- Ccnso-council - lists.icann.org

FW: [ISTACC] Fwd: FINAL - Agreed text for IANA Service Level
by Bart Boswinkel Aug. 31, 2015

Aug. 31, 2015

Dear all, To ensure receipt, please find included Paul Kane¹s email and the SLE document, as prepared by one of the sub-working groups of the CWG-Stewardship. Apologies for cross-posting. I have also included Eberhard¹s comment. Kind regards, Bart > >-------- Original Message -------- >Subject: FINAL - Agreed text for IANA Service Level >Date: Mon, 31 Aug 2015 12:10:38 +0100 >From: Paul M Kane - CWG <paul.kane-cwg(a)icb.co.uk> >To: cwg-stewardship(a)icann.org > > > >(apologies for cross posting) > >Dear all, > >I am delighted to attach the agreed Service Level Expectation document, >containing the specifics of what ICANN/IANA has agreed to monitor and >report. > >I would like to thank the members of the working group, (Elaine Pruis, >Jeffrey >Eckhaus, Jeff Neuman, Patricio Poblete, Jay Daley, Adam Smith and >ICANN/IANA; >Kim Davies, Bernard Turcotte, Elise Gerich, David Conrad) for their >dedication >and professionalism over the past months. They contributed to over 300 >hours of >discussions, 8 full WG meetings, 15 sub-group meeting and countless >emails ... >and it is with pleasure I advise that the first phase is done. >I'd also like to thank ICANN staff for their support in facilitating the >WG >discussions. > >ICANN/IANA will now plan the scope of work to implement this SLE, >operating the >service in a test phase/parallel mode to start the necessary real-world >data >capture. > >Please circulate the agreed SLE document as you consider appropriate which >demonstrates ICANN/IANA's commitment to enhanced reporting and >transparency post >transition which I am confident will be welcomed by the global community. > >Kind regards > >Paul Kane >SLE WG Chair. > > > > Paul, with all due respect, IANA is a function, NOT an entiry (p 1 of the report) , and using the correct terminology is important, just in case it became relevant later. It's not just nit-picking. The report should have an Executive Summary. el >

1 0

Draft resolution Procedure nomination and selection ccNSO NomCom member
by Bart Boswinkel Aug. 31, 2015

Aug. 31, 2015

Dear all, Please find include a draft resolution on the Procedure for nomination and selection of the ccNSO appointee on the FY 2016 NomCom. May I suggest you express your concern, if any, to the list and/or indicate if you can support the resolution by Friday 4 September 2015. Kind regards, Bart Draft Council resolution on Appointment ccNSO Candidate on ICANN's Nominating Committee Background In November 2008 the ccNSO Council adopted the Guideline on Appointment of Delegate to the Nominating Committee. Over time the practice for the call for nominations and appointments of the candidates for the NomCom has deviated from the procedure described in the Guideline for various reasons, such as an impractical and bureaucratic nomination procedure, and related time lines. This problem and others, related to this Guideline and others, prompted the ccNSO Council to look at the issue and appointed the ccNSO Guideline Review Committee, including members from and Council and community. The Guideline for Nomcom selection are being reviewed and will, if needed, be updated and submitted to the ccNSO Council for adoption. On 10 August 2015 the secretariat sent out a call for volunteers to the ccNSO community, calling for volunteers to serve on ICANN's nominating Committee. The closing date of the call was 17 August. The ccNSO Council has been made aware that some members of the community commented on the procedure, in particular the concern about the non-conformity of the procedure with the established Guideline. Draft Resolution The ccNSO adopts the following procedure for the call for nominations and for the appointment of the ccNSO candidate on the ICANN Nominating Committee: 1. The ccNSO secretariat is requested to send out a renewed call for nominationsto ccTLD community by sending an email to the ccNSO members list and ccTLD community list. The call should include a reference to this Council resolution, and clearly state that representatives from ccTLD managers may self-nominate. This call for nominations should close one (1)week after the day it has been sent. Nominations, which have already been submitted, will remain valid and added to the set of nominations from the additional call for nominations. 2. One day after closure the secretariat will send the list of candidates and their CVs to the Council, requesting each member of Council to select one (1) candidate within a week after the secretariat submitted the list of candidates by email vote. The candidate receiving the majority of votes will be appointed. If two or more candidates receive the same number of votes, there will be additional rounds of voting, until one candidate has received a majority of the votes. The email vote is to be conducted by sending an email to Bart Boswinkel, ccNSO Senior Policy Advisor, indicating their preferred candidate. 3. After completion of the vote, the candidates, the chair of the NomCom and community will be informed accordingly. Further, the ccNSO Council requests its chair to inform the chair of the ccNSO Guideline Review Committee of the matters that have arisen in the context of the ccNSO Guideline on Appointment of delegate of the Nominating Committee, and to request the Review Committee advise Council on a practical and sustainable procedure for the nomination and selection of delegates/candidates before the next appointment to the NomCom is expected to be due (August 2016) .

