February 2009 - At-Large - lists.icann.org

Re: [At-Large] Still more folk complaining about GoDaddy Transfer Policy Violations
by Bill Silverstein Feb. 8, 2009

Feb. 8, 2009

> Hi Patrick, > > A herd of sheep was determined to craft new policies. They met and collectively resolved that henceforth all wolves would become vegatarians. > The wolves responded to the policy declaration by having a nice mutton > dinner. > > If policies can't or won't be enforced, then there is no point in wasting time on crafting new policy.... and if the ALAC won't bring user concerns to the Board, then why should anyone send their concerns to the ALAC? > Danny, That is not at all accurate! To be accurate, after dinner the wolfs would get a nasty letter telling them to explain why they had a mutton dinner after they had become vegetarians. Then after a several of these letters the wolves would eventually be told not to do that again.

2 1

Still more folk complaining about GoDaddy Transfer Policy Violations
by Danny Younger Feb. 8, 2009

Feb. 8, 2009

http://www.oxadox.com/article/healthfood/2009-01-29/51115.html The issue of GoDaddy's ongoing violation of Inter-Registrar Transfer Consensus Policy has been brought to the attention of the ICANN Compliance Department -- but what action has been taken? ICANN Senior Management is aware of the issue -- but what action has been taken? The ALAC has been notified of the issue -- but what action have they taken? Question: What's the point in working hard to come up with appropriate consensus-based policies if ICANN routinely turns a blind eye to policy violations? ... and what's the point in working with the ALAC if they fail to bring these oft-repeated user concerns to the attention of the Board?

7 11

Still more folk complaining about GoDaddy Transfer Policy Violations
by Danny Younger Feb. 8, 2009

Feb. 8, 2009

Hi Patrick, A herd of sheep was determined to craft new policies. They met and collectively resolved that henceforth all wolves would become vegatarians. The wolves responded to the policy declaration by having a nice mutton dinner. If policies can't or won't be enforced, then there is no point in wasting time on crafting new policy.... and if the ALAC won't bring user concerns to the Board, then why should anyone send their concerns to the ALAC?

1 0