council
Threads by month
- ----- 2025 -----
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2024 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2023 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2022 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2021 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2020 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2019 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2018 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2017 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2016 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2015 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2014 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2013 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2012 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2011 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2010 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2009 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2008 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2007 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2006 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2005 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2004 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2003 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
December 2007
- 26 participants
- 63 discussions
Hi,
After a conversation with Chuck and me, Liz and Dan produced the
following memo on the issues involved in proxy voting. I would like
to suggest that we discuss the issues in this memo on the list and in
an upcoming meeting after which, if the Council wishes to proceed with
a by-laws change we form a small drafting team to produce a
recommended change that we could vote on in council and forward to the
Board for consideration.
As a point of information, I asked Glen to give us the figures for
attendance comparing attendance while we were still using proxy voting
with the period once we no longer had proxy voting. My reason for
requesting this was to deal with the question of whether having proxy
voting affects attendance. Once I have these figures, I will forward
them on to the group.
My thanks to Liz, Dan and Glen for their work on this issue.
a.
Begin forwarded message:
4
3
Hello All,
The Board approved the proposed Telnic solution to WHOIS at its meeting
last week.
The solution is documented at:
http://www.icann.org/tlds/agreements/tel/telnic-proposed-app-s-20nov2007
.pdf
I thought it would be useful to summarise some of the key components.
(1) Telnic distinguishes between "Legal Persons" and "Natural Persons".
(2) A Natural Person may opt-out of the disclosure of their personal
information to the general public.
(3) If a Natural Person chooses to opt-out, the following information
will be disclosed to the general public:
Domain Name, Domain ID, Sponsoring Registrar,
Sponsoring Registrar IANA ID, Domain Status, Registrant ID, Registrant
Name, Name Server, created by registrar,
last updated by registrar, domain registration date, domain expiration
date, and domain last updated date.
(4) There is a "Special Access Service" for those that require the
personal information of a Natural Person.
Requestors must be able to demonstrate a legitimate need for access to
such personal information.
(5) To access the "Special Access Service", a requestor needs only to
fill-in an online form once.
The requestor will be required to submit their Company Name, Contact
Name, Address (street address, city, state, postal code, and country),
Email Address and Telephone Number. To confirm that the requestor is a
verifiable person or company a personal identification number and a URL
link will be mailed or sent by courier to the postal address provided by
the requestor. The cost of such courier service will be at the
requestor's expense.
The link that was sent to the requestor will take them to a secure
Special Access Service activation page. The
requestor will then enter their personal identification number in order
to activate their Special Access Service
account. Upon activation, a user name and password will be sent to the
email address provided by the requestor
above. The user name and password provided to the requestor will be used
to access the Special Access Service,
subject to the terms and conditions being met for each new request.
After logging into the Special Access Service, the requestor will
complete an information request form indicating
the domain name about which additional information is requested, and
they will be required to demonstrate a
legitimate need to access this additional information by selecting the
reason such access is requested from a drop
down menu. If the appropriate reason is not listed in the drop down
menu, the requestor must select "Other" and
specify the reason. The requestor will also be required to agree (via a
click through agreement) to accept the terms
and conditions of access, which specify the following:
(i) they have a legitimate reason for accessing the
information,
(ii) they will not use the data for marketing purposes, spamming,
data-mining, or unlawful purposes,
(
iii) they will not share information derived from the Special Access
Service with any individual or entity that is not bound by the terms of
the Special Access Service except as necessary to accomplish the
specified, legitimate purpose
(iv) they will not share their user name and password with any
unauthorised third parties,
(v) they understand and acknowledge that they will be accessing personal
information, and
(vi) they understand and
acknowledge that the Registry Operator records information about all
searches of the Special Access Service
(including the reason for such search). To prevent data-mining and
other forms of bulk data access, each Special Access Service request
will be limited to five (5) queries per twenty four (24) hours.
Regards,
Bruce Tonkin
1
0
Please see attached Topic List distributed to the IDNC list.
Highlights:
2. Mechanism for the selection of an IDN ccTLD string in the fast track
o What are the requirements regarding the status of the script/language in the
territory to be used in the IDN ccTLD string?
o Is there a limit to the number of scripts per territory to be used as an IDN
ccTLD under the fast track approach? Should it be limited to one (1) per
territory or some other number?
o Who should be able to propose a string for the territory?
o Who is required to endorse a string once proposed?
o What are the criteria for such a string to be acceptable under the fast
track (for example: meaningful representation in a selected script of the name
of the territory or recognized abbreviation as listed on ISO 3166 -1)
o Will a proposed string be ¡¥evaluated¡Š against criteria? If so, who will
the ¡¥evaluator¡Š be and who will appoint them?
o Assuming a string and script are selected in accordance with proposed
criteria, should there be an objection procedure? If so, who should be
eligible to object? On what grounds? What is the impact of an
objection (for example non-eligibility under fast track)?
3. Mechanism to designate an IDN ccTLD manager.
o Should any criteria specific to IDNs be taken into consideration for the
designation of an IDN ccTLD manager?
o Are there any specific requirements regarding the technical and operational
readiness of the eligible IDN ccTLD manager?
o Should there be a proven track record for running a TLD operationally?
o Should the eligible entity have experience (operationally or experimentally)
with running IDN in the relevant script at the second and /or higher levels?
o Should adherence to the IDNA protocol and related requirements be ensured?
How should this be ensured?
o Is the registration policy of the IDN ccTLD relevant in relation to the IDNA
protocols and related requirements? If so how is adherence to such required
policy ensured?
There is also a draft schedule in the doc.
Edmon
begin 666 Topic list fast track v6 clean.pdf
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M,XB #5)BX&7Z(>W,(]L`=(9X@Y9W19!C&1NKZCL!B81I[ _D&CY);X!8"51?
MT@>DF8#8&HB!IC?[`6E&(/X.$& `56 D^0T*96YD<W1R96%M#65N9&]B:@TR
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M(# @," P(# @," P(# @," P(#4Y.2 V,S((a)-3(W(#8R.2 U.30@,S@R(#8R
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MB_"'CUW$\JA(a)^]/-NSN3L=+8&Q$S97.SB<(HBE*V+V_H*L;5\\U7OF_/.M@D
M8<9+5FO3LT/;L8^-[K6LV=_5N>UZUC9,-WW75D/9!YLTW'$=B##E^/WC_2=6
MEON_W+.AJ53'#A(A^DZ6WUGPS_TO-Q';B#".MFQ_CVMZ-[V6LV#_+W]/T"UW
MN&PZ7&;_2X0XB7^OQLOH(:2=NK3_I]!3WL*%_H<];7]4K#S*KE?=K?UR'KHS
M/2_B4.RV0(YBT_."GO_*6Z-8>V!]D *P8[")PX0K`N&.??G M&%]:],6(A1B
M\7@\O=ZASBKUI.KVS&13L8Y0#K;AE@/="!%9&R1AS)L@#@ON<-S$29@@UT7*
M%$U,<7TY#TH:_5 K=E)!3A&/;65PE?+;@)[E3-NS'^A-6\YDD.$]29CS%R"
M0]BT! XAW3?VW [V?DU/I+QBJJ&''ER>19A<IKD9+^D\. F!E3NP8H U,BG(
M$)W*>NLR+,(L^P'Q)5-UPR3K]4G5+^PD(a)RUO&I30HY.%N^P2';HJIRL*06C;
M,"?DAA0#RLB&0;(N\1T21XIFZ)1Q_&B;'ICQ9E X\@X`N,QW8>Y3WXRG="]+
M=^YE1I4#=4O!.]MA.RIOC(\7O!; RL;=K>@CY\SXV_+!_> ?JM%J@D\1'%3;
M[?+5,U3^U2^6I$>*LR5^-NX*-/=7JK^EBW1B5Q'&A85O`F]JQLCCCY#2LA0Z
M0?BE7/>J`C= V&8X/0#%]@"@6$/T!:TVI;_HP46P#.$+JKC]<7!?#?MHO]X[
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M`K+P$L_F9&1S##8'9&U(:6*S+\4VS,6*>Y.PV-3X9(+F6X!#04 J"\HNC,02
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M2F:ZWG_Z_'X$S*.^F6"?4/^-@,]X3] 3`'?MZ5QK:<VO*=7":.X__0Q@6VK<
MMFQK\_Z2$9O_!R7F\:\8NY/P3?EY<)^]+5)BYS99/6F<^="UI\EBQ)NZ1IGU
MJCPVNL0R`&4Y#5@,7CQ;\F+U['P6]S -6F#:6966=;-61^'NA\F=!,9BS#40
M)@[W<I1I8&M>K_08Y#<#:0_O[.5NZ#J\&864,(D2.KIT&<STT>[2D,?4"?Q*
MU>I1VJF9)D;R]L:.1) )[P^3-XN4@KV^P) TKQQPI"#TM^WL[A)0/UD5QO H
MH0'*]31D$3]@DPFHH3!EQ'9MB?%[S"='$]GU:2IV2D%UTP==0L>Q(#7:G R3
MG1I%IOJ)N6KZ2*]M6VX@I47NYSG2A*I1M0>V2+;7MB7/0S59MN\UOW*:WDL7
M-HO5\#&]/_)]`7G\1@.YC1-C;*K;YV_!>S\"-(11-1NMN/0#[TCQE,;\&.7C
M!@=;BHS&'*,?&PRB`+P@E;0C;HH1UT._S:_V3>0VTS&YDVSD(^H\GSL9SQU.
MV"/46N_>G.XN7T4.(O7)`8N1KFK+@5H/XYV'-8E6+)DH'_L>MW9",Q4"89 R
MO8V%&:\TOK+I;EF8W?H$7[G=.5,W[&QI]7K6=4"+B5TW@6:CW(QI)^,'&G&3
M:6F!DUR=B#8+(F-]LQ.*LIO?8@3UYXO_FP#.#8#JER6:#T_7(S[Q(KEL]@N?
