- Bc-gnso - lists.icann.org

CBUC Position Statement on RAP
by berrycobb＠infinityportals.com March 29, 2010

March 29, 2010

CBUC, This is the final call for any edits, comments, or disagreements with the positions outlined for the Registration Abuse Policies WG. If there are no objections to the draft as presented here, this will be submitted as a BC Consensus position. We have been granted to COB March 29th to submit the statement. If you have any questions or concerns, please advise. Thank you for your support. FYI, the only change with the attached draft is that I added Phil Corwin as a member of the team. My apologies for omitting his contribution. Berry Cobb Infinity Portals LLC 866.921.8891

5 5

.XXX
by berrycobb＠infinityportals.com March 29, 2010

March 29, 2010

CBUC, I am reviewing the documents and decision tree for the .XXX public comment period. Forgive my inexperience and lack of history regarding this TLD, but can someone explain to me why the GAC Comments (either past or possible new) are a consideration in the decision tree? Why wouldn't any of the SO get equal opportunity to influence or weigh in on the decision outside of public comment? Thank you for enlightening me. Berry Berry Cobb Infinity Portals LLC 866.921.8891

2 1

RE: [bc-gnso] BC Draft Position on New TLD Registry Agreement Amendments DAG v3
by berrycobb＠infinityportals.com March 26, 2010

March 26, 2010

Ron, Thank you for supplying us with the BC Position statement for RA Amendments. I support the position statement as outlined, and I have no changes to offer. Within this topic, I am grateful to ICANN for the more uniform approach to Ry Agreements, as opposed to the variance that exists across existing agreements. This should greatly enhance compliance efforts, etc... Equal thanks to Jon for his efforts. Thank you. Berry Cobb Infinity Portals LLC 866.921.8891 Dear Fellow Members, Please find the draft BC position on new TLD Registry Agreement Amendments attached. This draft position is open for discussion/amendment through April 1st, 2010. Thanks to Jon Nevitt for carrying the ball on this one! Kind regards, RA Ronald N. Andruff President RNA Partners, Inc. 220 Fifth Avenue New York, New York 10001 + 1 212 481 2820 ext. 11

4 3

BC Position Statement DRAFT - Baseline Registry Operations Report from KPMG - Action Required by 3/30
by berrycobb＠infinityportals.com March 23, 2010

March 23, 2010

Sorry, outbound email issues....sending again to be certain, I will be disconnected most of tomorrow. BC, Attached is the first draft of the CBUC position statement for the Baseline Registry Operation report released by ICANN. Overall, I feel KPMG performed well and provided meaningful views of the data. It is ashamed that more participants were not a part of the sample data. My Registry operations experience is limited, so I ask the BC team to take a strong look at the report and the initial comments I provided. I especially invite our members that have direct Registry operations experience to enhance our position about this study and its future use by the gTLD Evaluation teams. This material is sure to have a direct impact to the next Draft Applicant Guidebook version 4 to be released just prior to Brussels. In a quick review, the following are what I believe to be sections of the DAGv3 where this study could influence the Application Evaluation Criteria, or the Application Process both of which will be used by the gTLD Evaluation teams. 1.2.2 Required Documents for Application 1.4.2 Application Form 2.1.2 Applicant Reviews 2.1.3 Registry Services Review 2.2.1 Technical/Operational or Financial Extended Evaluation 2.2.2 DNS Stability Extended Evaluation 2.2.3 Registry Services Extended Evaluation The comment period closes April 1st, so I ask for your quick turn-around. As Steve DelBianco eluded to in our last BC call, there are a large number of comment period closings converging at once. I thank you for your quick response. I will compile all feedback and incorporate changes on 3/30/2010. Berry Cobb Infinity Portals LLC San Jose, CA berrycobb(a)infinityportals.com http://infinityportals.com 866.921.8891

1 0

BC Position Statement DRAFT - Baseline Registry Operations Report from KPMG - Action Required by 3/30
by Berry Cobb March 23, 2010

