daily online experiences. > - *The Future:* Insights into 5G/6G, blockchain, immersive > technologies, quantum security, and the Internet in 2050. > > With *49 detailed chapters*, the book provides a definitive yet > approachable reference for students, professionals, policymakers, and > curious readers alike. > > My mission with *The Internet Ecosystem* is to make the Internet’s > complexity understandable — showing not only *how* the Internet works, > but also *why* it matters and has become one of the most transformative > human inventions — while sparking dialogue on how we build a secure, > inclusive, and sustainable digital future. > In the 21st century, understanding the Internet is not optional — it’s > essential. Whether you’re a business leader, policymaker, educator, > student, or everyday Internet user, this book provides the context and > clarity you need to navigate the opportunities and challenges of our > connected world. > > *Get Your Copy* > *The Internet Ecosystem* is now available: https://payhip.com/b/hfvYg > > Thank you, > > Best Regards, > Nikesh B. Simmandree > +230-5-907-3413 > nikeshbs(a)outlook.com > > This message and its attachments are intended only for the person or > entity to which it is addressed and are strictly confidential. If you have > received this in error, please delete it from any devices after having > informed the sender. >

1 0

Fw: Re: Launch of The Internet Ecosystem Book
by Ole Mubanga Sept. 23, 2025

Sept. 23, 2025

Those who wish to have a copy of the newly launched: "The Internet Ecosystem" Book. Use coupon code: INTECO10 I completed the reading and I will recommend it. A book which englobe the whole history and future of the Internet. Happy Reading ! - Ole On Tue, Sep 02, 2025 at 3:55 PM <abbasaheb(a)atomicmail.io> wrote: > Nice comprehensive book. I have received a shared coupon for community-use > from the author. You can use coupon code: INTECO10, you will receive the > book at a discounted price for those interested. > > Abba Saheb, PhD > CTO > > ------------------------------ > *From:* Nikesh B. Simmandree <nikeshbs(a)outlook.com> > *Sent:* Monday, August 18, 2025 1:35 PM > *To:* alac-announce(a)icann.org <alac-announce(a)icann.org>; alac(a)icann.org < > alac(a)icann.org>; at-large(a)icann.org <at-large(a)icann.org>; > afri-discuss(a)icann.org <afri-discuss(a)icann.org> > *Subject:* Launch of The Internet Ecosystem Book > > Dear Community, > > I am thrilled to announce the launch of my book, *The Internet Ecosystem* — > a comprehensive exploration of the history, architecture, governance, and > future of the Internet. > This book distills decades of technological evolution — from ARPANET and > packet switching, to AI, Web3, quantum networks, and beyond — into a clear, > engaging narrative accessible to both technical and non-technical readers > > *What the Book Covers* > > - *The Past:* How Cold War research, ARPANET, and packet switching > gave birth to the Internet we know today. > - *The Present:* The intricate roles of ISPs, backbone providers, > cloud infrastructure, AI, cybersecurity, and global governance shaping our > daily online experiences. > - *The Future:* Insights into 5G/6G, blockchain, immersive > technologies, quantum security, and the Internet in 2050. > > With *49 detailed chapters*, the book provides a definitive yet > approachable reference for students, professionals, policymakers, and > curious readers alike. > > My mission with *The Internet Ecosystem* is to make the Internet’s > complexity understandable — showing not only *how* the Internet works, > but also *why* it matters and has become one of the most transformative > human inventions — while sparking dialogue on how we build a secure, > inclusive, and sustainable digital future. > In the 21st century, understanding the Internet is not optional — it’s > essential. Whether you’re a business leader, policymaker, educator, > student, or everyday Internet user, this book provides the context and > clarity you need to navigate the opportunities and challenges of our > connected world. > > *Get Your Copy* > *The Internet Ecosystem* is now available: https://payhip.com/b/hfvYg > > Thank you, > > Best Regards, > Nikesh B. Simmandree > +230-5-907-3413 > nikeshbs(a)outlook.com > > This message and its attachments are intended only for the person or > entity to which it is addressed and are strictly confidential. If you have > received this in error, please delete it from any devices after having > informed the sender. >