MW8O=;6Y]CY* $KINB_+[$!WK/! *$ G48$IM5=KU])C[!;,='O&"F!\!>[,>
M&CMHT9-L2CM7TOCNR+?HM(L)>^P4VV*N@K:@P$TV6*EL(#O&P:3[,5JVFACF
MG=$M1?RH;*-#-T@[9%5I(C*\9%S*TMTK*XB#WQXC'*4[=M*=A.(5YQEAOW-
M&]8`$D60)-RR" 0",J723W: 8R)CO\AFD-U+.-IU.NV;8LSMLK%HW4C2N3JO
MM5NR=F?;;NL>(;;7Q&KGJ.DU#13CKC 8EP/4\S1/]]! ;#2CG[^"BZO&T-D]
MKM*F'(RQBMJ\[LMK'?<6-S7#M+V1]Q _CKJT>G=T.1T@5&[4<"<M1N<IPNUJ
MJ)VW-%^\@X9Q(32.@_&EZN3!`@89Q9Q/(?(PSZXM55ZD03$0K',;U;GM^C!D
M?V[)#"$@;G0;FPQE?&W=$>GHZ;W4-8 WY5%50ZWL[(a)/GLJ.SE>74R;+?J:(W
M3#UZBS/\@N:8`"ZMV4U(<*&_7K/2V27)<E8F";G3KM0'"?[UF&^^K^>A!/7,
M7^.[O[F"*K:X<\9^2&3-_=B7A<B/TM+;I2//]WE+S>V6>L>^?" )!,<KY=B"
M6_F*TY.!)+9 W,HYO&?.GRCJ^XD6EZM4LV?B,X(S6F-_%_%KZNL[P<%J4'LY
MXGO2:(25"M?Z9"<%W3OB]4'$<4:S; C0M+@NR7'ACUDQK)^8+G6#D;24S9,T
MQOG9R$'A)P(7[&)Z*2Z-0SY@;PP*&@>7I+TZ1?QI?_,?`08`N:L,) H-"F5N
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MUFUT1D]%G2ZN8ZT.UGWJT(a)/U,.KH.+06UXZ=%SA'G4YGIM/O'^_W.?=W[^_=
MW[WWG?,`H">EJK75, L`C=:@STJ,Q185%&*D"0`#"B "$0`R>:TN+3LA!^"2
MQDNP6MP)_(N>7@>0:;TB3,K ,/#_B2W7Z0T`0!DX!RB4M7*<.W&NJC?H3/89
MG'FEE2:&41/K\01QMC2Q:IZ]YWSF.=K$"HU6@;,I9YU"HS#Q:9Q7UQF5.".I
M.'?5J97U.%_%V:7*J%'C_-P4JU'*:@% Z2:[02DOQ]D/9[H^)TN"\P(`R'35
M.USZ#AN4#0;3I235ND:]6E5NP-SE'I@H-%2,)2GKJY0&@S!#)J^4Z168I%JC
MDVD;`9B_\YPXIMIB>):'!P4)_']$[A?JOF[]0IM[.TY/,N9Y!_ MO;3_G
M5ST*@'@6K\WZM[;2+0",KP3 \N9;F\O[`##QOAV^^,Y]^*9Y*3<8=&&^OO7U
M]3YJI=S'5- W^I\.OT#OO,_'=-R;\F!QRC*9L<J F>HFKZZJ-NJQ6IU,KL2$
M/QWB7QWX\WEX9RG+E'JE%H_(PZ=,K57A[=8JU 9UM193:_]3$W]EV$\T/]>X
MN&.O`:_8![ N\@#RMPL`Y=(`4K0-WX'>]"V5D@<R\#7?X=[\W,\)^O=3X3[3
MHU:MFHN39.5@<J.^;G[/]%D"`J ")N !*V /G($[$ )_$ +"032(!\D@'>2
M`K 4R$$YT `]J <MH!UT@1ZP'FP"PV [& .[P7YP$(R#C\$)\$=P'GP)KH%;
M8!),@X=@!CP%KR ((D$,B M900Z0*^0%^4-B*!**AU*A+*@`*H%4D!8R0BW0
M"J@'ZH>&H1W0;NCWT%'H!'0.N@1]!4U!#Z#OH)<P`M-A'FP'N\&^L!B.@5/@
M''@)K()KX":X$UX'#\&C\#[X,'P"/@]?@R?AA_ L`A :PD<<$2$B1B1(.E*(
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M&L (2 AH"S@2\&V@5Z R<%O(a)GX.X06E!JX).!OTC."18'[P_^$&(2TA)R'LA
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MYX=>>>\7:T5KA];^N*YLW41?<-^V]<3UVO77-T1MV-7/[F_JO[LQ;>/A`6R@
M>^#[3<6;S@T&#F[?3-ULW#PYE/I/`*0!6_Z8N)DDF9"9_)IHFM6;0INOG!R<
MB9SWG62=TIY GJZ?'9^+G_J@::#8H4>AMJ(FHI:C!J-VH^:D5J3'I3BEJ:8:
MIHNF_:=NI^"H4JC$J3>IJ:H<JH^K`JMUJ^FL7*S0K42MN*XMKJ&O%J^+L "P
M=;#JL6"QUK)+LL*S.+.NM"6TG+43M8JV`;9YMO"W:+?@N%FXT;E*N<*Z.[JU
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M.K_^`(*$TOA=9MR0]>?Z*3B"A%^'<HP9*GS%+!>"#$F%\CMF*S6S(!T;`V4'
M@C [+7:386#"0.AK:"6",-Q6PTP'D\6IA?9'(1[8#%:\W[XL%8(,'PCQGSN<
MN&..[P'H/]B"("S(`V%TW_03$73!IQ#IO@0/4;?@'M<KO'1<Z6-OA@>SQBVX
M"E67F R&U ?MQ_7LF6%R. @ZC<N+X#+8#/=()H-=HT'345$?3>"&P26!2$+W
MK4:,"(G8$0N"(Q0<8^@;!:_Z8_LMK5MPK9G7N2SA7$K=LP3YH1JW[[NHF]D(
M1QA3*"AO.+'P>NVAKV1'UBPN:QK2I-5_C'J_Y,I@0TJN3Z1#T+>YK PV3]!?
MCSL)+9%C`SIG'DD!%4X5V)TSI /0`!K %_B\`(@`9C-)I"(TO&<BI->2L.)
M2QFL#L*6`[2X,Y\PX4!CMU/2$6A4#SI"I0:IF#P12\5TDX!<H5"FZY1)(C#<
M%!8[$KRZ!CIX@'?L2%0FC4)'HO":#,58:52T]&?Q?W\#KG5]SYS!05BNQ?#<
MRYDN%W)*`NZ:9XG$$E?@3NZN6OY>?^^)Y[5M>>W'HL-WG7[D]=Z(^S<JGGGU
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M2$6ZEE[#[G1(@+$0:/!LB8C.:TFJ+HG.Y1CIAQX\LB<@A*+@@E@04%@-)
M@F@@!FF$R6DG(85>'GJ#A<@R4(3=!O*CI'S4B[;G"I@96JD`]:<%3P%OHH$T
MP]*C[#:I'^K3<Q0>&CS+:K=E20>C@;2&)0SH=:^ '.W.;K<OYOEOF(<'#%ZO
M(C?#&X%Z3Z:;P4 :*DX.W9SU]YL!!Y];B^1JWA-[>&Z+9*!V4U3,E=/FO\JZ
ML+?:JCKQ;[1"L)]][(.'QQS6REO'O]@>CJZ.RIRU9\N,T)Q5C5<+ON=<^Z&]
MZG$]_S>;/D^8Y[CZDWV*>K;=5Z-<&' 6OQ /..VCUUM6Q/GP0P6W@[X&2V(_
M,,[E' L9U*FIWE:=6G4V094YVEUTQTNFWVUN3%1NB)=N[&A;WI%Q1+1YX\$P
M=<N#97=90XKN!<1M^6EK^ER.U7AWD:!LU+GV0!_R`'?LE\,/WFQ>FGMD?_:N
M];K@;_DYLWY:4%B^+9NW=<+3+F=09^G[AQ^,][F5:0A):]T9EW5%\,G4H_.M
MJ?VWC_: A;S1S;F(NCGGNJ/SMH#-1!&43[_ZLMDL)J<&=971$H/M*D'GE/@5
M5?WMA*++O/+^J..V^!_Y[O6F_T(AN3G,!OA5B ;13-@,QG/V`%2(TE]^O5]V
M_5E,CQ($1AM">&PN"LESQZ)N=DP?#(\V=;-#H'I(35C),#-%.<BXR,A_41CK
MW:Q]+C>K06<F2&#"G12139@,% Z([H*ADPTGZ:IQXMFX$[>9<!$PV+(`09$@
MCX0P$I"4DS!1ED(>F6><CILH0-E%@#+CH/<07OJEZR7=:3!1=$.$K8G"K;B-
M`L,ADS >I$G2`*D$A8OD&PB+P6BAF;SJK7<#P$#%\=ZTT7B:M5)LA6X@#L 5
MQ$X\-P\G*7+LJSB[DP>A+X"OQE0$HF2QT3",!M@AY?DX5*39\VR4`;+2$WB!
M"(80Q(Y 1T3S,K1RB',4.HD<,T4W26EL;,QK[@"06RQ 0R-(^$-$PIZ,9TF
M0JG1R3$5;Z)<HY&K=)A2"Y(PK2)5CJ4IDX!<E=2G#Z=B:1ALPQ(>C59AJI0X
MH!NG!!E:)5 GPU=,V^T.2\84<IT20%&KTV *7>HDH,U('*]4Z(!.39OP]$H-
M!O]8J?K@,;4*I&OD"AVF4$([Z"!-J=)!VO02F%:;`=?[!_-5'A;%D<5?577/
MX*"B(!Y@M!414,,.'GB(a)1([AD%-&4$1=AE,4&.4*")AQ1!=0.3P31!'/)1B%
M)"B:*$)6U!575XQKB)J("BZK?B3Q-DSG#0JX[.[W[5_[;;_IF:GJ>E7O]WM'
M50M.@?,\_ +0%EF7D<HN!(*GC[^WYUN;%0O\`Q1*I="#"DGP=?$.=-7/TM,K
M0[M]% $N'MCL0ND7(+AYSO/5J[OA?R?!WPEM= GT=@H0_ ,#_/V4B@F=B\SW
M]/86?/WFR9P5G21Y*SH57/Q\E8JY@6B\IY/W!%3Q]9SG&?16I\M8/T05(+@Z
M^3BY*Y2V(a)E*AD.EQZO<+_1RN"ASEK42F7=28^_'H,G54[UB,CDG$LA 9(<2K
MX_5A%143&:%\DPA.29@98<F80++(5-3O#.X456QRI)"X5(5Q$*].$L(BA7 U
M/HKHG$25**C"PY,3WF1@E#HAKC-G9"EOMAL<@9&JM\#3R5:VSUXS^;])\Z[^
M6'6TVC8Z)DJ^YJB^D@C<FD-RC5PC,0Q=[T'6OU 0*2'882TQP*K"\UA!!P__
MC_,C2?*P[I%4'B0W'=RK'LKQL$+,9G5U6B5V,AO3LQ-WUQ0A-D859BO$)F$N
M_//I$CHO^>!W*ITY9R"78+7#3Z]SC_ZDMLU[;UI(a)4]*B#99U!X7VV.HOTMW2
M=Y>L.KE2XF%J'-FPV.;%7(><E95/!DU+;<H_8JBQ+UCLL>,L3),I:V9/%7--
MK.+ ??)S#V_;A)_K&U=WN*I'Y_]U<\G=K8]:1;A0]SAA^'?%+/Y8;7CZQ%17
MA]WK<E]GK9]J;=MZ<-I4QY.__J*UL--RH[$&CT#H\N3_P?[Q;PZ#?24&;TBA
M/ ][UAR6#^MFJ0^S>W=CX?",T=,RM.NU[<A']BAR=L;<`/X/B1,;?"JJ+[8]
M.QQ_KM\QN?\[P_O:.<MG[QFJ&0Q*2(,X" ,UQ((`4?@;#TFE8S2C]='T-ICB
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MVMP0R\VW]CV5&SN7KA[ME]7'X]>3]CL=OOZTT;=E8WFBOJ@1[A(I`!Z +^(G
M8=/RS2_;`U'4N"_C>4*)5$)Y*?2Z?-3Q:IC=+K2+_$:=&YED8$CJ--U/^<5@
MQWO#2+R'LZU@#B#>>7O?TP6+C_CE8*%;)MZT,L+!7[Z]WUPJL(0E8 -SH [:
MX309!_YP1KP"X;" ?@CO8W\^'(<S<!M<(0(HF)$,$,1BV AC82WL@>F<F5@%
MWO# P @&PQB80=0@`5.(AMWD)GB"%\[A`.Z0`PGX/1?[GY-I^(2 #!;CZEMA
M)YR&O\ /, QGM(7KZ/KGXE?@@A4E'-+A!-SFG?D-8 *%< C*H!;N$UNRG[2Q
MQV*5V"#^`[5LP [L(02K3QALAE(<=P@N4@NV3S03T\4_BN=A.%I?CJAKX2RN
M]8P()(B$TX,L3?=*C!?+D8>^:#-:C^*$:'PA"0[(a)R.OPFO1!T5*!?D##=0/%
M(2"%D5CAQJ-]@5CQ5D,V;$(415 "1^$!^8 L)9?(8]J/:F@-[R_UE?KVJ>GX
M5G07G^$:?6$46CL?ED,J:FZ&+; =-4MQK3^AM$,'L2<.Q)%XD@"23]:3`^0%
M'4^_IZ]9?V;$)K!@%LHR6#-[:<!W^.EVZ*Z(_F(J<DF0<QEZT@5QSH-%L (2
MX4/(``U:EX=2@.R5HU0@GS4HW\ MN(O2`@_@(<8<CQAE9!R*',6!S"9S2"#Y
M/8DFB60'.4:JR6EREK21)W0RM:?3J1\-H-%T!4VB!;2"5M(:>H_^(a)E;.8 J6
MR#YBY:R.G6=761,'W!Q.Q<5PR=Q6KH+[EFOGGG Z'G@+%%M>Q>_IV*OSTH6(
M8T4',4S<)!:@/$".1R":L6"%>/S1J^&XHT0CJA6P$B4-N5N'B+;#;N1.S]XQ
MJ(:O,4KKT+_U< 6:$-\M:(;G\!+)T>,S):/(^\0.^9U%W%$6HI]22 ;1D#Q2
MA#Q7DBJ4,^0FHM0APB :3)?0%)I!-]$=="<]0<_0Z^(a))D4G0$T.9._-B\UD(
M6\*2V';V,?N$[68EK)J=8?4<Y69P_EP"MY8KX/9R1[ES7"-WDY?S#GPN2@5?