1 0

Launch ICANN Community facing Beta KPI Dashboard
by Bart Boswinkel Aug. 31, 2015

Aug. 31, 2015

Dear all, Last Friday ICANN launched its community-facing Key Performance Indicator (KPI) Dashboard: see https://www.icann.org/news/blog/icann-beta-kpi-dashboard In addition ICANN's CEO and President has posted a related witten and video blog: see written blog https://www.icann.org/news/blog/icann-beta-kpi-dashboard<http://mailer.samanage.com/wf/click?upn=3sVClaOwo5uihwlrrc4Of3HJ8DZcynM49NM…> and video blog https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QrX9XW0L30o. Kind regards, Bart

1 0

CCWG - Accountability - IMPORTANT
by Chris Disspain Aug. 31, 2015

Aug. 31, 2015

Dear ccTLD colleagues, As you would all be aware, we are coming to a critical point in deliberations regarding the IANA transition and, in particular, work on accountability that will underpin the post-transition model. I am writing to implore all of you to devote whatever time and resources you have available to analysing and providing your considered views on the draft report that has been released for public comment. The CCWG on Accountability called for input <https://www.icann.org/public-comments/ccwg-accountability-2015-08-03-en> on 3 August and comments close on 12 September. To date, nine comments have been received and none of them represent the ccTLD community. The changes currently being considered are the most significant in the history of ICANN and it is critical that the voices of ccTLD managers are heard. In order to allow us to have meaningful input, I encourage you to formulate and convey your comments now and not wait until a final draft is tabled when we meet in Dublin. Whether we agree or disagree on the principles and substance of the CCWG’s work, we must participate actively in the process. To support your deliberations, I would like to draw your attention to three conference calls that will be held very shortly. The first is a CCWG meeting with advisors that will be held today (31 August) at 13:00 UTC. The second is CCWG briefing to the ICANN Board that will be held today at 22:00 UTC. The third is a CCWG/Board Dialogue that will be held between 22:00 and 01:00 UTC on 2 September These calls are open to all and information about participating via Adobe Connect are available <https://community.icann.org/display/acctcrosscomm/CCWG+on+Enhancing+ICANN+A…> on the CCWG-Accountability’s wiki page. Please try to attend these calls and become better acquainted with the most immediate points of agreement, discussion and disagreement regarding the CCWG’s proposals. If you believe you have something to say in this process, now is the time to say it! Cheers, Chris Disspain | Chief Executive Officer .au Domain Administration Ltd T: +61 3 8341 4111 | F: +61 3 8341 4112 E: ceo(a)auda.org.au <mailto:ceo@auda.org.au> | W: www.auda.org.au <http://www.auda.org.au/> auDA – Australia’s Domain Name Administrator Important Notice - This email may contain information which is confidential and/or subject to legal privilege, and is intended for the use of the named addressee only. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not use, disclose or copy any part of this email. If you have received this email by mistake, please notify the sender and delete this message immediately. Please consider the environment before printing this email.

1 0

Changes ccNSO secretariat effective 1 September 2015
by Bart Boswinkel Aug. 28, 2015

Aug. 28, 2015

Dear all, As some of you will have heard during the Buenos Aires ccNSO meeting Gabriella Schittek (Gabi) is leaving another the ccNSO secretariat. Effectively 1 September 2015 Gabi will be working for another ICANN department as Global Stakeholder Engagement Manager Central & Eastern Europe. She will therefore be no longer directly involved in ccNSO and broader ccTLD community matters, with exception of the process for the ccNSO Council Elections 2016. If ,in future, you have any queries relating to ccNSO matters please contact one of us*. Finally, please join us, in wishing Gabi all the best, and success in her new role. On behalf of the ccNSO secretariat Bart Boswinkel ccNSO senior policy advisor *Kimberly Carlson <kimberly.carlson(a)icann.org<mailto:kimberly.carlson@icann.org>> *Kristina Nordstrom <kristina.nordstrom(a)icann.org<mailto:kristina.nordstrom@icann.org>> *Bart Boswinkel <bart.boswinkel(a)icann.or<mailto:bart.boswinkel@icann.org>

4 3

36-2015: Proposal for Arabic Script Root Zone Label Generation Rules
by Gabriella Schittek Aug. 25, 2015