1 0

SAC131 SSAC Comments on Functional Model for Root Server System Governance
by Matthias M. Hudobnik Sept. 23, 2025

Sept. 23, 2025

Dear all, The SSAC commends the Root Server System (RSS) Governance Working Group (GWG) for developing the proposed Functional Model, a significant step toward evolving RSS governance. We acknowledge the Root Server Operators’ (RSOs) critical role in ensuring DNS stability through independent, resilient, and technologically advanced operations. The SSAC supports the Functional Model as a foundation for future RSS governance but highlights areas needing further clarity: · Governance Principles: Define clear principles to guide decision-making and governance evolution. · Implementation Roadmap: Develop a staged plan balancing continuity and governance maturity. · Inclusivity and Transparency: Ensure accountability and diverse stakeholder participation. · Funding Stability: Explore sustainable funding to maintain RSS security and resilience. Regarding the RSSAC037 Concept Model, the SSAC recommends the RSS Council address: · Operationalization: Provide a detailed plan to implement the Concept Model. · High-Level Principles: Specify processes, e.g., for RSO designation/removal. · Operational Details: Define secretariat formation, funding mechanisms, and ICANN community relations. · Interactions: Clarify relationships with bodies like CSC, RZERC, and SSAC. The SSAC urges the RSS Council to prioritize these operational specifics, maintain transparency, and consult the community throughout implementation. We look forward to offering further support to enhance RSS security, stability, and accountability. Link: HYPERLINK "https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/security-and-stability-advisory-committe…"SAC131 SSAC Comments on Functional Model for Root Server System Governance. SAC131 has also been submitted as the SSAC’s response to the Functional Model for Root Server System Governance: https://www.icann.org/en/public-comment/proceeding/functional-model-for-roo… Best, Matthias __________________________ Ing. Mag. Matthias M. Hudobnik FIP, CIPP/E, CIPT, DPO, CIS LA matthias(a)hudobnik.at http://www.hudobnik.at @mhudobnik