MQ9_B6R3&$G/)9(E24BV5&*09M!KHX LX!Y50U3OW23890"KA,]+*.*:A#70!
M-:37B9:[3*S0`S,)\'FXV_Z,%KY'KM*I9#X+)PN1/RV)(B&PBPUG>]D<:.#C
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MN/CD[\)-N,;=(a)#WXU$CH.^=3W'O?P"?-7GC,E>)^"N-S9-+;T]/])4]79T=[
MV[:M6UI;-C<WN1M=#?7/U3D=F]2-=L6VH7:]M:;:4E6YKF*MN=RTIJRTI-A8
M)$NB0<"W5F@,JGU1A3JC5'"J.W>ZF:S&4!%;H8A2!55]JWVH$M7=E-6>7O0\
M^ 5/;][3N^Q)3(H'/.Y&):@J]*. JF3)OJ$(\N<#JJ;0^SK?K_."4Q=*4;#;
M,4()6L8""B51)4C[CH^E@M$`]I<I-OI5?]+H;H2,L1C98N1HE3J9(57=1&>X
MJF!GA@.Y%*NB-6H@2*O5`"N!\HY(a);)0.#D6"`:O=KKD;*?$GU#@%M9>N<>DN
MX-?34-%/)3V-,LYN!\XIF<;YU&M9$\2CKI)1=31V($+YF,9RE+LP;X!6??..
MY:F(G9O]D;,KK58^%;2,*TQ,I<XJ]*VAR$JKG;6:AGU@+.?HBZ;Z,/5K.(JA
ML(+9N#-:A)(SF%)A=\+N*G]_237(--%#"BU2>]6QU*$HSDU-BL+PE'VVIL8[
ME[L)-4$E-1)1[;3'JFJQP/I,!:2&IRY7>Y7JU19W8\94GA_83-F:`E-2NI))
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MG9D0*:&"`_^BOJA'LY*,JU+7$*6/FJ([\ZUFM-O_RZ!L[A,6I9.G884R::=K
MM=RU2EY57DF*QX(%)Q<:V9=*&5?:@ V:7/RD&]N]3]Y[W"0?U8=QY75-^ A/
M579]#OAJAYB!.X8K$!,`',(H#(DSL$/L@)W\:>A$VPC"C;;7T>9 _R,%^CK7
MD<NA?A?B$T0C(HQ0$'&$AMB-^!9BB.N ]Q'G,-;#XAGEST.$\8;?0(5A+VQ$
M:A;N0HUP&^I$*^P4KH.*.B?FWV(H@0'D'8:34"'5LIC<GU'>+3K0YZ]8P\O@
M%#Z$=HSM,IR!2JQ]!]K:#?70*Q[ ?+>A$OOYF?@G<@CI+D,`=9![( #_!^Q[
M!.N80O3Q#R&(L<\++MC![\+[NPYN[J?@1QI$^SI$B_ CO"<7/(<\J[\->0WI
M./H,8*P+[3MP/'U8ZR#_*>Q'VHS][N=_!]?)#^ 2T@7TWRH\@K7D<SVOA^!L
M8<QV'"L019@31;(9Z=\0C^2]4"_=A1#V_^(2Y;? 039V>,*/%\9T"N,/8AX?
M_W,X5!ACADTLEPQP3[C.=<B0.X_WKH@7<,Y/@AO'YBO27?)='*L!'1<@AK2?
M`?MK1[0AN@KH-%PA1D0QVL,H[Q*'(<$@V: 58YLPUPA;&VC;C'7J*-2_NU"_
M3K'.9AQ7WU*\N L:,,;%FR&\`K",A_B^\1"_<W1*+F',,8SOYEKP.^@D]W8>
MX.?-N3=X,_=BGH**_'=TBK'D$JSWK0,S5X<_)^>$"5*)N^.K>ON"WO;H;3-K
MN>;99ILMRS7-OL5(XVQM/9)-WN);-;:6.K/-4\?D*F_7X7K;S9EJVRW$>W6M
MME<]K;;3B&;$<9297]U,O6VB;N+K$]^;."NT064ESK*Y7/9FR>U?[JDHJBAJ
M2V?)K[T=4OI74OJRE/Z:E!Z5TE^6TGU2>KN4;I+2+BGMD-*;I K9+)OD,KE$
M-LJR+,J"S,D@5V1S-[TNMODK1!,CHL!:0>=-'&O91L<G`4=D#K_NZ%H^Q(7"
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MID>>?M.B!WH\BQZ&ELWV<GNY`QM<V_!8X><?>PWP#SQQYO53[CIW`Y]]Q6"?
M`YY<\98525!3*E:7E#ZPLVY=`W=,]Z"G_W[+9E(AJAN=V[9NW]):R=U8N/CF
MPL*;%Q<X7YXNZ*=CZ__93_L?^['+"*\LO[]\._\$`[:*UJ"4YP7DIPN\B/R/
MT0I"$4I/X/T"3V #F2GP')21WQ9X'O4+!5Y _F&!%V$#9QZ9FDP>C"62RKO*
MR%A2Z9\X,G$458I_XJ7)B9=B1\<GCBB3AQ--2B!V-/8?G)I99TIXXO QIOFG
MBA4\\X#Z#"TM#72!A)&>@F-.CD)09GI&2;%"4&IQ:E%9:HJ78X"/OX]V<&5N
M4GZ.;PA^+D,(0R5#`4,J0QI#(D,RD%9@6 G$(0P98+8O0SY#'A"70%4I,#@#
M>45 -HA,!(IG@E4H`$5R@/KU@"P7L'@BA2;IPUVFP! ,E,EA*(6K*0:*>0)I
MB'V&#)9 :,"@"V49@44=@3IR@'004$\ZT TE8%U!0/.*@;B(H0Q(I@#K,T>&
M``8?!G\@U@;:4\F0RY $MLT7:#](=3K0WAR@^XH(J*5$%I(Z#P#M8@6G1B8&
M`:#_'8"LMZS\8!&0/%,#P_$^VX1X?INO'+(<8.'%'GNL0?0FGRL/____9\?Q
MG(,;R.6&I7R ``,`7V4RS H-"F5N9'-T<F5A;0UE;F1O8FH--#$@,"!O8FH\
M/"]3=&5M5B P+T9O;G1.86UE+TI!4$Q/3"M3>6UB;VQ-5"]&;VYT4W1R971C
M:"].;W)M86PO1F]N=$9I;&4R(#0P(# @4B]&;VYT5V5I9VAT(#0P,"]&;&%G
M<R T+T1E<V-E;G0(a)+3(Q.2]&;VYT0D)O>%LP("TR,C @,3$Q,R Q,# U72]!
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M;&NE=2OR]HX77KGIYL.NS-EB/;P:*18\X>TW,<2B5D+\"C `ZE)JE H-"F5N
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M2N*B.S><R[FJ*"F!WMR/M'KT8G^A'W!S_1>59>L?'U2#)Z%NO0`IJ)%2K$CU
M2O'N0Y'OP\A?I.FTU(*+_[C>'&G41YI(I(\-!8IZ&X_JHP[%L6B1`JY_>3YV
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MR*66BY:H2ZSSJFXZXB3I!?*=I/67KLK,(A^<BGPU47D2@.6%`/RW,C^!_J7,
M@[7(<6'4EO!USO8N/.90ZE_'C[B%M";+[*FE,M_BWSV_/%3B7W#P2=/9%G5=
MZ%\`^%2;X^E@/ZBC-27RM#T?E-#!>B'^/]7691AL2,;$['M D$BN2W2?HBI)
MDG$M>[ 9D5.DBD1+(I5M)O2,^V#[G@91-$?+'*272>3YLY,[YBCB9'!DU:Z4
M(%,_Z?J;+OY.0K?9U/:YD,@H@KF_"*]:"M<N=+W,2-. O#1T`;SW2%*UU#]U
M$A/[T7)ZA:&_2SKB<#;#&HC,%&IO29JHHTIQ.$!?$T39@[Q#/N#S#_ML#F=#
MTHFFG'>YFB\GF4 8ORJS,T4)9'5H7:E'=)SJG?H./GZG@SK,T?NO5;+K>U1)
M/IZ;,]P)VHTV+#(M]7MH3?TK0YQ_*V5!WA_&KRES.E4%?W0+T#IQF06W#_(^
M1^ZJOZ%$3=JB7$]_;)KSD9+<ZXPI"?.N*U)]AEK-I1$3'4@1>HH08>B%I1^D
M-RVC]#Z=956=&]*Q[T6['^HL;1P+Y]<]B$(5`]"5\YWTD=S9$<I\J:K-SXBE
MJ)P2S2\HDDR;44EG9R(BW(J6^EQ;=,5'[I9;^@E^K)'FR<#A3ZZ#Q5CO7J,.