March 23, 2010

BC, Attached is the first draft of the CBUC position statement for the Baseline Registry Operation report released by ICANN. Overall, I feel KPMG performed well and provided meaningful views of the data. It is ashamed that more participants were not a part of the sample data. My Registry operations experience is limited, so I ask the BC team to take a strong look at the report and the initial comments I provided. I especially invite our members that have direct Registry operations experience to enhance our position about this study and its future use by the gTLD Evaluation teams. This material is sure to have a direct impact to the next Draft Applicant Guidebook version 4 to be released just prior to Brussels. In a quick review, the following are what I believe to be sections of the DAGv3 where this study could influence the Application Evaluation Criteria, or the Application Process both of which will be used by the gTLD Evaluation teams. 1.2.2 Required Documents for Application 1.4.2 Application Form 2.1.2 Applicant Reviews 2.1.3 Registry Services Review 2.2.1 Technical/Operational or Financial Extended Evaluation 2.2.2 DNS Stability Extended Evaluation 2.2.3 Registry Services Extended Evaluation The comment period closes April 1st, so I ask for your quick turn-around. As Steve DelBianco eluded to in our last BC call, there are a large number of comment period closings converging at once. I thank you for your quick response. I will compile all feedback and incorporate changes on 3/30/2010. Berry Cobb Infinity Portals LLC San Jose, CA mailto:berrycobb@infinityportals.com http://infinityportals.com <http://infinityportals.com/> 866.921.8891

1 0

ICANN Proposed Framework for 2011 Operating Plan and Budget
by Marilyn Cade March 22, 2010

March 22, 2010

Dear colleagues If you are interested in joining me and other BC colleagues in a discussion about the ICANN Framework for the Operating Plan and Budget, followed by a call with Kevin Wilson, CFO, ICANN, please email me off list at marilynscade(a)hotmail.comI'll schedule a one hour conf. call for interested parties to discuss the document/attached. Comments are due by April 1. I do not envision this being a BC comment, but a discussion among interested parties, and then a moderated call with Kevin. I would encourage individual postings of comments, rather than trying to undertake a BC approved statement. It is not a gTLD policy issue but has implications for the BC in terms of ensuring funding for compliance/enforcement, policy development, ICANN's strategic priorities/directions, and the 'tool kit of services' that the BC has supported. Marilyn Cade

1 0

Selection of Nairobi photos
by Chris Chaplow March 22, 2010

March 22, 2010

Selection of general photographs from meeting Nairobi <http://www.michellechaplow.com/icann-nairobi.htm> http://www.michellechaplow.com/icann-nairobi.htm Selection of images from the Business constituency Nairobi meeting <http://www.michellechaplow.com/csbc-dinner.htm> http://www.michellechaplow.com/csbc-dinner.htm Chris Chaplow Managing Director Andalucía.com S.L. Avenida del Carmen 9 Ed. Puertosol, Puerto Deportivo 1ª Planta, Oficina 30 Estepona, 29680 Malaga, Spain Tel: + (34) 952 897 865 Fax: + (34) 952 897 874 E-mail: <mailto:chris@andalucia.com> chris(a)andalucia.com Web: <http://www.andalucia.com/> www.andalucia.com Information about Andalucia, Spain. Please think of the Environment before you print this email

4 3

Working Group Guidelines -- Comments -- last call, final draft
by Mike O'Connor March 19, 2010

March 19, 2010

hi all, i received a few more comments about the draft, which are incorporated in this (hopefully final) version. if i don't hear anything further, i'll go ahead and submit these on the 22nd. thanks, mikey - - - - - - - - - phone 651-647-6109 fax 866-280-2356 web www.haven2.com handle OConnorStP (ID for public places like Twitter, Facebook, Google, etc.)

3 3

BC position EOI
by Philip Sheppard March 18, 2010

March 18, 2010

Thank you for the last round of comments. Our 14 day process is almost complete and I wanted to send a copy of our paper so that BC colleagues in Nairobi will have a position to speak to. I attach a version three factoring in the last round of comments / support. This includes all substantive contributions of content though not all of the style suggestions. Us rapporteurs should be free to retain that element! For good order I also attach a clean version 3 and have entitled it "final" to facilitate any external communication in Nairobi. Philip

8 9

ACTION REQUIRED - CBUC Position Statement on Registration Abuse Policy WG
by Berry Cobb March 18, 2010

March 18, 2010

CBUC Team, Attached is the first draft of the CBUC Position statement for the Registration Abuse Policies initial report. Comments are to be posted by 28 March 2010, so I ask for everyone's prompt review and feedback. I will compile all comments starting on 27 March to meet the 28th deadline. I ask that you review each recommendation and do not settle on just a "Green Check Mark" as an indication that all is well. Many recommendations contain a Suggestion and Rationale, and it is here where we require your meticulous review and feedback. Further, I welcome suggestions to improve the language in these sections, whether you agree or not. There is a lot of information to review here. I strongly recommend that you review the entire Initial Report first before formulating your position form the CBUC Position paper. Links to the work products are provided in the attached document. If you have any questions or concerns, please field them my way, and I can call upon other CBUC RAP participants to try and answer them. Thank you for your time. Berry A. Cobb Infinity Portals LLC 866.921.8891

1 0