1 0

Summary Report of ccNSO Council meeting #221
by Laura Margolis Sept. 23, 2025

Sept. 23, 2025

Dear All: I hope you are doing fine. Here is a summary report from the last ccNSO Council Meeting #221 This is the just submitted response to request for comments Root Server System Governance Working Group. <https://www.icann.org/en/public-comment/proceeding/functional-model-for-roo…> *Report of the ccNSO Council Meeting #221* *Date:* Thursday, 18 September 2025 *Time:* 21:00 UTC Full Agenda - Background Documents - Relevant Correspondence <https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/ccNSOCWS/pages/103123999/…> ------------------------------ *1. Welcome* AOB items announced: 1. Update by OMC. 2. Request from Tech WG Chair. 3. Announcement: ICANN adopted a Code of Conduct for community participation. ------------------------------ *2. Relevant Correspondence* Tripti Sinha’s communication to SO/AC Chairs regarding the Review of Reviews CCG Charter Approval and Board Appointed Participants was noted and scheduled for later discussion. ------------------------------ *3. Action Items* - *Action items:* All from Meeting 220 were completed. These included: - Sharing the Finance WG Final Report with ICANN CEO. - Updating guidelines with the new Banded Model. - Publishing resolutions on IFRT adoption and IANA IP rights transfer. - Appointments and working group updates. ------------------------------ *4–5. Intermeeting Decisions* No Council or Triage Committee decisions since Meeting 220. ------------------------------ *6–8. WG Updates <https://docs.google.com/document/d/16Yy33VRHtchfaDpI0sytrp5iszogpE-6kmvGp2H…>* Written updates from ECA, IFRT, CSC, Working Groups, and Liaisons noted. ------------------------------ *10. ccPDP4-IDN <https://ccnso.icann.org/en/workinggroups/idn-cctld-strings.htm> – Board Consideration* Patricio Poblete reported progress: the second reading of the validation procedure is done; further in-depth discussions are upcoming. ------------------------------ *11. Review of Reviews (RoR CCG)* - Alejandra Reynoso noted delays and lack of co-chairs but highlighted that the process has started. - Preparations ongoing for ICANN84 in Dublin: prep week session, 2 plenaries, and a ccNSO internal session. ------------------------------ *12. “How We Meet” CCG* Alejandra Reynoso summarized past consultations and the upcoming development of an implementation plan based on ICANN CEO’s decisions. ------------------------------ *13. Nomination Process – ICANN Board Seat 11* Joke Braeken reported that ICANN Legal confirmed due diligence for Patricio Poblete was completed with no issues. ------------------------------ *14. Council Selection Process* - Joke Braeken reported that nominations were received from most regions; pending confirmations from Latin America/Caribbean and North America. - Councillors were suggested not to wait until the last minute (nomination period closes 30 September). ------------------------------ *15. Updates – Chair, Vice-Chairs, Councillors, Regional Organisations, Secretariat* - *Chair updates:* - Planning ccNSO webinar with LACTLD. - Successful presentation at APTLD (SOPC showcased). - SO/AC Chairs meetings discussed topics like risk aversion, meeting guidelines, and RoR. - Bart reported on ccPAIG’s first meeting post-adoption of the Review Mechanism policy. ------------------------------ *16. CSC Matters* - *Membership:* Full slate approved by ccNSO Council Selection Committee and GNSO; term starts 1 October 2025. - *Bylaws/Charter updates:* ICANN org drafting text on alternates and review frequency; awaiting legal feedback. ------------------------------ *17. Draft Response – RSS Governance WG* - Draft response to public comments on the RSS Functional Model was adopted. - Resolution passed: Chair submitted the response; Secretariat to publish it. - Vote: All in favour; Peter Koch abstained. ------------------------------ *18. Appointments to Committees & Working Groups* Appointments approved: - *MPC <https://ccnso.icann.org/en/workinggroups/mpwg.htm> Effectiveness Review Team:* Olga Cavalli, Irina Danelia, Khaled Khelifi, Peter Koch, Sean Copeland. - *SOPC <https://ccnso.icann.org/en/workinggroups/sopiwg.htm>:* Mostofa Al Mahmud. - *Study Group on IANA Disaster Recovery:* Peter Koch, Antonia Chu, Barrack Otieno, Irina Danelia, Katrina Sataki, Jodi Anderson. ------------------------------ *19. ICANN84 Preparations* - Highlights include: - Joint sessions with RSSAC and GAC (focus on domain abuse). - WIPO presentation during Welcome. - Review of Reviews and GRC <https://ccnso.icann.org/en/workinggroups/grc.htm> World Café sessions. - IANA Study Group and Disaster Recovery discussions. - Councillors asked to propose topics for the joint Board session. ------------------------------ *20. Any Other Business (AOB)* - *Buddy Program:* OMC <https://ccnso.icann.org/en/workinggroups/omc.htm> launched updated ccNSO newcomer buddy initiative. - *Tech WG <https://ccnso.icann.org/en/workinggroups/techwg.htm> Request:* Proposal to amend ToR to add Tech WG Chair as ex-officio member of the Disaster Recovery Study Group. After discussion, the Council agreed to decline politely. - *ICANN Code of Conduct:* Adopted for community participation; SO/ACs expected to implement. Suggested review by GRC. This is all for now! Thank you for reading. If you have any questions or topics you would like me to deep dive, please let me know and I will be happy to answer. Kindest Regards, *Laura Margolis* *ALAC Liaison to ccNSO* margolisl(a)gmail.com +59899690992 Teams: lauri.margolis ccNSO Liaison Workspace <https://community.icann.org/display/atlarge/ALAC+Liaison+to+the+ccNSO+Repor…>