M1KLX9KFC+Y7LJB_80[$KN ]NI ]"%2_['ATW[Y[2S5;J)^D8B 6"O*MEQ9E6
MS+MF(LL;W.,+^#XC;-%3K)?3&B^21ED0VE)],EEO+R.VVNQFC3N)KQ2,*C+M
M$$M!HDM]V6GS+ZS(JJS*>WO@@L1^D(SJ,;OT9O!$NV)3'(KVQ36'K>'XP&$6
M_2=OU>47CBNY[5,81<&0^IX(D2/"U47""1=B7_W99GNTD>9(;2NW3;$K3<L`
M&_SCT928+6I?39EVDZ>CL,9G3WFXWA.?L@KD:TWSC1LL50K'?E)??H"-4,XB
MS]GMOLXRS!2Y?;8'!FPEZG)B:05*C_W]MEQC][SN[UKP:ZQ1J=YQ"'WFP^N^
MQ]#^JEU*$#6CLI:$,4\>)&O\&60QK#$"QU+@J;KVO!B;J5Z'@Z7<2@2R$&I2
MFB[DD[RT+) FWK".[<Y%#K*5MNENP:=,1H4>CK&3*5,^FZ8186L<MD-TXNJ9
M*Q#Y\<6,DUX.=63:<+9M3C8KS.'PTELG-^(D\94X]<QB>2"'U;+O<@,']G"
M&(L-)H7Y_*HD?32.6UUEO533/:JME (5^OCYTR//DX_]Z#)/7X'6T@DX2NDK
M@!5VO"BSPSFW[Y0YNFX1CTF^'.[E<%GQR5QU8*LAQ8.D5O(76DX#)B$C83VC
M)1_4<-5@.=75(>_NIE5V/L+%49*<0"-7S1FMMVX'#X;+_UAEYJ >L;1VO@MR
M&:8WBQI+35OUJ3H>SR5$ZG>J/RGOM]_6U='Y"MEK4I:>\%$\^(H:'?39E*TZ
MG3>'(E/F+,,AHYJ,A1L6<:1A=)?R`.BW64>;>#Z"TU"QN1RS+PO<E7V3(K5/
MX%W@":#]FX)_)=GUJ X>-3[*/N/U2 >B6F;'E+9>A"<D>FJ@4GRC7]_4X@$0
M>EV=B@R%G<HBOZTG7C,>R?G_:GB<>_DLWL&4+\,TPTS=(O\0?0ANHSH7<7M>
MB!Q/X3Q:\XT@E6J:&O V!+R!Y-1BUSL1'[S!M8)>>9.>K^2%>\8NF+%B3QX(
MV8D>^A&K!"OPJBO/#0=Y5:6WLI R'-:6D]KGTHV\H EG$V*]&(^'O??7;8.U
M.U/GU!DH7<"VH)9U5#C%KT]T>ZI.U<DE'F_6UN2D^XWCO7+*/8MO#[NR`QLS
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M-BL9`%[7D+<IYD"["ZB/QRK1-/>-Q(5*`H$56:3^J)FE'V%KP "L7F@X"<XE
M1H?9))=L/[+JT"EI3LDTU+\'F8(.;49:C3U>JW&WHRT;C(WY2OV1QY5*4/B=
MID0<%-%T1MV:1]6"=\<;W"[<$W[Y_T2<T/GHQT8)F+RYWA4-&R(:`*$)TK5.
MU4%8D[WP2,A^`(O)T7-^48%TW!@G#>%KWYD$[M:3$9>A"\!SYND@5\[>[O3)
MEP/^C:^EXDOEEZA\Q4J5>027ZM!T)?;$[B1Z*#6_8(\=[:+H=F\3VA$J5NIQ
MJYI*[:OO-(:9? 1'Z2K8(5#X$R:)6J0^-CE.AIBNN3?G;#_$`5N5<[J1:;(1
M<_%WH198B5'OV/B']=T_!1(a)`H-P.!PH-"F5N9'-T<F5A;0UE;F1O8FH--" P
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MKY*@)<$T$6AU;;"(Q2),8=TTZ_W3IMJ@^HRZ706K]L 2BE"<% )V`P")>E0]
MM4'/Q_8K.NW+!FV/+=JT,CG#!3>I<BDF\Y?VZ_/B/BJW7=T\HC(6F$9-O*28
M`-3IZ0&VOI.1FZ;N8H[SJ"[WZ*_J=&P[C.*_5Y\62PI 3*CSD*GC%'J)#[";
MMMI6;=6L*W6BF^O;*_3E(UK5!_BA?-A7<8I9A);H5+:=`B<%SG-OYWF/FFE4
M=-S"MF@D`>-,?KFYCGFD@=<[P*E:`*S/$"016A]/,<,BJF/89195&XS,*?1*
MKBE>36WKJ-\Z[ZBLWQ37F^HYH#M@B]L,*QHO4US(8B>P[;ISA54;<E2A`C,V
M[K3:U=($EUS@+%4;'V^7,YP5$YV19Y#;?:=9BN)E1D7T_EO5`%N7+,^3Z,ON
M*'^G"03N.JBFW+GN3(HY\;JNH#./B&57J9T(G!,T+)A*NX^NCH?3OH*U83'H
MB:I$&FGX9 K9@:8XY1>@5&4`YD'M'Y)\#!7T?DV\6KU?+7*.68I2EF,&0L$\
MEV6"SZPH<F#M8CO,X%!2F@\3! 6&76#P*0Q1@([<*@`E=)C(1\-A2BD6?":>
M$[ER,,X$P<G,\IR!)/SGU<9=W!QP\#SWXMI%^82+BIS*(a)X.1>H)A.&59KAE(
MT+54"8I9RD2T.I[JM:8!Q[P0OBKEX\*QK'?6# ,!AFEY[W),.^K5KJQ;,(P1
M#1Q_-*HRI@L&*2"J20;6(J,<%X@J%?0D+%0\':W@4_2Z6E>'!["EJ14,`I6,
M[]73+Q*!P_PT:*6A'MI32*\'V6KX<&Q7'?>I+!)<4)]+G ^X'(Q;,H<3#)N#
M"9;.P03+YS[!\MDF6$+["-Q/`$8/>0R'XEP:Z,'CC"*R9AA%OO\X\O8^1NCP
MEK_79(?+"8SO#T5F27O+9O*#[)SJ_X!"(_^<8% RXG> G1>W(57BCJ#"G\KF
MJ6S_G6&E/AF5HAW9^R0SH6><SS$S2=7,$S+94-CR,A@WM S%+2M#<4O*/AXP
M6?_Y"Y,=4)*#1'G:$](Y*]7T8L#(YGS<U_+JA/$JBXS)AOWU?W+4LU#F6JF\
M]CSCM*\RV8OYQ8Q;, L:AL7+(B4P5)&\_X7)L2]>$BAD=%?!"*:G%X 4T]/>
MVM5K,QHC^J%_:2L%3W3JOE)747=4D^WDL:>N+4=H:#B_L%KB$YKS'#A@`P(F
M^M0G=#!L"!V.:T('XX;0P;@A=!]7?/;BAM#^\]R/CPC-4DFL(*&Y&Q5X$FV!
M9-W,J."9R[>J/<LQ=ZJEJ69D`R\+]6&Z>ZKKD1[0W<0!.Z/J8OXU? _Z]D^=
M*J9]&QX?^_;H+@@8=S(#K%2H&[?1K9PJFGO*--YVI]4VIOLP]:K0VQ=E1IY*
MDV/-24Y"=EASK$(a)D]X.B"\>-ZF82M.S""49WX00C/)<04-X`859Z+,NPR-V8
M3GKMI;H%PHTW2GU232],Z5CU0S[<=SP6F$=;L&1PYD +4V_:>;THP^+SZ#DY
M-,W1]U6Z4()[";CX8<%-C4HL+V179UC.B"Q8F.7!N&5Y.,&P/)A@61Y,L"SO
M$T(L]Q'F64X*#%YJ+YC1-)$B&!<8HPGPROA3D..S/'5#O^ZOH:GCZ7"LN3 \
M>Z/\HM?5I%]-:$*YB>F5I)ZJ9D30A^JA_0F7B -67A1]/IZ[NGE$=5-W=;F?
ML8?$+_[DY:@J'YW:ZE2V93><$>;V<%L]H^MJOZM5_NHWO6CN%CU4E=KD4(_
M5,)G]$A%CC,GA@QZ1GT]AN-&CS,)6H_A!*/'<(+1HTM0>O02C!X'"-Q/N-0C
MY2FF7!97*Q*F>:7#K-?AYZ>'O7K_H*.W%G)QW6CEV$MJBA/C4<\V[CLN$\4`
M#G::&;- !,5<Y")R--<;++[G-=<*B 04.:&=%Q"M=)SW*'+?NQIFT?25J^HW
M7[K+P>H$)3QN0(+K_=.F.K_UJTG<N^ +BU\<^_G8?CWOCB=4CG>ASYW9)YB=
M#*_>W=XB$%N\! %%G1PM:*2$-W722X^J&]0K^6U@2-""_]/HN3=<2YU+[P;'
MA>U+U*G.D3Z=Y?H$U\!TF(:J.('_]SOY5Q;52/N'_NM1?J2F?KV92)E1WTR4
M'#TS(?"F6S@E$RXPHQ,)@N&"#]U(N\T,@$S(<IN1PR[3(8+QHQD(2ID4F=U$
M+@-#".U8<Q"0D?<0:2'K,8 PGC8#(3/</C. &"(8TW,(JLH^`@=3I_TF"C$J
MIK'%P2;X`&(Z8P#RGP`#`)B82T4*#0IE;F1S=')E86T-96YD;V)J#3@@,"!O
M8FH\/"]#<F]P0F]X6S @," V,3(@-SDR72]087)E;G0@,C(@,"!2+T-O;G1E
M;G1S(#$P(# @4B]2;W1A=&4@,"]-961I84)O>%LP(# @-C$R(#<Y,ETO4F5S
M;W5R8V5S(#D@,"!2+U1Y<&4O4&%G93X^#65N9&]B:@TY(# @;V)J/#PO0V]L
M;W)3<&%C93P\+T-S-B S,2 P(%(^/B]&;VYT/#PO5%0R(#(Y(# @4B]45#0@
M,S @,"!2/CXO4')O8U-E=%LO4$1&+U1E>'1=+T5X=$=3=&%T93P\+T=3,2 S
M-" P(%(^/CX^#65N9&]B:@TQ," P(&]B:CP\+TQE;F=T:" Y-#4O1FEL=&5R
M+T9L871E1&5C;V1E/CYS=')E86T-"DB)G)=!;YLP%,?O? H?2:6XMK$-/J;I
M6K52NVE%VJ':@:9T8TI(1<BF?OL]&PR&8!15/83DO?<W?C__;??R]HFB7X?@
M*@TNTY0ABM*W@#)$X \^%$$Q25"Z"R[7!XDV!Q,@Z+ I@R7!A!"&TDU@G@1*
M_P7AW?7C&OVX16FQRU&=O6QSM$C_! 0M*68ZYQJ>=8G)=F(FM+1*FT!@&L5&
M\SE<;>KB;U%_H.NLSB_08ADK$:ZW^\.QTE\E$>%#41:[;(L6/]/[@,580NU@
M2!CM^EAE=;$OS:A?TB#A.))(*H(%1P3SA!"J/V.E$E3EP=LP@_,(LV28(& H
M.M+@DQJ28B&[45B";9PJ@<D(a)P8U&1.#8C1IA)X%3B?F<OGU%-X&["<!^0%QR
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M(a)B0XMA#.LDOCC#$4=XLZCPK#G J+Q1IF!"-&#UGGD"B6X)!DRB$B9C +OT$$
M@S&[SD&:&(+IPD[,8K$Q0Z4/6R@>98O$"7,G/ ,$=&.SE8UN"LUZ[7QQ4Y3M
M>?)9`*,B:0>*:,."H_MCF7?=%X3XS2%@L<5LQAQ<*1S/;5%.PH0Y^JC'''[]
MEL0@X4QS\"3&3/8LNG.%<=/<V]4:9>4KVFP>G[Z>7M(a)FMK7G\.GX;HC<+"1F
M8;&@6(6EO8%]<H/KK#1^3>4EJ0\FYS>FA._TT8UC<F(a)N.D K#"*ONYSXJ;WZ
MX+2_O.(6JQL_SV'M3/2>UW?W:I]5KQX[&6<\A]^J_?O^D&TOH(4`[0+0T;!I
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M3V6.,6//H;8QJ;^!53_R*%-V;64`MT\X(Q[X(:.N=H+H/1V])]6;[R;W^.)T