Aug. 25, 2015

Dear Councillors, Please, can I have your input to 36-2015: Proposal for Arabic Script Root Zone Label Generation Rules by Thursday, 27 August at the latest. Thanks! Gabi === Topic: 36-2015: Proposal for Arabic Script Root Zone Label Generation Rules Originator: ICANN Summary of request: The Arabic script community has formed the Task Force on Arabic Script IDNs, also acting as the Arabic script Generation Panel (GP), which in turn has developed a Proposal for the Arabic Script Root Zone Label Generation Rules. This proposal is now posted for public comments: https://www.icann.org/public-comments/arabic-lgr-proposal-2015-08-24-en Date received: 25 August 2015 Last day for Comments/input/response, if any: 6 October 2015 Recommended action, if any: No Action Expertise needed, if any: Lingual, Technical, Legal Impact on ccNSO/ccTLDs: Low

2 1

Reminder: Invitation to join ccTLD Webinar on CCWG 2nd Draft Proposal / 25 August 07:00 and 15:00 UTC
by Kristina Nordstrom Aug. 24, 2015

Aug. 24, 2015

Dear all, This is a reminder of the two webinars that will be held with specific ccTLD focus in order for the community to discuss the 2nd Draft Proposal of the CCWG. CCWG Co-Chair Mathieu Weill will be conducting both sessions. The webinars will be held on 25 August at 07:00 and 15:00 UTC. Please find the dial in details below: Dial in numbers: http://www.adigo.com/icann/ Conference ID: 5258 Adobe Room: https://icann.adobeconnect.com/ccnso2015/ You do not need to RSVP, you are welcome to join the webinar that is most convenient for you. If you need dial out assistance for this call, please let me know as soon as possible. Recordings of the webinar will be posted on the ccNSO website. Kind regards, Kristina