1 0

GNSO Council 18 September 2025 meeting agenda is out
by Justine Chew Sept. 20, 2025

Sept. 20, 2025

Dear all, Please be informed that the agenda for the GNSO Council Meeting taking place on Thursday, 18 September 2025, is as follows: *GNSO Council Meeting #9 of 2025 held on 18 September 2025 <https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/atlarge/pages/265846872/G…>* *Full Agenda* <https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/x/OKafBg>* | * *Documents* <https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/x/8KefBg>* | * *Motions* <https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/x/TKifBg> - *Item 1: Administrative Matters* - Item 2: Opening Remarks / Review of Projects Action List - 2.1 - Review focus areas and provide updates on specific key themes / topics, to include review of Projects List <https://gnso.icann.org/en/council/project> and Action Item List <https://community.icann.org/x/RgZlAg>. - *Item 3: Consent Agenda * - Confirmation of GNSO Members to the Review of Reviews Cross Community Group (RoR CCG): Sophie Hey and Osvaldo Novoa - Approval of 2025 Customer Standing Committee slate - ALAC-appointed Liaison: Houda Chihi (Term: 1 October 2025 – 30 September 2027) - *Item 4: COUNCIL DISCUSSION - Prioritization of Upcoming Work* - *Item 5: COUNCIL DISCUSSION - Urgent Request Timeline and Related Topics* - *Item 6: COUNCIL VOTE - Board Readiness Small Team Recommendations* - *Item 7: COUNCIL VOTE - Proposed Agenda for GAC-GNSO Bilateral Meeting at ICANN84* - *Item 8: Any Other Business* - 8.1 - GNSO Council SPS - 8.2 - ICANN84 planning and GNSO Draft schedule - *8.3 - *GNSO Prep Week Webinar <https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/x/AYC1G> *- 07 Oct at 21:00 UTC* - *8.4 - Next Steps for Accuracy Small Team Rec. 2 (educational materials)* - *8.5 - Initiating the Standing Predictability Implementation Review Team (SPIRT)* For more details on the marked agenda items, please visit *this link <https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/atlarge/pages/265846872/G…>* and click on 'Matters of Interest' This Council meeting will take place on *18 September 2025 at 05:00 UTC for 2 hours* and is open to observers remotely in listen-only mode via *this Zoom link <https://icann.zoom.us/j/91048235847?pwd=bmEHjk0uYT3sR2DIoE0c0yw4HKbM6O.1>* Thanks for reading / considering. *Justine Chew* ALAC Liaison to the GNSO GNSO Liaison Workspace <https://icann-community.atlassian.net/wiki/x/fG7xBQ?atlOrigin=eyJpIjoiNDI1Y…> ------

1 1

Petition for ALAC Advice on String Change/Replacement Mechanism for ASP Applicants
by Justine Chew Sept. 9, 2025

Sept. 9, 2025

I am petitioning the ALAC to urgently produce advice to the ICANN Board to support the intent of Edmon Chung's proposal to help ASP applicants have an appropriate way out of a contention set should they get caught in one, and not be pushed towards an ICANN Auction which they will more than likely not win given the cap to the Bid Credit. We have pushed as hard as we can in the SubPro IRT but apart from pushback from ICANN org IRT support staff (too late, additional costs, complications to alter system development), several IRT members are constrained to support it as the IRT isn't supposed to make "policy" changes. Other members of the IRT are opposed to any changes whatsoever. So the only way through is to appeal to the Board. It would be better if we can secure (another) collaboration with the GAC, but we should move in parallel and just submit ALAC Advice if we cannot get GAC on board quickly. If there is support for this, I would ask that Edmon Chung be involved in helping to set out a suitable description of changes that could be accommodated without too much difficulty to ICANN org. Kind regards, Justine

16 17