M?G6%WI=)E:%*U.5Z*_.R0!Q=E<_"(C[U\),5P/]'"PPXV%RK+,+A%^*V'<P0
M0M;O\>5$[]J$APBCS$/Q61,I;R.]QRLI-[/I=+?;T3Q-BH*6U7+Z9(4X!YNX
MV$I13RMMCW'J@Q%;F2%=QNYQZV=-;%Z4SW9 5U*Y&>"O_HC+5/GH8,_S[<CQ
M'6WKAWBBLN%[-/"1X\)]R!+UP:8+<4\6JHA=XEQ'+_#](a)/JA;7+=UJ[+.N$A
M#?TNV.9J_'43M:\6:L<=D^W355))4:&+LZM39!&5UX]61%U<6N ,KC[EQ1)]
MJ,KM9O8ZI7NC/6AZF4S3HBY[^=R5VM92F:JG>5:D)&WVUID")TU"N$L='_&(
MT0CRX451%([DPPG5?9_[E(='D@&VN/=6-EB;C88]@QZD8HX^;/-,K/-"U#/]
MS&'8_TH0?)9;:"!%DBAD_?H"X80QB[(a)TQ$_)BR&F(\,+.8V #,>E1\'@ZKX7
M@IFW$W&\>[V M5 =[UW/"ZGM&_RZ)!BT5":NY0IHRLITNP\;[59YND+J9V(1
MAE_0HT#E`D)9B^>D2)O&"JCKF,;J5*$5"&59H*2P/.BB#!6EA,>U/NDKJ<A0
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MT>/K2X#T^T Z$5#XV4 Z$7C[GX \9.7=*_E18(a)?$)&.8* [GF\TZ-W(,\F /
MYIQ.Z+6.8&W5X#5_L&;HHJZWHE8>A30(^@STH KTL[HUT*UQ3+P[,8<U]$8X
M)A2DM^]EN2I0"R4+"4R%Q Y.T#=9E2PD^;061@9]]U@K866 P!B2/.8U0;GV
MGH"*RK_D=Z_4BQAK;TV0(a)^-?R(4^_7.=?"&)]JN>:J\<&AU.C[CU?.#3P*4>
M5QP.:Y@*U)%]9#YRN5[@<.> J\& !..D^S^S!=<:M$#_#%R!TT^#FN @BZ^
MNJE*6:;E^MU)TW^^-TA=^]I@ZHG0`1K[>=B)N@C':3Z$J"V%KAM34^8KF)K2
MJTIMC*<P^H_CHQ\?SB"?Q4Q6&9;;AL*'I*@ET#G,+#APIT.'>URAX^JY\FU)
M<AV]@'L@J_SUJT;WEN&%G\>-_A89;.9%,UZ#CX]KT8"B`*GRY4H269)U<Q1"
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M]^72SGO2WOI(1C?N54N=-"#N45.M-SN4ZP6,^2/5&L(a)[B)]]4#)XNW.;ESL]
MEW.GNP5N_"/ `(D/E2 *#0IE;F1S=')E86T-96YD;V)J#3$T(# @;V)J/#PO
M3&5N9W1H(#,W,#DO1FEL=&5R+T9L871E1&5C;V1E+TQE;F=T:#$@-S4P.#X^
M<W1R96%M#0I(B;27?6P<1Q7 W^[M^:N.>[;/CMN-D]E,[.1\=MQ\V\G1G&]O
MG;.M)HZ3P&Y$I5W?G6.7N'$^B/HAB",!K?9<-6J@14#30"O40MK..:2<"PTI
M3:$4TJ8IJ$)!0D#X!U%4^ N2)N;-.SL?J$;\PXW?;][,O/F>>;,&!0#FP3@$
MH'_+MO:5726[WL6<WZ%\.CWJC4&?%@>XXRT`)98^>(#=^X^A(=17`ZCVT-BN
MT8?/3HX"!"8`*H[NVOW@T&O[VC,`]8]B_=APULN\\?O4$P"-"S"]=A@S*A<'
M&@&J&*:7#(\>>.#ARA-7,)T$*-%V[TE[]>/UQ[#^66Q3&_4>&"O96(KM+?@8
M[=G]WF@V&=O>#* OP3%\,+9G_P$<-_YT39:/[<N.?7/\R": < K'%P=%.Z<<
M@2!4!2NT<]*N& =6P9!:$PRJI27EJAI4-5G[EE^JGS&(`[NB!@/7QN#9DKVJ
MS#[ZGW;_KU\(2O:6[-7>#I9KSVF7,1P"T"[BR,]KN<!PX!$UI'Y&.8':L%I0
M3ZB@@O*78LWI/T[_8?KBM=/7X!HHEY53VB&U4>.S[2J;,;RF12 -PQ32%+(P
M!)^;R1ND. T9Z($1%!=3+C@SN?^[]0$,!S'LF0G2^MXY<F4;(QC2<!^&+/6R
M9<[<3PJ#.+FBW!H\#"[FIU%.87@&PV&X@*F7X")\"=[!`/ RR8N05SK@<7@!
MY33VE\6QXI+1PNU"D6T!];85Y[L5QS)8+%6^B'*[4H/J4QB*[<G3@J4*A_/P
M+;B*O/Q?-IS:B??U]J0V=5M),]$5WWCWIV(;UG=VK%N[9O6JE2ON:E_>UAIM
MB2Q;VMRTA"\VV**%C0OT.^]HF%]?%ZZMJ0[=7C6O\K:*\K+2DJ 64!5H%771
MME;6[?L]8GS0;6L5"TU;$4K4]Q$>$]!O"\5UAD4(a)JAO%GX,5!.RPA=I4W8':
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ML=U/ZI*X8M'97=)%8U0.."1;,_+M8#8^].<&T1+5\<#U3JGC`$(W<Q/I]6AE
MR %YW,89YQPL[VAKY8SA?N'6>0(F.F@B7&XQE@@CBE&^"4NMBOS291C=UM9:
MF6]N\I,\.2^_;*F,<1V^(E>V%[M)\Q#=FYS.LQ/8'UZ7H"E'&8OI<H$O7=(O
MG76P(!*RV9EV?;F#O&X6,V)ZY)*L)KAE8^*O\F X5B,=)1'7Q;AS)PX(`FC,
M0J55,4,/&1Q[+"Z$LMU6='"H@U#1RI G' UC^HS5369D=QK*T)M%,,0QCEH'
MK9&&7,+DUF!BLKPL4L!CY..T3.[AYJ)CL'&]+&:+,C,MRDW725J^Y=N#>%/D
M`7>*IU0>(JG1<5NQ/!H]F6V/K$BTB!6HK91:6VO71O2P#TG?JBC$HI^=)EXC
M7B5^3+Q"O$S\%_&?Q%\3WR=>(+Y'/$]\E_@.\1SQ5\1?`G1]A/';E/H%\2WB
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MH[;8$,6_XALU^RC?> "@SI0-,%%/;KENONGW;=LIV\'A'I;P1& `7V]R8"PD
M<P9LIL08Q*17*TQ_N,!Q#/2!^<ZR)AZU`1V<GR^7NB(62Q4?P*B>+UW8XHAZ
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M``5X\D9!XJ:"+E5>K4E5G=\BORX4HXV^3$M>OHJW53LW?6&Z/7ALYHOX^D\Y
MK#Y=U.3_5O(a)?UY]0#J%^&N4#E.^B'-;.J34H2[$LA>F_H3R'^GZ,W\?X-RBR
M_F]1WD1Y'.4;*,=1?HR";<+S*._]F_UJC8VJB,+G=K?=`A$)02V4Q[8K7>A:
ML%4@-UAIM[O+RS0()!9I^J L9>PNE>T"(202?Q@F_6&,F!9$FO"0D$C"[I97
M`8%22B&$-W\,\8^)&O\9$H(*;OW.O:?8K 02_QFY-]]\9^Z<F3ESYL[CV.66
M/M==;K=#VY#/!7<!.4"-E#%'!?,`O[0?`JJ!!H#KC1;=O<)<MEW8@Y'_#CR$
M/!,H!1+V6.@>^@V >V7LLZ2O2;9-5"O\B\A3@3X92XTM#SX`<SWVV5C1VR+C
M2@$^8)QM`TT76Z^@KPVPX0UPM>W?(=];XSL$=-CML@[]C+*91'_N)$I_([KL
MCW>DC]M2=L\NL_#(+C,^`,J!7\66-9 '`+8!_C/\TLYIR<>E_0:[KB67R_<Q
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M/FC<<EI[H<'KGOODO8UD#1T13!V&`@'[A]<6UH!1:L-:9[R67B+KLIS^@G=F
MY"/ C^*7*<#;MFV\5NDG8 [P*5 ,' :N`]> 7;:=;"_;S3:RO99M9V1,;/M,
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M/UI8&"@H"" ^M)"W(C6IPE455,O]"<QM364>[<2$?PGL`O8#7P,'@,- `D@"
M)X%3P&E:$ACVK* LWDFR3.<?Y,"<.A/D*S3DX>\XGP;X3F\(a)OH$./<0.Y^QX
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M>K8V#/&C8VG*[LJYB6SNT!_REP`#`) +@HP*#0IE;F1S=')E86T-96YD;V)J
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M(# @-S(R(#8V-R V-C<@-S(R(# @-34V(#<R,B W,C((a),S,S(#,X.2 W,C(@
M-C$Q(#(a)X.2 W,C(@-S(R(#4U-B P(#8V-R U-38@-C$Q(#<R,B P(#DT-" W
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1<F5F#0HQ,38-"B4E14]�H`
`
end
2
2
Hi,
Here is the report Ross spoke of in yesterday's meting. I have put a
first discussion of this on the agenda for 17 January as requested in
yesterday's meeting.
Thanks to Ross and the other members of the Inter-registrar Transfers
Prioritization WG for their efforts.
a.
Begin forwarded message:
>
>
>
2
1

Draft GNSO Council teleconference minutes 6 December 2007
by GNSO.SECRETARIAT@GNSO.ICANN.ORG Dec. 26, 2007
by GNSO.SECRETARIAT@GNSO.ICANN.ORG Dec. 26, 2007
Dec. 26, 2007
[To: council[at]gnso.icann.org]
Dear Council Members,
Attached, and in plain text below, please find the draft minutes of the
GNSO Council teleconference held on 6 December 2007.
Please let me know if you would like any changes made.
Thank you very much.
Kind regards,
Glen
--
6 December 2007
Proposed agenda and documents
List of attendees:
Philip Sheppard - Commercial & Business Users C
Mike Rodenbaugh - Commercial & Business Users C.