1 0

Note Pod Content from ccNSO Council
by Bart Boswinkel Aug. 24, 2015

Aug. 24, 2015

Dear all, Please find included notes from note pod Major actions: * Keith, Becky and Nigel together with secretariat draft note for ICG and Board. * Action staff: draft resolution and re-issue call ccNSO appointment to NomCom . Send Resolution to Council for adoption * Call for one more volunteer to select two candidates (Jordi already volunteered) ccNSO Council Meeting Notes 20 August 2015 - 12:00 UTC Agenda 1) Apologies 2) Minutes and Actions 3) Internet Governance 4) Update Stewardship Transition and Accountability Processes 5) Fast Track Review: next steps 6) SECIR WG 7) Discussion Meeting B Strategy: next steps 8) ccNSO Council Elections 9) Appointment ccNSO member on ICANN’s nominating committee 10) Appointment new members ccNSO SOPWG 11) Leadership training (ICANN) Dublin 12) Council Updates 13) WG updates 14) Liaison Updates Written updates 15) Work plan 16) Date of Next Meetings · 24 September 2015, noon UTC · 21 October, Dublin (Time to be determined) · 19 November, noon UTC 17) AOB 18) Adjourn Notes Council meeting 20 August 2015 1) Welcome and Roll call No Quorum Apology: Patrick Miles, Ching Chiao late, Peter vanRoste will leave after an hour Quorum at 12.15 UTC 2) Minutes and Actions Minutes BA meeting adopted, Actions completed 3) Internet Governance Young-Eum Lee provided written update 4) Update Stewardship Transition and Accountability Processes 4.1 Update ICG Keith: * ICG put out consolidated proposal end July, closure 8 September. To date 22 submission: Issues identified to date are easily addressable. * ICG has held two webinars * If ccNSO intends to submit comments closing date 8 September 2015 * Note ccNSO reservations in BA around CWG Stewardship Proposal: Inclusion of ICP-1 in list of relevant documents, IPRs related to IANA and Service Level Experience. Note with regard to IPR the ICANN Statement. * Byron: regarding ICP-1: In ISTACC call reasoanble discussion. Council sending a note on this issue. Communication on reference in Proposal, clarification on reference. How would ICG react? * Keith: ICG formally stated not to amend the proposals Also recalling Council motion on implementation of FOI. Achiving ICP-1 and GAC 2000 principles. Note to the ICG. Presentation to ICG Some ccTLDs want relevance ICG Reference in text of Propsoal. Reflects story of ICP-1. Accurate reference of what has happened. No way to deny history. Concern around list of reference documents: By inclusion in the list: it could be interpreted as still of any relevance. Proposal: letter to Board and submission ICG. Action Keith, Becky and Nigel together with secretariat draft note for ICG and Board. No objection, unanimously supported Note Nigel: reservations on use of wording "implementation of FOI”. Policies are implemented, Policy already exists, FOI is interpretation of existing policy, and hence needs to be applied. Keith: Aspects of systems, website etc. need to be changed to accommodate for FOI in existing processes FOI Advisory update: Indication IANA staff treats it with urgency. Moving froward expeditiously. Meeting 4.2 Update CWG-Stewardship Main item around SLE effort: Strong Indication SLE almost concluded Issue around ICP –1 discussed extensively. 4.3 Update CCWG -Accountability * Publication of 2nd proposal * Publication of comment tool/responses on comment 19 August * GAC members directly involved in process, stress test 18 (only take into consensus GAC Advise) Concern Becky: not all issues of concern of ccTLDs addressed Fundamental pieces are agreed upon. Goal is to have accepted in Dublin All aspects of CWG requirements are met, but no formal feed-back from CWG to date. Question Peter: timing to meet deadline. To be followed up off-line with Keith 4.4 Preparation Decision-making on CCWG Proposal See Agenda document Any thoughts on: * Overall structure Peter: support the structure and getting right people to present. No further comments * Involvement RO's Becky: Reach out RO Because of conditionality reason to involve RO, and take input on 5) Fast Track Review: next steps Work in progress, expect email vote 6) SECIR WG 6.1 Adoption Final Report Mover: Lesley Unanimously passed 6.2 Adoption of Draft charter Standing Committee Mover: Abibu Approved 7) Discussion Meeting B Strategy: next steps Discussion in Program WG. Issue when to run survey, Concern, how we need to amend working procedures. Need time to think through impact on working methods and proceses. Fulsome discussion needed with community Next meeting B will not be a usual meeting, due to transition. First B meeting is exception 8) ccNSO Council Elections Need to fill two seat in LAC region Thank you Victor for long-standing service to community and 8.1 Timeline Any questions: none Mover: Keith Approved unanimously 8.2 Appointment of Election Manager Mover: Keith Carried unanimously 9) Appointment ccNSO member on ICANN’s nominating committee Process this year is consistent with processes since 2008 Also clearly not-conssitent with process as documented in 2008 Guideline Options: Accept nomination and flag issue Redo nomination Nigel: requirement nominations/ second, Email vote Not acceptable that changes are changes not made by Council Lesley: knowingly divert from Guideline, inform Council Katrina: grown practice Council is to accept nominations Becky: Somebody was confused by process? Was that reason? Person took issue with inconsistency Given there is objection, go back to Guidelne Byron: Council has to put proces in place, What is core that is needed? Re-issue call with rules. By definition deviate from guidelines What must be contained in process: Follow continued process: extend period. Recognise that deviation from Guideline. Add another week and re-issue to call based on Council decision Action staff: draft resolution and re-issue call Resolution to Council for adoption 10) Appointment new members ccNSO SOPWG Mover: Abibu Caried unanimously 11) Leadership training (ICANN) Dublin Proposal: small group who propose candidates. Staff prepare list of criteria, + practical limitations ( no travel funding) Two Councillors to put name forward as volunteer Jordi volunteered 12) Council Updates Chair update: Received letter from chair GNSO on auction proceeds session in BA, Will send a letter together with chair of GNSO to chair of GAC on overlap between CCWG use country and territory names and GAC Working group APTLD update: I have to bow out- a quick update from APTLD: we have our Meeting on 8-9 Sep and a session on IG will be focusing on IANA Transition, with Cheryl and Paul Kane as remote commentators and Izumi Okutani doing so live.Good-bye, guys. 13) WG updates Update sto follow in minutes 14) Liaison Updates Written updates 15) Work plan Update to follow next week 16) Date of Next Meetings · 24 September 2015, noon UTC · 21 October, Dublin (Time to be determined) · 19 November, noon UTC 17) AOB Thank Gabi, last formal Council meeting in personal capacity and as chair ccNSO! 18) Adjourn Closure meeting 13.57 UTC

2 2

Chat notes and recording - ccNSO Council Call 20 August
by Kimberly Carlson Aug. 20, 2015