Bilal Beiram - Commercial & Business Users C
Greg Ruth - ISCPC
Antonio Harris - ISCPC - absent - apologies
Tony Holmes - ISCPC
Thomas Keller- Registrars - absent - apologies
Tim Ruiz - Registrars
Adrian Kinderis - Registrars - absent - apologies
Chuck Gomes - gTLD registries
Edmon Chung - gTLD registries
Jordi Iparraguirre - gTLD registries
Kristina Rosette - Intellectual Property Interests C
Ute Decker - Intellectual Property Interests C - absent - aoplogies
Cyril Chau - Intellectual Property Interests C
Robin Gross - NCUC
Norbert Klein - NCUC
Carlos Souza - NCUC
Olga Cavalli - Nominating Committee appointee
Jon Bing - Nominating Committee appointee - absent - apologies
Avri Doria - Nominating Committee appointee
16 Council Members
( 20 Votes - quorum)
ICANN Staff
Denise Michel - Vice President, Policy Development - absent - apologies
Liz Gasster - Senior Policy Officer
Dan Halloran - Deputy General Counsel
Olof Nordling - Manager, Policy Development Coordination
Tina Dam - IDN Program Director
Glen de Saint Géry - GNSO Secretariat
Craig Schwartz - Chief gTLD Registry Liaison
Patrick Jones - Registry Liaison Manager - absent excused
GNSO Council Liaisons
Suzanne Sene - GAC Liaison - absent
Alan Greenberg - ALAC Liaison - absent
Rita Rodin - ICANN Board member
Bruce Tonkin - ICANN Board member - absent - apologies
MP3 Recording
Chuck Gomes chaired the meeting.
Approval of the agenda
Avri Doria requested that the following items be added under Any Other
Business
- Travel expense letter
- IDN mailing list
Item 1: Update any Statements of Interest
Statements of Interest received from new councillors:
Carlos Souza
http://gnso.icann.org/council/soi/souza-soi-27nov07.shtml
Item 2: Item 2 - Approve Nominating Committee job description
http://gnso.icann.org/drafts/nomcom-position-03dec07.pdf
Greg Ruth, seconded by Tim Ruiz proposed that:
The GNSO Council move a motion to approve the Nominating Committee job
description as agreed upon by the Council and set forth in the document.
The motion unanimously passed by voice vote.
Decision 1: The GNSO Council moved a motion to approve the Nominating
Committee job description as agreed upon by the Council and set forth in
the document.
Item 3 - Status update on the Inter-Registrar Transfer Policy Planning Group
Olof Nordling reported in the absence of Ross Rader, who is the group
coordinator.
Background:
One of the 3 documents produced by the working group to review
inter-registrar transfers
http://gnso.icann.org/meetings/minutes-gnso-12may05.htm
was a Communication to GNSO on Policy Issues Arising from the Transfer
Review that requested an Issues Report.
At the GNSO Council meeting on Thursday, 11 October 2007, pursuant to
the Council resolution passed regarding the Registrar Transfer Policy on
20 September, 2007 that the GNSO Council form a short-term planning
group to analyse and prioritize the policy issues raised in the report
"Communication to GNSO
on Policy Issues Arising from Transfer Review" before the Council
further considers a PDP on any of the work discussed in the report."
Update:
Ross Rader was appointed as the lead/coordinator for the short-term
planning group.
The group worked on a mailing list to prioritise a list of 19 identified
issues and held one teleconference on 26 November 2007 to discuss the
ranking of the members input. The group decided to create a final report
summarizing the input on the priorities received to date. In addition to
the summary of priorities, the group also decided to include whatever
supplementary statements the members of the committee wished to have
included in the report to the Council, so as to ensure that those
comments received visibility during the Council's deliberations.
The purpose of the exercise was to prepare for additional policy
development processes (PDP), not to amend the already launched PDP. The
prioritised list could be considered as a starting point for such.
The comments should be in by Friday, 7 December, after which Ross Rader
will compile the report for Council in the week of 10 - 14 December 2007.
Item 4 - 'Whois Studies'
Chuck Gomes introduced the topic reminding Council of Part 3 of the
resolution 20071031-3 that
"Recognizes the demand for future policy development including, but not
limited to, ensuring appropriate privacy safeguards for natural persons,
lawful access to data for rights enforcement, consumer protection, law
enforcement and anti-crime purposes and will immediately initiate the
following sequential actions:
1) Council shall provide additional definition regarding the potential
data gathering and study requirements
2) staff shall provide the Council with rough cost estimates for various
components of data gathering and studies no later than February 15th, 2008
3) the Council will decide what data gathering and studies would be
pursued, and
4) staff will perform the resulting data gathering and studies and
report the results back to the Council."
Liz Gasster explained the various steps that were envisioned for the group:
1. Provide a format to solicit what studies should be undertaken
2. Distribute the format to the community for input
3. Evaluate the returned input
4. Calculate a general cost assessment based on the group's input and
have this prepared by the New Delhi meetings in February 2008.
The draft template for the WHOIS studies would be reviewed by the
Council at its meeting on 20 December 2007.
Volunteers for the group:
Liz Gasster, Senior Policy Officer from ICANN staff was designated as
the group coordinator
Steve Delbianco - CBUC
Milton Mueller - NCUC
Avri Doria - Nominating Committee appointee
The IPC and Registrar constituencies will appoint representatives.
Item 5 - IDNC and new ccTLD allocation issues discussion
a. Description of the issue
The Internationalized Domain Names Committee (IDNC) is being formed by
the ccNSO according to
charter adopted by the ccNSO and referenced in a Board resolution in Los
Angeles, in November, 2007.
The Charter of the group is to try to come up with a fast track
approach, by June 2008, for introducing IDN TLDs that would be
associated with ISO-3166 country code names. Some of the considerations
raised in the ccNSO/GAC Issues Report were that the names would not be 2
character names, but would be associated with the country codes, and not
necessarily operated by the existing ccTLD operators. The group has a
narrow responsibility to examine whether a plan could be put forward to
fast track some IDN TLDs associated with country codes until such time
as the ccNSO can develop a complete policy for IDN TLDs associated with
country codes.
b. - report on GNSO chair exchange with ccNSO chair
Currently the ccNSO charter states that there should be 2 GNSO
representatives on the IDNC.
Avri Doria reported that discussions with Chris Disspain, the ccNSO
Council chair, had not been successful in obtaining increased GNSO
representation on the group.
Chuck Gomes said Chris explained that minimising the size of the group
was to make it more effective and that 5 ccNSO members represented the 5
regions and for this reason the GAC was allowed the same number of
representatives. The aim of the group was a consensus building effort to
introduce one IDN TLD per country code where the ccTLD operators were
ready and where there was the greatest demand.
If the GNSO selects two representatives at the current meeting it would
not mean that the GNSO has given up trying to get larger representation
in the group.
Avri Doria clarified that in the charter:
- there was no commitment to one name per existing ccTLD
- there was no current guarantee that the ccNSO and GAC participation
would be restricted to 5 representatives per group
- Chris Disspain had emphasised that the allocation of names was a
ccNSO/GAC issue and the GNSO and other groups were being included for
consultation and expertise.
Chuck Gomes stated that a key question related to the allocation of
names in the name space was whether all names, not on the ISO-3166-1
list, were presumed to be in the generic name space. It was unlikely
that a new ISO list for IDN names and territories, as for the 2 letter
country codes, would be created. It thus became a fundamental issue for
the GNSO because the allocation of names in the name space was a broad
issue that required full community participation.
Tim Ruiz supported additional membership because it was as much a GNSO,
as it was ccNSO and GAC issue.
Olga Cavalli supported the idea that there could be more than one IDN
ccTLD allocated to countries where there was more than one language with
the number of characters required in that language, but anything in
excess of that qualified as a new gTLD and belonged in the 'g' space.
Norbert Klein supported the allocation of names, outside the ISO-3166
space as being a GNSO policy issue and not a technical question.
Edmon Chung viewed the allocation of the name space as a larger ICANN
issue, but was in favour of the ccNSO/GAC fast track approach for
satisfying those countries that needed IDN ccTLDs and as a means of
defining issues and providing input to a broader discussion on the
topic. Edmon likened the fast track approach to the experimental basket
used in the gTLD process. Edmon supported increased GNSO membership in
the group, or alternately having observers in addition to the 2 chosen
representatives.
Philip Sheppard, speaking as an individual, noted that:
1. Solutions were not simple and logic would not always work. Generally
Government involvement did not favour a logical process and there was no
precedent in terms of mapping the historic ISO- 3166 list into IDNs. So,
a clean extrapolation from the new gTLD process in a logical way to
predict certain outcomes was unlikely. Following the fast-track approach
of one IDN ccTLD per country would work for some countries but not for
others, because of political issues and shared multiple scripts.
2. The number of people in the group did not play such an important role
if there was no voting, as long as there were two people who could
provide regular feed back to the Council.
3. Trying to promulgate a particular view might be preempting the
discussions. However, the GNSO could perhaps state a minimal level
agreement that their current view was, that all IDNs were in the generic
name space until such time as there was an agreement or reservation
policy which could be examined.
Tim Ruiz was in agreement with Philip Sheppard and noted that the
current ccTLD space was becoming very competitive with the gTLD space.
ccTLD operators were not required to have the same agreements as the
gTLD registries with ICANN, such as mandating that only ICANN accredited
registrars be used by the registries to offer registration services.
Thought should be given to allowing the ccTLD space to expand without a
framework of documents and agreements with ICANN, and how this imbalance
effects the business of Registrars and Registries, the user and business
constituencies, in regard to other policies and rules that apply to the
domain name registrations in the gTLD space.
Chuck Gomes referred to Milton Mueller's blog posting which raised
another nuance that a new IDN gTLD would be a giveaway for country
codes, while it would cost several hundred thousand dollars to even get
a chance to play for the gTLD applicants wanting an IDN gTLD.
Avri Doria offered 3 clarifications with regard to the IDNC working
group charter:
- the charter did not mention official languages because not all
countries have an official language.
- the charter specifically stated that anything that the IDNC did, would
not set precedence for the ccNSO's PDP on the full solution for ccTLDs.
- the charter was approved by the ICANN Board, thus if the Council
wanted increased representation, back-ups or observers,it may be
appropriate to send a request to the Board asking for such consideration.
Tina Dam commented that it was interesting that the Council opened up a
specific name space discussion and referred to the workshop on IDN
policy in Lisbon attended by ccNSO, GNSO and GAC members
http://www.icann.org/meetings/lisbon/agenda-idn-wg-28mar07.htm
where there was broad agreement that from a technical standpoint IDN
TLDs were not different from gTLDs and getting some IDN TLDs deployed
for production should be beneficial to both groups.
Tina offered the following observations to address the GNSO concerns:
- The IDN ccTLDs need to be limited as well as country and territory
specific.
- There will be no delegation of ccTLDs that could be considered gTLDs.
- Any TLDs allocated in the fast track cycle would not set precedence
but would need to follow the rules and policies to be set later in the
formal ccNSO Policy Development Process.
Some sensitive points include the comparison to the initial round of new
gTLDs where there was no interaction from the country code side at that
time.
In terms of timing, there are concerns about who gets TLDs in the root
first. From the staff point of view, there is an attempt to merge the
introduction of new gTLDs to have IDN ccTLDs go into the root at more or
less the same time. In terms of contracts and fees, where the 'cs' and
the 'gs' are very different, further discussion is required.
Seeking a middle ground, with GNSO participation in the IDNC, is
important for the fast track approach to succeed.
Chuck Gomes, expanding on the 'middle ground' concept, asked if it would
be reasonable to believe that it was good for countries or territories
to have an IDN version(s), of their country code names, realizing that
in many cases it would go beyond two-characters, for use in their
country and territory and for users of the script? Could Council support
such a notion, or were there proponents for the other extreme that
everything outside of the ISO 3166-1 list belonged to the gTLD space?
Olga Cavalli commented that in her view, anything outside of the ISO
3166-1 list would be generic ('g') name space, but country names could
be in scripts other than ASCII. However, the whole name of the country
in another script, would then belong in the 'g' space.
Avri Doria, stating her personal viewpoint, believed that until such
time as a reallocation of the name space had been undertaken by ICANN,
the community as a whole, Supporting Oragnisations and Advisory
Committees, all of the name space, IDN and ASCII, was generic except for
the ISO 3166-1 two character ASCII list.
Avri totally supported the notion of a fast track approach without
waiting for the full reallocation discussion.
Tim Ruiz, as an individual Registrar, agreed with Avri and supported the
fast approach, but expressed reservations about the policies and rules
that the IDN TLDs would fall under. The current ccTLD market trends
indicated that the allocation of additional IDN TLDs would not
necessarily benefit the local people in their country. The gTLD space
versus ccTLD space was important from the GNSO’s perspective in that
consideration should be given to one of ICANN's core values, to promote
and sustain a competitive environment.
Edmon Chung, supported the fast track approach and reminded the group
that despite the broad agreement that existed from a technical
standpoint that IDN country/territory TLDs were not different from IDN
gTLDs; a clear distinction could not be made before their deployment.
Thus it would be inappropriate for the GNSO to preempt a position, but
rather be informed on the issue by the fast track approach.
Mike Rodenbaugh expressed support for the fast track approach and, while
recognizing that IDNs needed to go beyond two characters, believed that
they should not go beyond a direct reference to a country’s name.
Robin Gross supported the fast track approach and added that the GNSO
needed to be a part of the decision in scoping the name space.
Chuck Gomes proposed that a small group be formed to develop a clear
statement, for consideration by the Council if possible by the next
Council meeting on 20 December 2007, that describes the Council's
position regarding:
1. - the basis for allocating TLDs to the GNSO and ccNSO name spaces,
2. - clarification of the limited scope of the IDNC
The group would do its work on a dedicated email list and by
teleconference to develop the statement.
Volunteers for the group:
Avri Doria - Nominating Committee appointee
Olga Cavalli - Nominating Committee appointee
Edmon Chung - gTLD Registries constituency
Robin Gross - NCUC
Tim Ruiz - Registrar constituency
Tina Dam and Liz Gasster, ICANN staff, volunteered to co-ordinate the group
Kristina Rosette, seconded by Edmon Chung proposed that:
The GNSO Council submit a formal request to the ICANN Board for
increased GNSO participation on the IDNC working group as stated in the
charter that was approved by the ICANN Board
The Motion passed unanimously by voice vote
Decision 2:
The GNSO Council submit a formal request to the ICANN Board for
increased GNSO participation on the IDNC working group as stated in the
charter that was approved by the ICANN Board.
Item 6 - Choose 2 GNSO representatives on the IDNC
a. Decide on closing and halting the recording for this part of the meeting
The Council agreed to proceed with the recording of the meeting for the
selection of two GNSO representatives on the IDNC.
b. Discuss candidates and pick 2 as required by the current IDNC charter
Avri Doria reported that there were 6 candidates:
Cary Karp - gTLD Registries Constituency
Edmon Chung - gTLD Registries constituency
Avri Doria - Nominating Committee Appointee
OLga Cavalli - Nominating Committee Appointee
Charles Sha'ban - IPC
Yoav Keren - Registrar Constituency
Chuck Gomes noted certain selection criteria:
1 - good understanding of IDN issues from a technical and policy point
of view.
2 - good representation of the views of the GNSO and in particular, the
Council's views.
3 - good regional representation from key areas, such as Asia, the
Arabic world and India, where there was the greatest demand for IDN TLDs
Charles Sha'ban with technical and policy knowledge of both the gTLD and
ccTLD environments was proposed by the Intellectual Property Interests
Constituency and supported by the CBUC, Norbert Klein and Chuck Gomes.
In addition to rich exposure to Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs),
generic and country code Domain Names, and Multilingual Domain Name
issues, Charles Sha'ban is the Executive Director of the Regional office
of Abu-Ghazaleh Intellectual Property (AGIP), member of Talal
Abu-Ghazaleh Organization (TAGOrg), Director of Internet Affairs in
TAGOrg. and Founding Member and ex-board member of the Arab Internet
Names Consortium (AINC)
Edmon Chung stated that he had actively worked with IDNs since their
inception in 1999. He had followed through the policy process being
involved in ccTLD’s especially in Asia, where there was a pent-up demand
for IDNS and also being from GTLD space, understood the overlapping,
rather than the conflicting issues as well as the political
sensitivities that existed.
Edmon is an elected member of the elections committee of the Hong Kong
special administrative region, a member of the Chinese Domain Name
Consortium and was involved in developing the ICANN IDN Guidelines.
Edmon believed that his technical knowledge, policy experience,
awareness of cultural and political sensitivities of the regions that
are most eager for IDN TLD deployment, would provide a valuable
contribution to the Council's position in the IDNC.
Philip Sheppard, seconded by Bilal Beiram proposed that:
The GNSO Council approves two candidates to join the IDNC working group,
namely, Edmon Chung (gTLD registry constituency) and Charles Sha'ban
(Intellectual Property constituency) with alternates Olga Cavalli
(Nominating Committee appointee) and Cary Karp (gTLD registry constituency)
The motion unanimously passed by voice vote.
Decision 3:
The GNSO Council approved two candidates to join the IDNC working group,
namely, Edmon Chung (gTLD registry constituency) and Charles Sha'ban
(Intellectual Property constituency) with alternates Olga Cavalli
(Nominating Committee appointee) and Cary Karp (gTLD registry constituency)
Action Items:
Avri Doria proposed writing a letter to the Board, with a copy to the
ccNSO and the GAC chairs asking for expansion of the GNSO participation
in the IDNC.
Avri Doria also proposed informing the IDNC that the GNSO had selected 2
members with two alternate participants and request that the GNSO chair
be allowed to participate, at least as an observer, until such time as
there was a ruling on the Council's request for expansion of the IDNC
membership.
Item 7 - Action Item Review
http://gnso.icann.org/meetings/pending-action-list.pdf
Chuck Gomes reporting on the GNSO Council response to the GAC/ CCNSO
issues paper on IDN TLD’s, said that the group had been formed, they had
held one meeting, and were revising the statement via Google documents.
The goal was to have a rough draft before the Council by January 18, 2008.
Avri Doria proposed to work with staff on crafting a motion on proxy
voting for the next meeting on 20 December 2007.
Kristina Rosette called the Council's attention to the revised IGO
Domain Name DRP and the vote on a PDP that was scheduled at the next
meeting on 20 December, 2007.
The GNSO Secretariat reminded Council that the nomination period for
GNSO Council chair would close at 23:00 UTC and that voting would start
on Thursday 13 December 2007 and run through to 7 January 2008.
Item 8 - AOB
8.1 Travel funding
Avri Doria stated that there were two actions being undertaken:
- a letter that had almost been stabilized to Dr. Paul Twomey, the CEO
requesting funding for volunteer councillors to attend ICANN meetings
- a discussion with Doug Brent and Denise Michel on the utilization of
money that had been allocated in the 2006-2007 budget to fund
participation at intersessional meetings.
Avri proposed that both actions should proceed in parallel.
Chuck Gomes suggested that the issue be divided in two:
One, funding for India, which was a short term need, involving high
expenses and the possibility of using funds that were budgeted, not for
ICANN meetings, but for other GNSO policy work,
Two, the long term issue of funding the related travel for GNSO policy work.
Kristina Rosette noted that funding was to ensure all volunteers, who
contributed to the formation of ICANN's policy, were actually in a
position to do that without personal financial disadvantage. If ICANN
was essentially limiting participation, barring reimbursement of
reasonable travel expenses, it was inconsistent with the entire bottom
up, international, multi-stakeholder model.
Tim Ruiz, from a personal point of view, was in general agreement with
the concept of funding travel. If GNSO policy was a considerable part of
what took place at ICANN meetings then reasonable expenses should be
covered to ensure good Council representation. However, there was some
strong opposition to the concept in the Registrars Constituency.
Jordi Iparraguirre, speaking for the gTLD Registry Constituency noted
that the constituency did not oppose travel subsidisation but that the
criteria for having such support should be transparent, crystal clear,
and public.
There should be a strong case made for the need of support. The question
should be asked whether it is necessary for all participants to be
physically present at meetings.
The constituency would like to see ICANN invest more in the
constituencies and the council to provide video conferencing tools to
minimize travel and allow participation at any time and any in place in
the world.
Bilal Beiram supported Jordi, but until such time as the remote
participation via video conferencing had been developed, physical
participation was important.
Norbert Klein agreed that there were two different issues, the immediate
New Delhi meetings and the long term travel policy, and urged for the
matter to be expedited, because airline tickets increased in price
nearer the dates.
Chuck Gomes added that the issue of meeting venue for meetings was an
important issue and needed to be revisited.
Avri Doria stated that as Council Chair she would put forward the
Council position, but her personal view was that parity of treatment
with the ICANN Board and staff should be requested.
Chuck Gomes summarised, that two constituencies had noted hesitations
about a blanket request for travel funding while different personal
views were expressed in at least one of those constituencies. Almost
everybody else seemed to be supportive of requesting travel funding.
Furthermore, there might not be an immediate need for the letter to the
CEO addressing the long term issue. Actions were already underway
involving Denise Michel and Doug Brent that should be pursued for rapid
possible funding with a resolution, not later than the next Council
meeting on 20 December 2007.
Avri Doria invited Council members to inform her privately if they were
completely dependent on funding to attend the New Delhi meetings.
Chuck Gomes adjourned the GNSO Council meeting and thanked everyone for
their participation.
The meeting ended at 17:30 UTC.
Next GNSO Council teleconference will be on 20 December 2007 at 15:00 UTC.
see: Calendar
Glen de Saint Géry
GNSO Secretariat - ICANN
gnso.secretariat[at]gnso.icann.org
http://gnso.icann.org
1
0

Dec. 26, 2007
[To: council[at]gnso.icann.org]
Dear Council Members,
Attached, please find the draft minutes of the GNSO Council Open meeting
in Los Angeles held on 31 October 2007.
Please let me know if you would like any changes made.
Thank you very much.
Kind regards,
Glen
--
Glen de Saint Géry
GNSO Secretariat - ICANN
gnso.secretariat[at]gnso.icann.org
http://gnso.icann.org
1
0

GNSO Council Agenda Thursday 3 January 2008 at 21:00 UTC
by GNSO.SECRETARIAT@GNSO.ICANN.ORG Dec. 26, 2007
by GNSO.SECRETARIAT@GNSO.ICANN.ORG Dec. 26, 2007
Dec. 26, 2007
Proposed GNSO Council Agenda 3 January 2008
http://gnso.icann.org/meetings/agenda-03jan08.shtml
Coordinated Universal Time UTC 21:00 - see below for local times
(13:00 Los Angeles, 16:00 Washington DC, 21:00 London, 22:00 Brussels,
08:00 Melbourne, next day)
Avri Doria will be chairing the GNSO Council meeting
Scheduled time for meeting 120 mins.
Dial-in numbers sent individually to Council members.