Aug. 20, 2015

Dear all, Here is the recording from today's Council Call: http://ftp.adigo.com/clients/icann/20150820_ccNSO_Council_Call.zip A copy of the chat notes may be found below. Kind regards, Kim Carlson Kimberly Carlson:Welcome Ron Ron Sherwood:Good morning, Kimberly Maureen Hilyard:Morning Ron and Kimberly Bart Boswinkel:Hello All Maureen Hilyard:Hi Bart Kimberly Carlson:Hello Leonid Todorov:can you hear me? Leonid Todorov:ok. will be working on the mike... sorry Thomas Rickert:Hi all! Vika:Hello all! Keith:Hello all Lesley:Hello everyone Kimberly Carlson:checking with the operator Celia Lerman:Hi there Barrack AfTLD:Hello everyone Peter Van Roste - CENTR:Hello Everyone! Kristina Nordstrom:Hi all abibu (.tz):hello everyone Barrack AfTLD:Hi Abibu Carolina Aguerre:I've just contacted DEmi and Margarita Katrina Sataki:Hello! Leonid Todorov:great r'n'b... Ching Chiao:Hi Ching Chiao here and on the conference bridge Jordi Iparraguirre:apologies for being late, trek took longer Thomas Rickert:All, we will hold a third webinar with translation services on the CCWG report on the 25th of August from 18-20 UTC. Peter Van Roste - CENTR:Very hard to hear Becky. Kristina Nordstrom:All, since we have so much noise on the line today the operator have mutet many of the phone lines. To unmute you press *7 Peter Van Roste - CENTR:Sure! Katrina Sataki:Thanks! The MPWG is already working hard :) abibu (.tz):cudu move up the agenda. Kimberly Carlson:you should have scroll control for the agenda abibu (.tz):moved. thx Kristina Nordstrom:I'd like to point out once again that we have muted many of the lines and if you need to speak please press *7 Vika:Seconded Byron:The phone line quality is very bad for me. Can it be improved? Lesley:To B or not to B! Katrina Sataki::) Kristina Nordstrom:Byron, we are trying to work on it. Many noisy lines today Barrack AfTLD:Chair, no update at the moment Peter Van Roste - CENTR:I have to go to another meeting. Only updates from CENTR: we will send in comments on both ICG and CCWG consultations. Peter Van Roste - CENTR:Bye! Vika:I second Gabi Gabi::-) Vika::-) Carolina Aguerre:Bye Peter Carolina Aguerre:Cheers Gabi :) Keith:Peter lets make contact tomorrow then... Thomas Rickert:All, I am sorry, but I need to leave now due to another commitment. Carolina Aguerre:I will have to leave to attend another call. Updates: LACTLD organized a webinar for members in SPanosh on the ICG proposal. LACTLD will send comments to the online consultation form. Carolina Aguerre:Good bye all. Lesley:When did we last vote on a NomCom appointee please? Lesley:(where there was more than one candidate) Katrina Sataki:2013, if I'm not mistaken Katrina Sataki:but there was only one, I think Lesley:Quite. When did we last have a competition for this role? Katrina Sataki:apparently this year :) Lesley:;) Lesley:Thanks for the info Bart. abibu (.tz):I suggest we maintain the status quo this year and next year follow the guidelines 100%. Lesley:I disagree, as we have recieved a complaint. Leonid Todorov:I have to bow out- a quick update from APTLD: we have our Meeting on 8-9 Sep and a session on IG will be focusing on IANA Transition, with Cheryl and Paul Kane as remote commentators and Izumi Okutani doing so live.Good-bye, guys. Vika:Guys I must leave for the next meeting unfortunately. I think we should stick to the precedent that we've used pragmatically since 2008. Let us elect straight away. I hope we'll be given an opportunity to vote in the next 24 to 48 hours so that we can meet the NomCom deadline Vika:Bye all! abibu (.tz):i move the resolution Jordi Iparraguirre:mvlunteer to join that group Jordi Iparraguirre:i volunteer abibu (.tz):Thank u Gabi..... Katrina Sataki:thanks, Gabi! Ron Sherwood:Bye everyone Jordi Iparraguirre:thanks Gabi! Keith:Now is the real test for ccNSO, can we survive without Gabi's support! Katrina Sataki:not sure about that, Keith... Gabi:Thank you! Jordi Iparraguirre:thank you, bye! Katrina Sataki:thank you, bye! Kimberly Carlson:Goodbye All Byron:Bye all Ching Chiao:Bye!

1 0

Reminder: Dial in details Council Call today 20 August 12:00 UTC
by Kristina Nordstrom Aug. 20, 2015

Aug. 20, 2015

Dear all, Thank you for indicating availability for the call. Please find a reminder of the dial in details below: The Council Call will take place today on 20 August at 12:00 UTC. Dial in numbers: http://www.adigo.com/icann/ Conference ID: 5258 Adobe Room: http://icann.adobeconnect.com/ccnsocouncil/ Two-way audio will be available in the Adobe Room. Kind regards, Kristina

3 2