Item 0: Roll call of Council members
Item 1: Update any statements of interest (5 mins)
Item 2: Review/amend agenda (5)
Item 3: Approve GNSO Council minutes (5)
- 31 October 2007
- 6 December 2007
Item 4: Update from Denise Michel on Board activities (10)
Item 5: Review/Extend timeline for Whois study suggestions (10)
Item 6: Decision on appeals note on IDNC WG (15)
http://gnso.icann.org/drafts/repsonse-to-resolution-07-89-20dec07.pdf
Item 7: Discuss memo on proxy voting and formation of Drafting Team (15)
http://gnso.icann.org/drafts/proxy-voting-issues-19dec07.pdf
Item 8: Long term Travel funding plan for Council members (15)
- Vote on letter to CEO/COO
http://gnso.icann.org/mailing-lists/archives/council/msg04353.html
Item 9: Discuss New Delhi meeting organisation (15)
Item 10: Action Items (5)
http://gnso.icann.org/meetings/pending-action-list.pdf
Item 11: AOB (5)
(13:00 Los Angeles, 16:00 Washington DC, 21:00 London, 22:00 Brussels,
08:00 Melbourne, next day)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Local time between October and March, Winter in the NORTHERN hemisphere
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reference (Coordinated Universal Time) UTC 21:00
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
California, USA (PST) UTC-8-0DST 13:00
New York/Washington DC, USA (EST) UTC-5+0DST 16:00
Buenos Aires, Argentina UTC-3+0DST 18:00
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil UTC-2+1DST 19:00
London, United Kingdom (BST) UTC+0DST 21:00
Brussels, Belgium (CEST) UTC+1+0DST 22:00
Karlsruhe, Germany (CEST) UTC+1+0DST 22:00
Barcelona, Spain (CEST) UTC+1+0DST 22:00
Oslo, Norway (CEST) UTC+1+0DST 22:00
Amman, Jordan UTC+2+0DST 23:00
Phnom Penh, Cambodia UTC+7+0DST 04:00
Hong Kong, China UTC+8+0DST 05:00
Singapore, Singapore UTC+8+0DST 05:00
Melbourne, Australia (EST) UTC+10+1DST 08:00 (next day)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
The DST starts/ends on last Sunday of March 2008, 2:00 or 3:00 local
time (with exceptions)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For other places see http://www.timeanddate.com
--
Glen de Saint Géry
GNSO Secretariat - ICANN
gnso.secretariat[at]gnso.icann.org
http://gnso.icann.org
1
0
For info:
18 December 2007
Special Meeting of the Board
The Board Agenda for the Special Meeting of the Board (as set by the
Executive Committee on 11 December 2007):
1) Approval of Minutes for 20 November 2007 Special Board Meeting -
Preliminary Report is posted publicly @
http://www.icann.org/minutes/prelim-report-20nov07.htm
2) Discussion of .TEL Contractual Amendment - Possible Board Action
3) Discussion of ICANN Strategic Plan July 2008 - June 2011
4) Update on New gTLD Process
5) Discussion of Joint Project Agreement with the NTIA
6) Discussion of ICANN Accountability and Transparency Frameworks and
Principles Document (Management Operating Principles)
7) Discussion of Supporting IPv6 in the Root Server System
8) Update on Formation of BGC's ALAC Review Working Group
9) Discussion of President/CEO's Report for November 2007
10) Discussion of President/CEO's Performance Review Goals
11) Whois Conflict of National Laws Procedure
12) Update on Czech Arbitration Court UDRP Application
13) Other Business
2
2

Dec. 24, 2007
[To: council[at]gnso.icann;org]
Dear Council Members,
AMEX travel requires a profile of each potential traveller to the New
Delhi meetings. In order to do this, would you please provide me with
the following information, OFF the Council list,
gnso.secretariat(a)gnsi.icann.org
as soon as possible to facilitate timely travelling arrangements.
Please remember, personal information should not be sent to the Council
list as it has public archives:
http://gnso.icann.org/mailing-lists/archives/council/
Business Phone number*
Cell phone number
Airline preferred
Preferred Departure City*
Departure Date/Time*
Return Date/Time*
Frequent Flyer number
Seating - 'A' Aisle, 'W' Window
Special requests
* indicates mandatory information.
Even if you will not be making use of the offer for the Delhi meetings,
please provide me with the information so that we may complete the GNSO
Council profile.
Thank you for your cooperation.
Kind regards.
Glen
--
Glen de Saint Géry
GNSO Secretariat - ICANN
gnso.secretariat[at]gnso.icann.org
http://gnso.icann.org
1
0

Update: ICANN Projects Underway to Improve Whois Accuracy
by GNSO.SECRETARIAT@GNSO.ICANN.ORG Dec. 24, 2007
by GNSO.SECRETARIAT@GNSO.ICANN.ORG Dec. 24, 2007
Dec. 24, 2007
[To: council[at]gnso.icann.org; liaison6c[at]gnso.icann.org]
[To: ga[at]gnso.icann.org; announce[at]gnso.icann.org]
[To: regional-liaisons[at]icann.org]
http://www.icann.org/announcements/announcement-2-21dec07.htm
Update: ICANN Projects Underway to Improve Whois Accuracy
21 December 2007
The following compliance projects, intended to improve Whois data
accuracy and Whois service accessibility, are underway by ICANN.
I. ICANN Commences Whois Data Accuracy Study
http://www.icann.org/announcements/announcement-2-21dec07.htm#I
II. Registrar Whois Data Reminder Policy Audit
http://www.icann.org/announcements/announcement-2-21dec07.htm#II
III. Registrar Investigation of Whois Inaccuracy Claims Audit
http://www.icann.org/announcements/announcement-2-21dec07.htm#III
IV. Whois Accessibility Study
http://www.icann.org/announcements/announcement-2-21dec07.htm#IV
I. ICANN Commences Whois Data Accuracy Study
Over the years ICANN constituencies and others have observed apparent
inaccuracies in Whois contact information provided by registrants when
registering and maintaining their domain names. In an attempt to
contribute to community discussion regarding Whois policy, ICANN has
undertaken a study of domain name Whois contact information accuracy.
With a great deal of Internet community interest behind it, ICANN
commenced this study in November 2007 by developing a sampling plan to
draw a representative sample of domain names from the gTLD name
population. In consultation with a statistician, ICANN developed an
algorithm to determine the appropriate sample population size – one that
provides acceptable accuracy and certainty levels. In the first phase of
this study, ICANN will select a sample from what is (for statistical
purposes) an infinitely large data base that will provide a measure of
accuracy to +/- 5% with a certainty of 95%. Staff will then randomly
select domain names in accordance with statistical sampling practices.
ICANN is currently defining the steps staff will take to determine the
accuracy of Whois contact information associated with each registered
domain name and address within the representative sample. It is ICANN’s
goal to ensure that staff uses practical and reasonably reliable means
to assess accuracy of each data set.
After finalizing the methodology to determine the Whois data accuracy of
each data set, staff will execute the steps for each registered domain
name within the representative sample. Staff anticipates several steps
will be necessary to determine Whois data accuracy. Therefore, staff
will conduct this study in phases. ICANN will publish status reports as
staff completes work in connection with each phase of the study. The
first report regarding this study will be published by February 2008.
II. Registrar Whois Data Reminder Policy Audit
ICANN adopted the Whois Data Reminder Policy (WDRP), through the
consensus policy process, on 27 March 2003. Partially aided by staff
audit and compliance efforts, there is a very high level of compliance
by registrars with this policy implementation. This is illustrated by
the fact that most registrar activities in compliance with this
requirement are timed to occur coincidentally with the annual ICANN
compliance audit.
The WDRP requires all Registrars to:
* present current Whois information to each registrant on an annual
basis.
* request each registrant review the information and if necessary,
make any corrections.
* remind each registrant that the provision of false Whois
information can be grounds for cancellation of their domain name.
All ICANN-accredited registrars must comply with the WDRP for
registrations they sponsor in all top-level domains for which they are
accredited.
The WDRP audit requests that all registrars respond to a survey designed
to obtain information regarding registrar compliance with the WDRP.
Additionally, ICANN request registrars to provide a sample copy of the
WDRP notice transmitted to their registrants for assessment by ICANN
staff. Staff determines whether the notice is compliant with WDRP
requirements.
ICANN transmitted the WDRP survey to ICANN-accredited registrars in
October 2007. Registrars were given until 16 November 2007 to respond
to the WDRP survey and provide a copy of their WDRP notices. ICANN will
publish its 2007 WDRP Report in February 2008. As has become tradition,
ICANN has witnessed registrar compliance with this contractual
requirement, sending the notices to registrants, within the past few weeks.
III. Registrar Investigation of Whois Inaccuracy Claims Audit
ICANN commenced an audit in November 2007 to assess registrar compliance
with Registrar Accreditation Agreement (RAA) requirements concerning the
investigation of Whois inaccuracy claims filed through ICANN’s Whois
Data Problem Report System (WDPRS).
ICANN’s WDPRS receives and tracks complaints regarding incomplete or
inaccurate Whois data entries. ICANN assesses and reports annually the
WDPRS activity and apparent level of success this tool has in improving
Whois accuracy. As a result, ICANN can make a preliminary determination
as to whether complaints of inaccuracy are routinely investigated by
registrars. This investigation is a contractual requirement.
ICANN recently transmitted Notices of Concern to registrars that
appeared to take inadequate action in response to WDPRS complaints.
Prior to sending the notices, staff analyzed complaints and complainant
follow-up correspondence. As an example, the Notices of Concern included
a sample of domain names complainants filed as of 7 July 2007 that
remained unchanged on 7 December 2007.
Staff requested registrars provide ICANN with details regarding the
steps taken to investigate the claimed inaccuracies as required by
Section 3.7.8 of the RAA. If after analyzing registrar responses ICANN
determines that registrars breached section 3.7.8 of the RAA, ICANN will
issue breach notices to those registrars not in compliance with this
requirement and who have not filed a plan to cure this failure. ICANN
will publish a report regarding the purpose, methodology and findings
concerning the Registrar Investigation of Whois Inaccuracy Claims Audit
by February 2008.
IV. Registrar Whois Accessibility Audit
Pursuant to Section 3.3.1 of the RAA, a registrar is required to
provide free port 43 Whois service, allowing the public query-based
access to up-to-date data concerning all active registered gTLD names
under the registrar’s sponsorship.
To monitor and enforce registrar compliance with port 43 Whois service
requirements, ICANN developed an application to regularly, and on an
ongoing basis, determine if registrars maintain port 43 Whois service
for public use. ICANN’s new application is being used to conduct a
Registrar Whois Accessibility Audit.
After obtaining gTLD names from VeriSign, ICANN selected up to five (5)
domain names from each unique registrar in the VeriSign Whois database.
[1] ICANN used the domain names selected to query the Whois servers of
850 registrars to determine if the registrars were providing free port
43 Whois service as required by the RAA. Responses to ICANN’s queries
were divided into five (5) categories. [2] The first query revealed that
745 registrars returned “good” responses indicating that the Whois
service for those 745 registrars was available to the public at the time
of the query. ICANN is examining the responses that were not returned
“good” and where appropriate, informing registrars of port 43 Whois
service violations. To monitor whether registrars’ port 43 Whois
services are functioning in conformance with RAA requirements, ICANN
will commence regular, weekly queries and inform registrars when port 43
Whois service violations are observed. A report regarding the Registrar
Whois Accessibility Audit will be published in February 2008.
--
Glen de Saint Géry
GNSO Secretariat - ICANN
gnso.secretariat[at]gnso.icann.org
http://gnso.icann.org
1
0